[Discussion] Does anyone have any theory..

nointro

Member
Joined
May 22, 2015
Messages
241
Reaction score
13
About why shanks had the Gum Gum DF? do you think he was going to use it for himself? maybe he had it because it was Gol. D Rogers? I'm just not sure why he'd leave a DF sitting around for someone else to take. When Luffy ate it he seemed to be pretty upset like he was saving it for something.
 

Guntah

Sannin of the Scrolls πŸ“œ
Elite
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
9,753
Reaction score
613
That's an interesting question, I never really thought about it before, but now I'm left to wonder...

Sure Oda has something planned for this though. He always does.
 

Rikudou Tobi

Kage in the Making πŸ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
10,654
Reaction score
417
If Rogers had the rubber fruit, not only would been mentioned but Mr. Gol wouldn't be able to survive that edd war.
 

ichirou

Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2011
Messages
155
Reaction score
5
Maybe he was upset because of how much money they could've got from selling the devil fruit. The booze they would afford and the partying they could've done.
 

nointro

Member
Joined
May 22, 2015
Messages
241
Reaction score
13
Maybe he was upset because of how much money they could've got from selling the devil fruit. The booze they would afford and the partying they could've done.

If so why was it just sitting in a box on the bar? I'm sure he could have found plenty of people that wanted to buy it.
 

Rikudou Tobi

Kage in the Making πŸ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
10,654
Reaction score
417
Hown would he have died in the edd war

The huge tides. Shiki is lucky his devil fruit powers can still manipulate water. Still don't know how he survived either, unless Rogers ship wasn't hit by the storm too?
 

WoldOfFingo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jul 29, 2009
Messages
1,862
Reaction score
138
My theorie is his crew and him found it when being on one of their countless travels. Same way like other people encounter DF's
 

Caliburn

𝕷𝔒𝖔 π•­π”’π–‘π”€π–Žπ” π–šπ”°
Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,944
Reaction score
4,197
I don't think there's even a reason to think about this much. It's not uncommon for pirate crews to encounter DF and especially not for a crew the caliber of the Red Hair Pirates. Most of all the DF users in the OPverse seem to have obtained a DF by accident. So a crew that travels all the seas has a higher rate of encountering DF than other people.

- The Roger Pirates found the section fruit, which was accidentally eaten by Buggy

- The WB pirates had a rule that whoever finds a DF, can do what he wishes with it (though I think it was stated more specifically that he who finds it, eats it but I assume they have a choice)

- BB joined the WB crew for the specific purpose of finding one DF in particular, which he succeeded in

So for adventurous, powerful pirate crews finding DF isn't that unusual and considering they are already plenty powerful, there's no reason for them to immediately eat it. DF are an expensive commodity, around 100m beri on average. Buggy originally had the intention of selling the DF before he swallowed it by accident. So there's really no reason to think there was some scheme behind this all. Lucky Roo even showed a picture of the fruit to Luffy to figure out if he had eaten it, which indicates they found a DF and later on checked which fruit it was (there's a book of DF). In the same chapter Lucky Roo said that they took it from an enemy.

That Roger had eaten the rubber fruit before Luffy has been suggested before, but you can pretty much ignore it. If that truly had been the case, someone should by now have made a remark about it.
 

chopstickchakra

Kage in the Making πŸ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Reaction score
1,012
About why shanks had the Gum Gum DF? do you think he was going to use it for himself? maybe he had it because it was Gol. D Rogers? I'm just not sure why he'd leave a DF sitting around for someone else to take. When Luffy ate it he seemed to be pretty upset like he was saving it for something.

Back then they said DF's were rare, which I guess they are compared to the entire OP population, so odds are they were planning on selling it since Shanks got upset Luffy ate it, he didn't want someone he liked who wants to be a pirate to eat a DF. The real question is why despite all the famous pirates we know did Shanks still think a DF was a bad trade off for someone who aspired to be a Pirate.
 

Caliburn

𝕷𝔒𝖔 π•­π”’π–‘π”€π–Žπ” π–šπ”°
Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,944
Reaction score
4,197
Back then they said DF's were rare, which I guess they are compared to the entire OP population, so odds are they were planning on selling it since Shanks got upset Luffy ate it, he didn't want someone he liked who wants to be a pirate to eat a DF. The real question is why despite all the famous pirates we know did Shanks still think a DF was a bad trade off for someone who aspired to be a Pirate.

Because at that point he still saw Luffy as nothing more than a naive child who was talking big. Shanks is very well aware that the life of a pirate is dangerous, so he really did not want to encourage a child too much and now that child lost the ability to swim. It's only when they were about to leave and Luffy made his bold statements that Shanks realized that Luffy was dead serious.
 

chopstickchakra

Kage in the Making πŸ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Reaction score
1,012
Because at that point he still saw Luffy as nothing more than a naive child who was talking big. Shanks is very well aware that the life of a pirate is dangerous, so he really did not want to encourage a child too much and now that child lost the ability to swim. It's only when they were about to leave and Luffy made his bold statements that Shanks realized that Luffy was dead serious.

I don't know, Shanks always seemed to take Luffy serious that he'd be a pirate it was at the end when he took his claim of being the next PK serious and gave him the hat. He acted upset Luffy ate the DF because it would be a hindrance to him being a pirate. Also if what most assume is true his crew has no DF's either, which also implies he sees them as not worth the trade off.
 

ArabianLuffy

Sannin of the Scrolls πŸ“œ
Elite
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
5,495
Reaction score
360
One would say that Shanks and crew would sell the GOMU to the highest bidder just for money. They probably don't see in GOMU that importance like GURA that has been known and feard as the power to destroy the world. It would be insane if World Government would treat GURA fruit as threatening as the Ancient Weapons, but who knows? The GURA fruit was a threat to Marines and WG to fall in wrong hands. DF are nothing but something for sale. Only those know their value and importance.
 

loj

from the east blue
Immortal
Joined
Aug 5, 2014
Messages
50,368
Reaction score
1,781
Good q,but I think they just found it nothing else where Luffy ate it after...
 
Top