Edo Nagato question

[InfiniteMugen]

Ok so I was thinking, nagato wasn't born with the rinne, mads gave him his right? And then obito took them back right? So when nagato was edo'd shouldn't he have come back with his own original eyes? Not mads' rinne? Just a thought, discuss

 

[Jiren]

I think edos return in the state they were killed.

 

[Chikombo]

I think edos return in the state they were killed.

Probbly can't think of anyone that this doesn't apply too.

 

[InfiniteMugen]

I think edos return in the state they were killed.

That would make sense, just thought it was odd both him and mads were revived with(fake?) mads eyes

 

[Jiren]

Probbly can't think of anyone that this doesn't apply too.

Madara because Kabuto made him young again.

 

[InfiniteMugen]

Probbly can't think of anyone that this doesn't apply too.

Well mads was brought back better, but I think he's a special case

 

[Jiren]

That would make sense, just thought it was odd both him and mads were revived with(fake?) mads eyes

Yeah edo tensei most certainly asspulled some things.

 

[Kakooli]

I think edos return in the state they were killed.

This.

This is the logical explanation for why Madara returned as a young man despite dying as an old one. When he used Izanagi, that counted as his first "death" and thus he was brought back in his young state.

 

[chopstickchakra]

That would make sense, just thought it was odd both him and mads were revived with(fake?) mads eyes

Madara was revived altered isn't that what Kabuto said. He made him better than his prime. Maybe implant Sharingan into an Edo sacrifice that's getting someone with rinnegan unlocked and maybe they become rinnegan due to the chakra?

 

[InfiniteMugen]

This.

This is the logical explanation for why Madara returned as a young man despite dying as an old one. When he used Izanagi, that counted as his first "death" and thus he was brought back in his young state.

Well as i stated earlier, mads was a special case and we where even shown that, not sure if kabuto did that to anyone else

 

[InfiniteMugen]

Madara was revived altered isn't that what Kabuto said. He made him better than his prime. Maybe implant Sharingan into an Edo sacrifice that's getting someone with rinnegan unlocked and maybe they become rinnegan due to the chakra?

Well it seems like(and I'll probably get flamed for this) mads didn't even know he had his rinne again until he used it. That's pure speculation on my end though

 

[Sagebee]

I think dubious is right since madara wasn't resurrected back with his rinnegan or I don't think eyes in general

 

[Amazeballs]

The same could be said for Edo Madara; his Rinnegan were originally Izuna's eyes, and Madara transferred them to Nagato before he died. Thus, Madara wasn't born with those eyes, and didn't die with them. Further, Nagato was revived in an unhealthy state (crippled and starved), while Madara was revived young and healthy (with Rinnegan). Similarly, Itachi was revived with his vision intact, whereas he died blind.

Basically, Edo Tensei is completely inconsistent. Don't think too hard about it.

Sarutobi was born the same age he died at; same goes for Chiyo.

It's unclear how Edo Madara's Hashirama face was implanted; he stated that it was Kabuto's doing, but how exactly does living tissue become part of an Edo Tensei "confetti" body? There are even numerous times that Madara's body was completely obliterated (such as by the meteor), and the Hashi-face regenerated along with the rest of his Edo body.

 

[BlacLord™]

I think edos return in the state they were killed.

That's it.

Hence why Hashirama came back with an armour plate missing on his shoulder:

You must be registered for see images

 

[BlacLord™]

The same could be said for Edo Madara; his Rinnegan were originally Izuna's eyes, and Madara transferred them to Nagato before he died. Thus, Madara wasn't born with those eyes, and didn't die with them. Further, Nagato was revived in an unhealthy state (crippled and starved), while Madara was revived young and healthy (with Rinnegan). Similarly, Itachi was revived with his vision intact, whereas he died blind.

Basically, Edo Tensei is completely inconsistent. Don't think too hard about it.

Sarutobi was born the same age he died at; same goes for Chiyo.

It's unclear how Edo Madara's Hashirama face was implanted; he stated that it was Kabuto's doing, but how exactly does living tissue become part of an Edo Tensei "confetti" body? There are even numerous times that Madara's body was completely obliterated (such as by the meteor), and the Hashi-face regenerated along with the rest of his Edo body.

It's not inconsistent at all.

Kabuto had rigged Madara's DNA before reviving him, that's all. Otherwise, they come back in the same state in which they died (or at least, the last healthy state they were in before death)

 

[InfiniteMugen]

The same could be said for Edo Madara; his Rinnegan were originally Izuna's eyes, and Madara transferred them to Nagato before he died. Thus, Madara wasn't born with those eyes, and didn't die with them. Further, Nagato was revived in an unhealthy state (crippled and starved), while Madara was revived young and healthy (with Rinnegan). Similarly, Itachi was revived with his vision intact, whereas he died blind.

Basically, Edo Tensei is completely inconsistent. Don't think too hard about it.

Sarutobi was born the same age he died at; same goes for Chiyo.

It's unclear how Edo Madara's Hashirama face was implanted; he stated that it was Kabuto's doing, but how exactly does living tissue become part of an Edo Tensei "confetti" body? There are even numerous times that Madara's body was completely obliterated (such as by the meteor), and the Hashi-face regenerated along with the rest of his Edo body.

These are really good points, I wasn't trying to think too much into it per se, it just popped in my head and I figured it'd be a nice change of pace thread. It does just seem more like inconsistencies though. Great response dude, + rep for you

 

[Kakashistomps]

Ok so I was thinking, nagato wasn't born with the rinne, mads gave him his right? And then obito took them back right? So when nagato was edo'd shouldn't he have come back with his own original eyes? Not mads' rinne? Just a thought, discuss

Nagato died with rinnegans, Obito took them after Nagato's death.....
Edo comes back in life with same shape and condition,before they die....
Except Madara,Kabuto changed him...

 

[Angelic.]

More importantly how did Kabuto even get his dna in the first place

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

Plothole detected.

 

[SusanooGodEgde]

Kabuto put some of Hashirama's cells into Madara.