[Discussion] Marineford power levels

[Ridoku X]

Alright guys, I want your opinion on the power levels of the big names that took part in the Marineford war. I am gonna start by saying that Whitebeard's a 100, so scale the following list based on that.

Whitebeard=100
Shanks= ?
Benn Bekcman= ?
Akainu= ?
Aokiji= ?
Kizaru= ?
Sengoku= ?
Garp= ?
Marco= ?
Jozu= ?
Vista= ?
Mihawk= ?
Doflamingo= ?
Jinbe= ?
Kuma= ?
Ivankov= ?
Boa Hancock= ?
Moriah= ?
Crocodile= ?
Blackbeard= ?
Luffy= ?
Smoker= ?
Ace= ?


I'll post my own opinion soon after I see some of you guys' suggestions. Thank you ~

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Whitebeard-100
Shanks-99
Miahwk-99
Garp-98
Akainu-98
Sengoku-97
Aokiji-96
Kizaru-96
Benn Beckmann-93
Blackbeard(Gura)-89
Marco-88
Jozu-85
Vista-85
Doflamingo-84
Hancock-84
Ace-80
Jinbe-80
Ivankov-80
Kuma-75
Crocodile-68
Smoker-60
Luffy-60
Moriah-55

Not that great with number scales as I don't do it often.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Whitebeard=100
Shanks= 97
Benn Bekcman= ?
Akainu= 99
Aokiji= 97
Kizaru= 97
Sengoku= 97
Garp= 96
Marco= 80
Jozu=80
Vista= 80
Mihawk= 97.5
Doflamingo= 85
Jinbe=75
Kuma= 70
Ivankov= 69
Boa Hancock= 68
Moriah= 50
Crocodile= 50
Blackbeard= 80
Luffy= 60
Smoker= 50
Ace= 70

 

[U mAd]

Whitebeard=100
Shanks= 94
Benn Bekcman= 85
Akainu= 89
Aokiji= 88
Kizaru= 88
Sengoku= 92
Garp= 96
Marco= 84
Jozu= 74
Vista= 72
Mihawk= 92
Doflamingo= 78
Jinbe= 73
Kuma= 79
Ivankov= 72
Boa Hancock= 77
Moriah= 35
Crocodile= 60
Blackbeard= 75
Luffy= 40
Smoker= 55
Ace= 60
After this thread someone should post average power levels based on opinions.

 

[Black Mamba]

Whitebeard= 100
Shanks= 100
Benn Bekcman= 93
Akainu= 95
Aokiji= 95
Kizaru= 93
Sengoku= 95
Garp= 99
Marco= 93
Jozu= 82
Vista= 80
Mihawk= 99
Doflamingo= 89
Jinbe= 80
Kuma= 80
Ivankov= 70
Boa Hancock= 75
Moriah= 60
Crocodile= 55
Blackbeard= 83 to 88(after gura gura)
Luffy= 65
Smoker= 70
Ace= 80

 

[ultraChalk]

Whitebeard=100
Shanks= 113
Benn Bekcman= 100 (my flame shield is ready)
Akainu= 110
Aokiji= 110
Kizaru= 110
Sengoku= 111
Garp= 111
Marco= 94
Jozu= 90
Vista= 90
Mihawk= 113
Doflamingo= 80
Jinbe= 58
Kuma= 83
Ivankov= 72
Boa Hancock= Idk
Moriah= 50
Crocodile= 60
Blackbeard= 93
Luffy= 35
Smoker= 40
Ace= 75

Now I'll explain some of them.
I think Shanks and Mihawk were the strongest ones there. Shanks stopped Akainu when literally nobody else could or would, and he's = to Mihawk.

I put the admirals that much higher, because they had a strong health advantage in health. And since Aokiji and Akainu are practically =, I also credit him with the ability to cover Akainus feats as well. Kizaru wasn't fighting seriously during that war at all. Anyway... Akainu tanked 2(?) of WB's very strongest attacks, directly. And still had it in him to get up and go, knowing he would have had to get through all of his commanders. And not even Vista+Marco could pierce his haki, and they had clear direct shots at him. So yeah, I put them that much higher.

Ben Beckman is questionable but thats just how idk

And me giving a character 50 doesn't necessarily mean they have half his strength so don't fret

 

[Ridoku X]

I am having a hard time ranking people like Garp and Shanks in correlation to Whitebeard...Garp should be stronger than Whitebeard since the previous 2 and Roger were at the same power level pretty much and Garp doesn't seem to be weakened that much from old age. However, he didn't seem that impressive in the war...

 

[Black Mamba]

Whitebeard=100
Shanks= 113
Benn Bekcman= 100 (my flame shield is ready)
Akainu= 110
Aokiji= 110
Kizaru= 110
Sengoku= 111
Garp= 111
Marco= 97
Jozu= 95
Vista= 95
Mihawk= 113
Doflamingo= 68
Jinbe= 58
Kuma= 75
Ivankov= 72
Boa Hancock= Idk
Moriah= 50
Crocodile= 60
Blackbeard= 96
Luffy= 36
Smoker= 40
Ace= 79

Now I'll explain some of them.
I think Shanks and Mihawk were the strongest ones there. Shanks stopped Akainu when literally nobody else could or would, and he's = to Mihawk.

