Why Peace In Narutoverse Is unfeasible
- Thread starter itsxtrayy
- Start date
Venomous Cobra
Kage in the Making 👑
- Joined
- May 13, 2014
- Messages
- 15,664
- Reaction score
- 1,229
They did worse :lol
My point is that if the world is at peace THERE IS NO WAY TO MAKE MONEY IN THIS WORLD. Missions and wars fuel the economy go read the chapter before the zabuza arc where Hiruzen explains this to team 7. Peace=Starving people. Wars and Missions= fed people but no peeace.
lndra
Legendary Shinobi 🐸
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2014
- Messages
- 31,928
- Reaction score
- 2,237
We shall see what kind of missions people do in the Boruto movie.
Wow, people really don't understand what i'm saying do they lol. let me make this clear, missions and war bring in money in fact, it's the FOUNDATION of ninja economies Missions and War= booming economy, but no peace. No war's and Missions=Peace but there is no way to make money so people STARVE just like pain said in chapter 436. This is a paradox you can only have one or the other. That's why I said kishi should of never introduced this idea in the manga unless he was going to go all the way with it.
This is why I said, introducing the idea of peace into a story like this is counterintuitive, it creates a paradox. The only way to break the paradox is for the people of the narutoverse to create new sustainable jobs that pay just as much as missions/wars, but whatever those new jobs ending up being they would render ninja obsolete.
NukaCola
Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2014
- Messages
- 6,161
- Reaction score
- 522
Not all mission are based on killing people or attacking villages. The nations used war to position themselves as the strongest country and gain more costumers.
Also, the countries have been at peace for like 20 years before the 4th war and nobody had the need for another war before Obito and Madara started with their nonsense.
Ken Kaneki
Anbu Operative 🎭
- Joined
- Dec 10, 2014
- Messages
- 3,443
- Reaction score
- 291
I have thought long and hard about this and I have found no perfect answer. Kishimoto should have abandoned Kaguya arc and focused on this. It is like he said let there be peace and there was peace. No explanation
. Guess I am a fool. When the greatest of philosophers and anthropologists have no solutions, how can I expect Kishimoto to have one.
However I think this maybe one of the ways to look at the situation :-
1) Like in countries where no war is ensuing, militaries are kept up and research and development is still carried on. This does not mean that the country wage wars, however the military is kept paid and engaged and thus everyone is happy for the moment. So I think it would be in the best interest of people to keep the Shinobi system alive via donations, even if the Shinobis refuse to do certain unethical missions. This would at least keep them safe as they know there is an army of sorts protecting them.
2) Now the Ninja system has always been funded directly by people or beneficiaries. So there has only been incentive to accept missions, however unethical. That has to change. It has to become like it is in most countries. Ordinary citizens pay TAX and a part of tax is used to fund army. This is how it has to be in the Ninja countries. You want army to protect your borders ? Fine pay tax. This tax would fund army and no one would die hungry.
3) As it has been shown that the development is taking place and it has also been shown that lately Ninjas have been passive. So I think as per the laws of demand and supply, the more lucrative position would be that contributing in development. Hence majority of new gen youth should look for employment in these booming industries. Since temporary peace has been achieved, the intake of the Shinobi system must be much lower and thus more people should be encouraged to find job elsewhere. This would create a stable economic system in the world of no war.
4) Finally when most of the people have been employed in operations elsewhere, it is obvious that the power centre must also change from Hokage or shinobi to elsewhere, generally a elected representative such as PM or President
So to conclude, for a stable economy Naruto can take the following steps :-
1) Ensure a cap is put on maximum number of Shinobis in each village. This detail can be finalised with round - table negotiations.
2) Enter into discussions with daimo or whatever to impose tax for ninja activities. The ninja would then only consider request from elected peoples representatives and not people directly. Also salary system should not be as per mission completed. This would address the need to wage war problem
3) Now since there is a cap on max shinobis, people find employment elsewhere.
4) Slowly shift the power centre to elected representative head system rather than the military or the shinobi head system
The thing which I have not issued here is the bijjus. I think they were most stable when they were evenly distributed, thus distributing powers. I still think that is how it should be. :sdo:
. Guess I am a fool. When the greatest of philosophers and anthropologists have no solutions, how can I expect Kishimoto to have one.
However I think this maybe one of the ways to look at the situation :-
1) Like in countries where no war is ensuing, militaries are kept up and research and development is still carried on. This does not mean that the country wage wars, however the military is kept paid and engaged and thus everyone is happy for the moment. So I think it would be in the best interest of people to keep the Shinobi system alive via donations, even if the Shinobis refuse to do certain unethical missions. This would at least keep them safe as they know there is an army of sorts protecting them.
2) Now the Ninja system has always been funded directly by people or beneficiaries. So there has only been incentive to accept missions, however unethical. That has to change. It has to become like it is in most countries. Ordinary citizens pay TAX and a part of tax is used to fund army. This is how it has to be in the Ninja countries. You want army to protect your borders ? Fine pay tax. This tax would fund army and no one would die hungry.
3) As it has been shown that the development is taking place and it has also been shown that lately Ninjas have been passive. So I think as per the laws of demand and supply, the more lucrative position would be that contributing in development. Hence majority of new gen youth should look for employment in these booming industries. Since temporary peace has been achieved, the intake of the Shinobi system must be much lower and thus more people should be encouraged to find job elsewhere. This would create a stable economic system in the world of no war.
4) Finally when most of the people have been employed in operations elsewhere, it is obvious that the power centre must also change from Hokage or shinobi to elsewhere, generally a elected representative such as PM or President
So to conclude, for a stable economy Naruto can take the following steps :-
1) Ensure a cap is put on maximum number of Shinobis in each village. This detail can be finalised with round - table negotiations.
2) Enter into discussions with daimo or whatever to impose tax for ninja activities. The ninja would then only consider request from elected peoples representatives and not people directly. Also salary system should not be as per mission completed. This would address the need to wage war problem
3) Now since there is a cap on max shinobis, people find employment elsewhere.
4) Slowly shift the power centre to elected representative head system rather than the military or the shinobi head system
The thing which I have not issued here is the bijjus. I think they were most stable when they were evenly distributed, thus distributing powers. I still think that is how it should be. :sdo:
RasenUchihaChaos
Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2012
- Messages
- 9,150
- Reaction score
- 702
Gato is the Is only man who didn't need the 5 villages to run his empire wonder what ever happened to his business and all that money
There will always be antagonists and criminals Naruto just wants to stop the world's major powers from waging relentless wars against each other for no greater cause. He's accomplishing this by befriending the other Kages and having regular Kage summits to maintain a mutual truce and help each other out. The world is far more stable than it used to be at the start of the story. However, ninjas are still needed, as long as chakra exists any crazy mother****er can achieve god mode and start killing weaklings like ants. We're about to see this again with evil Shisui.