Kishimoto criticism......not a troll thread.....simply hard CRITICISM

Narusaku619

Narusaku619

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Messages
795
Reaction score
27
Throughout the series there's things that masashi kishimoto does that piss fans off....

1. Stupid or under developt parings...
2. Forgiving every villian no matter what they do....obito, ORO,
3. Extreme plot holes!!
4. UNREALISTIC CONCLUSIONS
5.Powerup out of no where
6. Introducing a final villain that was lame.....not really important to the fanbase....


There's probably more....but this whole KARIN AND SAKURA FRIENDS BECAUSE OF ALMOST GETTING KILLED JUST DROPS THE HATCHET ON KISHI....

WHY DID HE INTRODUCE A NEW GENERATION....MAKE RANDOM PAIRINGS......SPEND ALL HIS TIME ON MOVIES.....GAIDEN WHICH WAS A FAIL....



HERES WHAT KISHIMOTO SHOULD OF DONE:

1. Create a third series with Naruto at 19...
2. Introduce toneri as the new villain....moon falling to earth his goal..
3. Develop HINATAS character as the true heroine
4. Create a closer bond between hinata and Naruto
5. Explain briefly how the pairings began......EXPERIALLY CHOJI AND KARUI
6. Show Tsunade retiring.....KAKASHI GETTING THE POSITION OF HOKAGE...
7. KARIN and sakuras freindship......have them be rivals for SASUKE....eventually one losses and dislikes the other
8. Give characters like rock lee, TENTEN, shino, kiba better endings
9. Show how the ninja world became peaceful
10. SHOW NARUTO BECOMING HOKAGES.....WALKING ON THE TOP OF THE HOKAGE BUILDING WHILE EVERYONE LOOKS UP IN APPRECIATION AND AFFECTION FOR HIM


THIS WHOLE NEW GENERATION STUFF IS A LITTLE ENTERTAINING BUT AS TRUE NARUTO FANS I THINK WE ALL WOULD OF APRECIATED A THIRD SERIES OF NARUTO SHOWING A SOLID ENDING


NOT SOME B.S WE GET IN CHUNCKS FROM MOVIES.....SPINOFFS.....ONE SHOTS...

TO MOST NARUTO FANS THIS NEW GEN IS LAME/ unnecessary!!!!,!!!!!


KISHIMOTO should of took time off and continued Naruto after the war ended.......MY OPINION AND MY CRITIZISM...
 
IcyStar

IcyStar

Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
149
Reaction score
8
Nah. Kishimoto-sensei didn't have the time or energy.
 
Narusaku619

Narusaku619

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Messages
795
Reaction score
27
IcyStar said:
Nah. Kishimoto-sensei didn't have the time or energy.
Click to expand...


It would make sense to take time off then.....finish Naruto........take a few years off to enjoy life......bang his wife like he wanted.....raise his kids....


Then come back in about 5 years. To do a third series?? That DOSENT sound bad at all the way thinks ended and the way we get plot holes sucks.


THE FACT THAT WERE GETTING LITTLE THINGS IN CHUNKS IS STUID........no body wants to read a novel, NOT ALOT OF PEOPLE WERE HAPPY WITH GAIDEN......THE LAST WAS TO FAST....THINGS LEFT UNEXPLAINED

HE SHOULD OF TOOK TIME OFF AND CONTINUED THE SERIES TWO YEARS AFTER THE WAR.....MY OPINION
 
Darkboy85

Darkboy85

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 26, 2012
Messages
1,423
Reaction score
99
Narusaku619 said:
Throughout the series there's things that masashi kishimoto does that piss fans off....

1. Stupid or under developt parings...
2. Forgiving every villian no matter what they do....obito, ORO,
3. Extreme plot holes!!
4. UNREALISTIC CONCLUSIONS
5.Powerup out of no where
6. Introducing a final villain that was lame.....not really important to the fanbase....
Click to expand...

1) Pairings are irrelevant in any shonen anyway. It was just a way to please the fans somehow.

2) Have you been reading the same manga? That's what naruto does and has always done. That's what he stands for. He rather listen to what the "villains" have to say instead of brainlessly fighting them. He has the "power" to change people's hearts and that has been said countless times thorough the series. I honestly don't really see the huge problem here. Plus, technically, he never TNJ'nd madara.

3) Such as? For real, I always see people bringing up the "plothole" excuse but they never tend to give real examples, just pointless nitpicks...

4) How so?

5) This is a shonen trope. The "powerup in a dire situation". This happens in every shonen and not just naruto.

6) Now that, I kinda agree. Kaguya was stupid but heh, it is what it is.

ALSO, a third series would've been too much IMO.
 
Last edited:
P

Pukkake Pokayo

Guest
I read it a bit and it sounds like Link in Majora's Mask.

