The reason non-Uchiha can use Sharingan is because the chakra of the original Sharingan owner is inside it. All KKG come from the user's chakra and without it Kakashi wouldn't be able to use Kamui while Nagato wouldn't be able to use Rinnegan jutsu.
Obito's eye had Obito's chakra which allowed Kakashi to use Obito's KKG, Madara's eyes had Hagoromo's chakra which allowed Nagato to use 6Path jutsu
nope part2. It still contain DNA, not chakra. Just like tap water example, the tap does not contain water from the manufactory, it just let the water from the current place stream through it in it's own style of design.
nope part2. It still contain DNA, not chakra. Just like tap water example, the tap does not contain water from the manufactory, it just let the water from the current place stream through it in it's own style of design.
You just ignored the obvious, the eye is an organ which means it's an Uchiha's body part which means it has Uchiha DNA. Furthermore DNA determines what chakra the person can produce but in the end of the day chakra is responsible for what KKG someone can use.
The chakra Obito transferred into Kakashi gave him DMS without the need to have Sharingan eyes, the chakra in Madara's eyes have Hagoromo's chakra which gave Nagato the ability to use Hagoromo's KKG.
Hold on now...Gonna have to disagree with this a bit. The way I see it is that each sharingan(tool) has codes(jutsu). It just need a power source to use them. This is why Nagato's chibaku tensei is ass compare to madara.
To further prove this theory. We know that itachi transfer amaterasu(code) into Sasuke's sharingan(tool).
This is why I think sharingan can learn all other sharingan jutsu. You just simply need the code.
The reason why rinnegan can use nearly any jutsu is because it can see any jutsu on a profound level...on a level where the code is practiclly written out for them to copy.
Nagato can't use Rinnegan to it's full extent because he doesn't have the body to utilize Hagoromo's power, he needs Ashura's physical energy to do so.
Sharingan can't learn all Sharingan jutsu because all KKG come from the user's DNA. Everyone's DNA is different which is why Uchiha have the different eye MS abilities.
Itachi and Sasuke both had Amaterasu because they're siblings so share some similar DNA code but other than that Sasuke can't copy Tsukuyomi and Itachi can't copy Enton.
And Rinnegan can't learn any jutsu if the user meets the requirements, the same applies to Sharingan. i.e : Sasuke can't copy Naruto's lava RS unless he has lava affinity.
I don't know if you've reached the conclusive answer you were hoping to find, but I'll help summarize what I believe to be true.
The brain of an Uchiha responds to emotional peaking and the eyes are a reflection of such. When one reaches a certain level of emotional offset, their brain will produce special chakra that flows into the eyes and allows change. An Uchiha's eyes will keep this chakra, but the brain will always be able to produce it. This is why when a transplant occurs, the eye is permanently in the state it was received, since the brain will have no control over it like how it normally has control over hormones. This chakra isn't what powers the techniques, but what makes those techniques possible. This is what I believe you to be confused about. If someone like Kakashi can't generate the special chakra and it's kept in the eye, why does it never run out? That's because the special chakra is for enabling the abilities while the regular chakra supply is what powers them.
You just ignored the obvious, the eye is an organ which means it's an Uchiha's body part which means it has Uchiha DNA. Furthermore DNA determines what chakra the person can produce but in the end of the day chakra is responsible for what KKG someone can use.
The chakra Obito transferred into Kakashi gave him DMS without the need to have Sharingan eyes, the chakra in Madara's eyes have Hagoromo's chakra which gave Nagato the ability to use Hagoromo's KKG.
Now you're confusing yourself. The opening question is do the Sharingan has Chakra? Not is the Sharingan is powered by Chakra! if the Sharingan has Chakra, then Madara shouldn't be able to use susanoo without the eyes. Which means The Sharingan do not have chakra, it is just a tool that awakened and powered by the speical chakra in the brain.
I just said the Sharingan has chakra. It is a special chakra which sprout in the brain to activate the optic nerves. Susanoo doesn't require vision to activate as blind users can activate Susanoo as in Madara's case not Sasuke however. Madara still is able to because of that permanent process of already haven awoken the Sharingan. He doesn't need to repeat it. It has already been awaken. The Sharingan has chakra and it serves as the Uchiha's tool to be stronger. It's both and for the tool part I believe Itachi said something along the lines of the Sharingan being a tool and the tool is as only powerful as the user.
You are confusing yourself. It's simple just stick to the 2nd Hokage's statements.
The Sharingan contains cells and DNA, so it obviously has some sort of chakra or else Kakashi wouldn't be able to constantly use the Sharingan's techniques if the eye itself didn't have chakra.
except you guys dont understand how chakra works but talk like you do, which is belong to fanfic section :lol
so i suggest him and you go back to learn how it works and how it become chakra in the first place :lol
except you guys dont understand how chakra works but talk like you do, which is belong to fanfic section :lol
so i suggest him and you go back to learn how it works and how it become chakra in the first place :lol
except you guys dont understand how chakra works but talk like you do, which is belong to fanfic section :lol
so i suggest him and you go back to learn how it works and how it become chakra in the first place :lol
I don't know if you've reached the conclusive answer you were hoping to find, but I'll help summarize what I believe to be true.
The brain of an Uchiha responds to emotional peaking and the eyes are a reflection of such. When one reaches a certain level of emotional offset, their brain will produce special chakra that flows into the eyes and allows change. An Uchiha's eyes will keep this chakra, but the brain will always be able to produce it. This is why when a transplant occurs, the eye is permanently in the state it was received, since the brain will have no control over it like how it normally has control over hormones. This chakra isn't what powers the techniques, but what makes those techniques possible. This is what I believe you to be confused about. If someone like Kakashi can't generate the special chakra and it's kept in the eye, why does it never run out? That's because the special chakra is for enabling the abilities while the regular chakra supply is what powers them.
Hmm nice summary. I like that last part about regular chakra supplying the abilities for someone like kakashi. Could be why using MS techniques are more taxing on him.
Chakra is not simple energy that is just being there or appear out of no where for user to mold it up. Chakra is ...
You must be registered for see images
and everytime to use any thing/jutsu that related to chakra you need to....
You must be registered for see images
You guys saying Sharingan eye ball from Obito that transplanted into Kakashi contain chakra. It may correct in term of left over/ remaining chakra in body part that has molded up before, suddently got ripped apart and it still contain amount of chakra just like it still contain BLOOD.
Bio logic :lol you can just ignore this if you like, free lesson after all :lol
But if you have learned how any body part got transplanted into another human being, the BLOOD will either rinsed off before the surgery or being replaced by the current blood from the host after the surgery since the blood from the donor will become incompatible with the current system. Even if THAT BLOOD is able to mixed with the current blood, it wont be the same tomorow, just like your body atom now is not the same body atom from the past. New & free lesson for ya :lol
Kakashi from the past is not almost ENTIRELY the same Kakashi, only the DNA factor that helps new Kakashi looks similiar to old Kakashi (only few part of body are not being replaced)
But Manga fact lesson remain solid :lol
Chakra = body energy or to be precise the life force that create bio movement + spiritual energy or to be precise experience energy that gained through time and other activities....
You guys are just making assumption that goes against the manga statement, really annoying to see that :|
In order for Kakashi to use Sharingan, he has to create new chakra from his body part (+DNA the key that playing major part in it) and his experience that he gained through time and training.
There is ONLY DNA left that let Kakashi to use sharingan and it's ability