- Joined
- Jan 21, 2012
- Messages
- 37,690
- Reaction score
- 1,999
You meant me?
No he ment the fans you described.
You meant me?
You meant me?
No he ment the fans you described.

That's not a manga fact bro. Hago confirmed sharingan doesn't evolve naturally to rinnegan like we originally thought. Rinnegan is Hago's chakra, brought out by Indra and Ashura's chakra.
You must be registered for see images
^^scan above for reference. That's probably why people seem to "hate fillers". It's not really the fillers they hate, but people tend to get so anxious for new material and explanations that they see a filler and quickly forget key manga facts, and then post threads all day complaining about why no one accepts fillers, which can be fustrating.
Manga already confirmed Rinnegan=Hago's chakra. So according to manga Hago wouldn't need the sharingan for Rinnegan but now that the filler is out people are going back to the "sharingan to rinnegan" concept that's already been proven false in an effort to make the anime seem canon when it's not.
This scan doesn't prove anything... The latest eye to Hagoromo is the rennigan i understand , but this scan doesn't mean he didn't HAVE a sharingan!! Its just known that Hagormo has a rennigan more than it was known he has a sharingan
its confirmed by Madara from sharingan to rennigan... whats the problem he should have a sharingan before awakening the rennigan
The scan proves that Sharingan doesn't naturally evolve to Rinnegan, which you stated was a manga fact and used as a basis for your "Hago has the sharingan" argument here:
^^ is false. Having a sharingan =/= potential to get Rinnegan at all. You don't need a sharingan to get Rinnegan. Rinnegan=Hago's chakra. Only way to get it is to get it from him or to specifically combine Ashura and Indra's chakra, which Hago himself confirmed is just his chakra. That was the point of my scan.
BZ also helped to support this as well, as he clearly stated that he approached BOTH Ashura and Indra's transmigrants to awaken the Rinnegan, despite only Indra's transmigrants having the sharingan, once again proving the sharingan isn't a requirement for the Rinnegan, otherwise, he would've only approached Uchiha only here:
You must be registered for see images
^^Note that BZ said he CONTINUED approaching BOTH transmigrants even after he had decided on changed the stone tablet and decided to the Uchiha would be good puppets to use, which was the page before. Feel free to look it up.
Madara assumed the answer was to combine senju+Uchiha dna, as he thought that was why he awakened it, not realizing it was due to him and Hashirama being transmigrants of Ashura and Indra. For anyone other than someone with Hago, Indra, or Ashura's chakra specifically, the Rinnegan isn't possible to obtain.
No, this doesn't prove outright that Hago didn't have a sharingan. It just proves that the sharingan has nothing to do with the Rinnegan. Yet that was the basis for your "Hago had a sharingan" argument, and you tried to pass it off as a manga fact that isn't in order to make the filler facts make sense. But the truth is, manga facts don't support the idea that Hago had a sharingan because manga facts have already confirmed he wouldn't need one in first place
So no, he shouldn't have a sharigan before Rinnegan because according to the manga he, or anyone for that matter doesn't need a sharingan for the rinnegan. There does that make sense now?