You were right about most bits tho.
 
Narusaku619

Narusaku619

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 24, 2015
Messages
795
Reaction score
27
Sasukeisoursavior said:
I didn't know NS fans were still butthurt even now....

It's over dude.
Click to expand...


In San diego there's a narusaku fanclub......over 120 members who each don't like the ending.....



The majority of us like me arnt just made about narusaku not happeneing it's the way KISHI hooked us and made us love a show......but end it horribly..
 
MangaArtist007

MangaArtist007

Member
Joined
May 22, 2015
Messages
276
Reaction score
6
Narusaku619 said:
Throughout the series there's things that masashi kishimoto does that piss fans off....

1. Stupid or under developt parings...

He confessed to forcing Choji and Karui together to make the new inoshikacho, and left Sasusaku to the audiences imagination. A lot of artists and writers leave things to the audiences imagination, and sasuke is a very unique character so it works
2. Forgiving every villian no matter what they do....obito, ORO,

It would not be Naruto's character to kill them and would completely ruin his character if he did. getting other characters to kill the aforementioned would just make Naruto look weak.

3. Extreme plot holes!!
Despite all the talk there aren't really that many. Masashi Kishimoto is a human being which means he can make the rare slip in writing 700 chapters to a weekly deadline.

4. UNREALISTIC CONCLUSIONS

It is a story, so idealistic conclusions work.

5.Powerup out of no where

Like when?

6. Introducing a final villain that was lame.....not really important to the fanbase....

Kaguya was always intended as the final villain, also taken from folklore, but Shonen jump said he had to finish on i think the 33rd issue making it 700 chapters, so pacing went out the window towards the end.


There's probably more....but this whole KARIN AND SAKURA FRIENDS BECAUSE OF ALMOST GETTING KILLED JUST DROPS THE HATCHET ON KISHI....

WHY DID HE INTRODUCE A NEW GENERATION....MAKE RANDOM PAIRINGS......SPEND ALL HIS TIME ON MOVIES.....GAIDEN WHICH WAS A FAIL....

The pairings weren't random, and the new gen finishes off the Naruto franchise, where Naruto has finally become Hokage. why don't you like the movies or Gaiden?

HERES WHAT KISHIMOTO SHOULD OF DONE:

1. Create a third series with Naruto at 19...

He has been drawing Naruto for 15 years...He is human and married with kids, give him a break
2. Introduce toneri as the new villain....moon falling to earth his goal..
That was The Last. Seems to simple to make into a third series
3. Develop HINATAS character as the true heroine
Sakura is heroine. Sorry if you don't like her. But now both Hinata and Sakura are more major supporting characters so what difference? Besides, he has already developed her character from underconfident to confident
4. Create a closer bond between hinata and Naruto
The Last did that
5. Explain briefly how the pairings began......EXPERIALLY CHOJI AND KARUI
Some make some sense from the series, inosai, NaruHina, ShikaTema, and already said Sasusaku and Choji Karui. Needed for the new Gen to tie up Naruti with him as Hokage
6. Show Tsunade retiring.....KAKASHI GETTING THE POSITION OF HOKAGE...
That happened in the manga, no?
7. KARIN and sakuras freindship......have them be rivals for SASUKE....eventually one losses and dislikes the other
He's shown that they are both mature women (if you recall they were both fangirls originally)
8. Give characters like rock lee, TENTEN, shino, kiba better endings
The Hiden series does a bit. How much do you want, the manga shows what they're now doing with their lives
9. Show how the ninja world became peaceful
Manga's done that
10. SHOW NARUTO BECOMING HOKAGES.....WALKING ON THE TOP OF THE HOKAGE BUILDING WHILE EVERYONE LOOKS UP IN APPRECIATION AND AFFECTION FOR HIM
Being released with the Boruto Movie

THIS WHOLE NEW GENERATION STUFF IS A LITTLE ENTERTAINING BUT AS TRUE NARUTO FANS I THINK WE ALL WOULD OF APRECIATED A THIRD SERIES OF NARUTO SHOWING A SOLID ENDING

15 years...Human...Wife...Kids...Break?


NOT SOME B.S WE GET IN CHUNCKS FROM MOVIES.....SPINOFFS.....ONE SHOTS...

TO MOST NARUTO FANS THIS NEW GEN IS LAME/ unnecessary!!!!,!!!!!

Same as above it ties up Naruto without going into a new thing

KISHIMOTO should of took time off and continued Naruto after the war ended.......MY OPINION AND MY CRITIZISM...
Click to expand...

You're opinion is your choice, though you forget Kishi is a person not a machine. Also you've left out the good things. It was a complicated and interesting story, and his artwork is gorgeous. whether you like that or not it shows he is very talented and respect - worthy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top