Help Me Settle Something: Was Yoton Rasenshuriken too much for Madara to handle

[ANiMUS]

I was in the middle of a discussion with a fellow NB member and the person believed that YRS was simply too strong for Madara too absorb

OT: Nope, it bursts out instantly and the amount of chakra it consists is massive which cannot absorbed completely before it explodes. No one can do shit against this Jutsu

Personally I think that the reason Madara didn't absorb the attack was because he was lacking one of his rinnegan, but the other person is intent on that "Naruto's godly chakra" was simply too much for Madara so could u all kindly help me settle this.

The other person's identity will remain hidden

 

[Gerkak]

Madara didn't absorb it because he lacked one of his rinnegan, he didn't absorb it because the plot didn't want him too.

This didn't just happen between naruto and madara but between many characters as well

 

[ANiMUS]

All those participating will receive rep if I can give it

 

[Kakashi42]

No, I want names!

 

[SizzlingSausage]

It was plot.

 

[ANiMUS]

No, I want names!

Can't do that publicly or the thread will be shut down

 

[Venomous Cobra]

It'll explode before getting absorbed completely, same thing with sousano slashes, it can technically be absorbed since it's made out of chakra but the impact/momentum itself doesn't won't stop

Though the hit itself was plot, madara had more than one way to counter that

 

[Adam Driver]

Too much for Madara to handle, even his limbo was ineffective.
Him having the other rinnegan may be a different story (though stopping it completely wouldn't work) but in that chapter the manga scans provide the fact that it was too much for him to handle, the tree as well.

 

[Tarinth]

I think there are only two possible explanations.

A. Plot
B. Rikudo Chakra is special and can't be absorbed with Preta Path. (After all, when Sasuke absorbed
chakra from Naruto, it had all been Kurama's chakra, not Naruto's rikudo chakra.)

Although, since no indication was given that Rikudo chakra can't be absorbed, it can be likened to plot,
the same way Madara chose not to use more of his Rinnegan powers and PS while Naruto and Sasuke
didn't bust out at full power immediately to make sure Madara would never get the chance to cast IT.

 

[Seventh Sama]

In my opinion he couldn't absorb it.

 

[ANiMUS]

It'll explode before getting absorbed completely, same thing with sousano slashes, it can technically be absorbed since it's made out of chakra but the impact/momentum itself doesn't won't stop

Though the hit itself was plot, madara had more than one way to counter that

Since when has a technique continued to function during the process of being absorbed :|

 

[DHOH]

PP has never failed to absorb any attack and a PP user have never said an attack was to big to absorb. It's also described as a bottomless pit by DB..

Momoshiki showed just how haxed PP can be.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

Since when has a technique continued to function during the process of being absorbed :|

Since when has tech stopped instantly after coming into contact with preta?

You must be registered for see links

Chakra is absorbed gradually as seen above

besides this is rasengan, once it loses its stability, it'll explode, the only thing that kept ot from exploding then was that the tech was absorbed quickly due to its size, that one you're talking about on the other would take much longer time. Preta had neve had any feats of absorbing massively destructive attacks.


By that logic One eyed obito or nagato would be able to absorb indra arrow/bijuu rasen shuriken etc....

 

[ANiMUS]

Since when has tech stopped instantly after coming into contact with preta?

You must be registered for see links

Chakra is absorbed gradually as seen above

besides this is rasengan, once it loses its stability, it'll explode, the only thing that kept ot from exploding then was that the tech was absorbed quickly due to its size, that one you're talking about on the other would take much longer time. Preta had neve had any feats of absorbing massively destructive attacks.


By that logic One eyed obito or nagato would be able to absorb indra arrow/bijuu rasen shuriken etc....

One Eyed Obito has never used preta so we don't even know if he can and everything has to have limits so Nagato absorbing such a massive amount of chakra doesn't seem possible.

Not on that Preta is pretty much the reversal of chakra flow if either of them tried not only would it take a long time leaving them a big target,

And like I said has any tech ever stopped functioning once being caught in preta

 

[VongolaX]

Madara couldn't absorb because he was lacking a rinnegan?

Where did this come from?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

From fake ass rinnegan to no eyes at all and then with only one eye in place.

Madara's been constantly able to absorb ninjustus.

The only reason why he didn't absorb naruto's technique is because he sent out Limbo to attack.
That's where all the focus was directed.

 

[ANiMUS]

Madara couldn't absorb because he was lacking a rinnegan?

Where did this come from?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

From fake ass rinnegan to no eyes at all and then with only one eye in place.

Madara's bin constantly able to absorb.

The only reason why he didn't absorb naruto's technique is because he sent out Limbo to attack.
That's where all the focus was directed to.

Fake rinnegan still had all abilities with the exception of controlling the Mazo.

And with no rinnegan Madara could only absorb the chakra from what he touched.

I propose that Madara couldn't use the preta that he used to absorb Naruto's FRS because he lacked the ability to use Preta in its fullest sense which would have been possible with both rinnegan

 

[Venomous Cobra]

One Eyed Obito has never used preta so we don't even know if he can and everything has to have limits so Nagato absorbing such a massive amount of chakra doesn't seem possible.

Not on that Preta is pretty much the reversal of chakra flow if either of them tried not only would it take a long time leaving them a big target,

And like I said has any tech ever stopped functioning once being caught in preta

Of course he can, what kind of post is this? He summoned the gedo mazo and was taught by madara who himself knew how to use it. Plus if nagato has limits then other users should damn well have limits too

Yeah, same thing applies to all other users unless of course you're suggesting that absorbing speed is different depending on the user

"Functioning" the just only stops function after its chakra is completely absorbed

 

[Blackzoro]

He lacked his other rinnegan and but it also may have being too much. When he absorbed a normal senjutsu RS he said it was a bit too much

 

[ANiMUS]

Of course he can, what kind of post is this? He summoned the gedo mazo and was taught by madara who himself knew how to use it. Plus if nagato has limits then other users should damn well have limits too

Yeah, same thing applies to all other users unless of course you're suggesting that absorbing speed is different depending on the user

"Functioning" the just only stops function after its chakra is completely absorbed

You must be registered for see images

Preta reverses the person's chakra flow to suck in jutsu. So more chakra or more powerful chakra should equal greater flow :|

So u think that Naruto can still control when FRS is being absorbed and can still make it expand if need be

 

[VongolaX]

Fake rinnegan still had all abilities with the exception of controlling the Mazo.

And with no rinnegan Madara could only absorb the chakra from what he touched.

I propose that Madara couldn't use the preta that he used to absorb Naruto's FRS because he lacked the ability to use Preta in its fullest sense which would have been possible with both rinnegan

That is all subjective and neither to be confirmed.

As for Madara with one eye, he clearly absorbed the God tree which was a justu created by Rikudou Obito.

There's no such thing as a half and half ability from one eye, it's a fanfiction that people made up.