[Predictions] Oda! WOW! THIS IS SO INSANE! MIND BLOWN!

[Yubel]

Just the lipstick is a rather shallow argument. Many people have already pointed out that there are quite a few characters who have that and it's very doubtful all of them are related to each other. It also has to be mentioned that Lola herself only has fat lips and not the characteristic heart-shaped lipstick you are referring to. So that her zombie-equivalant has them, makes it a rather redundant argument. On top of that it doesn't really make much sense at this point. Lola was a pirate from the NW. She and her crew came from the NW and went to Paradise, this is the opposite of what most pirate crews do and also Bonney. Bonney originates from South Blue and went from there to the NW via Paradise. She also blamed BB and seemingly Akainu for something that happened during the War of the Best, so her profile doesn't really match being Big Mum's daughter.

And I don't get what Bonney stopping Zoro from killing a Celestial Dragon has anything to do with this. She stopped him because otherwise an admiral would come.

On the other hand Bonney has the whole 'food addiction' quirk and her nickname Big Eater is similar to Big Mum, but in the end these are all rather weak arguments



Most people called Sabo alive already all the way back in 2010 immediately after when he supposedly died. That was such a common and straightforward possibility that it's not something a single individual can call.

It's easy to say it was straightforward when we have confirmation. That wasn't the case back then.

 

[LBeezy]

I think Bonny is WB's daughter.
She cried when she saw/heard WB is dead & she tried to fought BB after Marineford Arc.

I wouldn't mind that being the case for Bonney.. but tbh it wouldn't sit well with me for WB's character I think it was good writing for Oda to make WB this huge strong pirate that only wanted a family, but because he never biologically had one of his own, he lived his life with his crew being treated as his family. All of his sons and what not.. he held his crew close to his heart, which is what made him such a great and well respected Captain.

Plus with the knowledge we have of BM having so many daughters, I just don't want every single one of them to be fodder and have the same characteristics. That's why I'm hoping a couple of her daughters ended up becoming strong pirates on their own. Pirates (or even Marines) that we know of, but we just don't know they're related yet.

 

[Caliburn]

It's easy to say it was straightforward when we have confirmation. That wasn't the case back then.

It was easy to say already back then because it was exactly the case back then. The chapter after Sabo died Dragon went to his ship and then his nakama were talking about someone having severe injuries and it certainly was not Dragon. So many people, including me, independently from each other theorized that Dragon had Sabo with him simply because it was such an almost obvious and logical assumption and this was like one-two weeks after Sabo presumably died. Now saying it was that obvious might be a stretch, but that Sabo survived the ordeal was a much likelier possibility than that he truly died. It was not so much a matter of getting confirmation but when we would get the confirmation.

It has always been a straightforward prediction, even without the scene's with Dragon which were almost too perfect, as a living Sabo would benefit the story much more than a dead Sabo.

I wouldn't mind that being the case for Bonney.. but tbh it wouldn't sit well with me for WB's character I think it was good writing for Oda to make WB this huge strong pirate that only wanted a family, but because he never biologically had one of his own, he lived his life with his crew being treated as his family. All of his sons and what not.. he held his crew close to his heart, which is what made him such a great and well respected Captain.

Plus with the knowledge we have of BM having so many daughters, I just don't want every single one of them to be fodder and have the same characteristics. That's why I'm hoping a couple of her daughters ended up becoming strong pirates on their own. Pirates (or even Marines) that we know of, but we just don't know they're related yet.

I just realized why they call her Big Mum, she literally is a big mum. I mean if all those 35 daughters are her personal daughters...well she certainly is a matriarch. I doubt thought we will see all of them or that Oda will elaborate extensively on all of them. That Bonney is one of them, meh. As I said Bonney sailed the complete opposite trajectory you would normally expect.

 

[LBeezy]

I just realized why they call her Big Mum, she literally is a big mum. I mean if all those 35 daughters are her personal daughters...well she certainly is a matriarch. I doubt thought we will see all of them or that Oda will elaborate extensively on all of them. That Bonney is one of them, meh. As I said Bonney sailed the complete opposite trajectory you would normally expect.

Lmao!! You know what, even though I mentioned her having all those daughters, her name didn't mean anything to me until you literally just pointed that out. XD lol if she is in fact the biological mother to all those daughters, then her name is just too perfect for that big lady. xd haha

I don't think we'll see all of them either.. unless Oda shows a crowd of them at this wedding/tea party, but either way I HIGHLY doubt we're gonna get any back stories or anything to be elaborated on. Unless it's maybe the one who's supposed to marry Sanji, Lola (If she is indeed her daughter), and then that's basically it.. although that's why I wouldn't mind Bonney being one of her daughters.. because out of all 30 something of them, I would think that at least one of them became somewhat well known, and for Bonney it would be cool cause it would've been on her own. Without sailing under her Mom's name/powerful position.

But like you said though, the history of Bonney (from what was given to us) doesn't really match up or make sense for her to be BM'S daughter. So I agree with you that it doesn't make sense logically. Lol

I just want one of her daughters to be a strong pirate, or even marine, that we've seen in the story before, but just didn't know they were related yet. Until Oda tells us. Lol but we'll just have to wait and see.

 

[Yubel]

It was easy to say already back then because it was exactly the case back then. The chapter after Sabo died Dragon went to his ship and then his nakama were talking about someone having severe injuries and it certainly was not Dragon. So many people, including me, independently from each other theorized that Dragon had Sabo with him simply because it was such an almost obvious and logical assumption and this was like one-two weeks after Sabo presumably died. Now saying it was that obvious might be a stretch, but that Sabo survived the ordeal was a much likelier possibility than that he truly died. It was not so much a matter of getting confirmation but when we would get the confirmation.

It has always been a straightforward prediction, even without the scene's with Dragon which were almost too perfect, as a living Sabo would benefit the story much more than a dead Sabo.



I just realized why they call her Big Mum, she literally is a big mum. I mean if all those 35 daughters are her personal daughters...well she certainly is a matriarch. I doubt thought we will see all of them or that Oda will elaborate extensively on all of them. That Bonney is one of them, meh. As I said Bonney sailed the complete opposite trajectory you would normally expect.

I also theorized that Sabo is alive after watching the clip several times over but it was never certain. Alot of people went against the idea and thought Sabo was dead from what I remember. Right now I can say Bonney is Big Mom's daughter but it won't be certain untill we get confirmation and then everyone will be like: "it was so obvious" when it could've gotten either way.