I put the admirals that much higher, because they had a strong health advantage in health. And since Aokiji and Akainu are practically =, I also credit him with the ability to cover Akainus feats as well. Kizaru wasn't fighting seriously during that war at all. Anyway... Akainu tanked 2(?) of WB's very strongest attacks, directly. And still had it in him to get up and go, knowing he would have had to get through all of his commanders. And not even Vista+Marco could pierce his haki, and they had clear direct shots at him. So yeah, I put them that much higher.

And me giving a character 50 doesn't necessarily mean they have half his strength so don't fret

Bruh what is this...? this is terrible man, I was expecting a few shitty power rankings but this is beyond my expectations.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

I am having a hard time ranking people like Garp and Shanks in correlation to Whitebeard...Garp should be stronger than Whitebeard since the previous 2 and Roger were at the same power level pretty much and Garp doesn't seem to be weakened that much from old age. However, he didn't seem that impressive in the war...

Old WB was still the strongest but that doesn't mean he had the best everything like speed etc.. He was the strongest overall.

 

[Punk Hazard]

Jinbe>Ace. Magma punch through his body killed Ace. Even medical treatment wouldn't work. Jinbei survived however.

 

[ultraChalk]

Bruh what is this...? this is terrible man, I was expecting a few shitty power rankings but this is beyond my expectations.

This list is so fucking bad.

No shit posting please. If you disagree then state why.

Jinbe>Ace. Magma punch through his body killed Ace. Even medical treatment wouldn't work. Jinbei survived however.

Akainus df was especially effective against a logia like Ace, who has never shown any haki feats. Magma consumes fire.

 

[ultraChalk]

This list is so fucking bad. Why is Ace above Doflamingo? Why is Crocodild above Jinbe? And why the hell are so many people above Whitebeard, the WSM?

Croc is below Jinbei cus he got beat by pregear Luffy who would get job'd by Jinbei. Maybe I should reconsider Ace.

And I already explained. Don't like reading I presume?

 

[Ridoku X]

Jinbe>Ace. Magma punch through his body killed Ace. Even medical treatment wouldn't work. Jinbei survived however.

Well that would only mean that Jinbe is more durable than Ace I guess.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Croc is below Jinbei cus he got beat by pregear Luffy who would get job'd by Jinbei. Maybe I should reconsider Ace.

And I already explained. Don't like reading I presume?

You put Croc above Jinbe. I want an actual reason why so many people are above WB, not the bs reason you gave.

 

[Punk Hazard]

No shit posting please. If you disagree then state why.

Akainus df was especially effective against a logia like Ace, who has never shown any haki feats. Magma consumes fire.

Pretty sure everyone is vulnerable to magma piercing all the way through their body and melting their insides.

Well that would only mean that Jinbe is more durable than Ace I guess.

Not really, since it pierced through him just as much.

Edit: Yeah on second thought this means Jinbei has higher durability and endurance, which could be enough to pull off a win.

 

[Black Mamba]

No shit posting please. If you disagree then state why.

Lol sorry too much to correct man, i'll state a few

Dying really weak WB beat a healthy Akainu low-mid diff and yes he was beaten he couldn't get up needed time to recover if WB wanted to kill him he could of. Yet you put him and all the admirals above WB.

Garp, WB, roger said to be equals.

You put Doffy at 68, but Jozu at 95 even thou Doffy was toying with him.

BB at 96 when 5% WB beat his ass.

Jinbe 58? When him and Ace were considered equals

 

[Ridoku X]

Alright I've made up my mind. My list is :

Whitebeard= 100
Shanks=98
Mihawk=97
Garp=96
Sengoku=94
Akainu=93
Aokiji=92
Kizaru=91
Blackbeard=90
Benn Beckman=87
Marco=85-86
Doflamingo=83-84
Vista=83
Jozu=82-83
Hancock=79
Ace=79
Jinbe=78
Crocodile=74
Ivankov=72
Kuma=70
Moriah=65
Smoker=55
Luffy=50

 

[ultraChalk]

Alright I've made up my mind. My list is :

Whitebeard= 100
Shanks=98
Mihawk=97
Garp=96
Sengoku=94
Akainu=93
Aokiji=92
Kizaru=91
Blackbeard=90
Benn Beckman=87
Marco=85-86
Doflamingo=83
Vista=83
Jozu=82
Hancock=79
Ace=79
Jinbe=78
Crocodile=74
Ivankov=72
Kuma=70
Moriah=65
Smoker=55
Luffy=50

Why is Moriah above Luffy?

 

[Ridoku X]

Why is Moriah above Luffy?

Well Moriah didn't only fight Luffy, he fought the entire crew so I am not yet sure if Luffy was really stronger than Moriah by himself. Though I might change the difference of power level since I am kinda irresolute lol

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Alright I've made up my mind. My list is :

Whitebeard= 100
Shanks=98
Mihawk=97
Garp=96
Sengoku=94
Akainu=93
Aokiji=92
Kizaru=91
Blackbeard=90
Benn Beckman=87
Marco=85-86
Doflamingo=83-84
Vista=83
Jozu=82-83
Hancock=79
Ace=79
Jinbe=78
Crocodile=74
Ivankov=72
Kuma=70
Moriah=65
Smoker=55
Luffy=50

Crocodile above Kuma and Ivankov? Wtf?