[Discussion] Nothing wrong with this list IMO

[Legend Slayer]

One piece top fifty

1. Roger
2. Edward
3. Garp
4. Dragon
5. Shanks
6. Teach
7. Kaido
8. Mihawk
9. Sengoku
10. Charlotte
11. Sakazuki
12. Kuzan
13. Kong
14. Shiki
15. Reyleigh
16. Barsolino
17. Ryukugyo
18. Issho
19. Marco
20. Jozu
21. Benn
22. Sabo
23. Burgess
24. Luffy
25. Doflomingo
26. Kuma
27. Kid
28. Law
29. Zoro
30. Killer
31. Boa
32. Drake
33. Uroge
34. Crocodile
35. Ace
36. Vista
37. Jinbe
38. Vergo
39. Sanji
40. Apoo
41. Hawkins
42. Smoker
43. Megallen
44. Ceaser
45. Kinemon
46. Bartolomio
47. Cavendish
48. Daz
49. Ivankov
50. Momonga

 

[Wretched]

Who is avendish ?

 

[Legend Slayer]

Who is avendish ?

The guy with the split personalty (also known as Haukuba)

 

[I'm stupid real stupid]

Kaido>Shanks

 

[Legend Slayer]

Kaido>Shanks

We can't know that for sure right now, we do know however that their in the same tier

 

[Jinchuriki 10 Tails]

Sorry I don't watch this anime but when did luffy surpass ace?

 

[Legend Slayer]

Sorry I don't watch this anime but when did luffy surpass ace?

Over the 2 year time skip when he learned gear fourth

 

[Venomous Cobra]

So much wrong here, I can't believe the mihawk wank sometimes, how the **** can one put him avove big mam or even ****ing akainu????Not to mention how low sanji is considering he has enough speed not only blitz some of the people you mentioned but also beat them since he has haki over them. You put luffy above doffy when he clearly struggled to beat him with the help of law??nah doffy wins. Lol at zoro being above vista somehow, and yeah monster trio would beat all of those featless rookies so zoro goes up along with sanji and luffy.



This list is bad man no offense.

 

[Sheele]

Lmao crocodile above jinbei Gg.

 

[Darkboy85]

The guy with the split personalty (also known as Haukuba)

That would be cavendish then and hakuba (for the split persona)

 

[roncato]

Isn't Jose on par with Mihawk ?

 

[Wretched]

The guy with the split personalty (also known as Haukuba)

No shit

 

[Legend Slayer]

So much wrong here, I can't believe the mihawk wank sometimes, how the **** can one put him avove big mam or even ****ing akainu????Not to mention how low sanji is considering he has enough speed not only blitz some of the people you mentioned but also beat them since he has haki over them. You put luffy above doffy when he clearly struggled to beat him with the help of law??nah doffy wins. Lol at zoro being above vista somehow, and yeah monster trio would beat all of those featless rookies so zoro goes up along with sanji and luffy.



This list is bad man no offense.

Non taken. Mihawk is able to rival Shanks so his definitely Yonko level. Don't be so surprised if his top ten. I'm not sure about sanji's level. Vista is WB's best swordsman so his above zoro. As for doffy and luffy, I prefer to think it's a fair fight since doffy used his ability to repair himself. Luffy>mingo

Isn't Jose on par with Mihawk ?

Nope U_U

Lmao crocodile above jinbei Gg.

Croc is highly underestimated

 

[Sheele]

Croc is highly underestimated

Crocodile is weak against water.. Guess what jinbei his specialty is beside fish karate

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

All at their peaks:
1. Gol D. Roger
2. Edward Newgate
3. Monkey D. Dragon
4. Monkey D. Garp
5. Shiki
6. Sengoku
7. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
8. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
9. Kaidou/Shanks
10. Kaidou/Shanks
11. Sakazuki/Kong
12. Sakazuki/Kong
13. Kuzan
14. Issho
15. Big Mom (Charlotte Linlin)
16. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
17. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
18. Ryukugyu/Gabban
19. Ryukugyu/Gabban
20. Marco
21. Zephyr
22. Marshall D. Teach (soon to be a top 10)
23. Magellan
24. Shiliew
25. Sabo
26. Don Chinjao
27. Donquixote Doflamingo
28. Bartholomew Kuma
29. Jozu
30. Vista
31. Jesus Burgess
32. Boa Hancock
33. Momonga
34. Onigumo
35. Stainless
36. Strawberry
37. Comil
38. Yamakiji
39. Tsuru
40. Crocodile
41. Monkey D. Luffy
42. Eustass Kidd
43. Trafalgar D. Water Law
44. X Drake
45. Vergo
46. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
47. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
48. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
49. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
50. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace

You've forgotten about so many characters

 

[Caliburn]

It's a tier list, that in itself makes all of this very very wrong.

 

[Olorin]

Poor Sengoku, so underrated

If we're ranking power lvls Roger, Garp, Newgate and Sengoku should be in the same tier at least

I think doing an actual top X lost for OP makes no sense because more chars than just Roger fit into the "Tier 1" of OP, Roger prob wasnt the single strongest person alive, he had a few equals and more came after his time

PS: lol Sanji, Smoker and Magellan re ridiculously low on the list

 

[Forbidden Tale]

- Edward was stated to be equal with Roger.
- BB is last to become Yonko of all, I doubt he would be stronger than Kaido or Big Mom.
- Mihawk should be on par with Shanks.
- Sengoku, Sakazuki and Aokiji IMO should be above Kaido or Big Mom (for know).
- If you want to put Kong, than Kong should be alot above.
- Garp and Sengoku teamed up to take Shiki, he should be third.
- If you put Silvers in his prime than I think he should be a lot higher, if you put Old Silvers than he is below Borsalino.
- Marco around as powerful as Borsalino.
- Benn and Sabo above Jozu.

 

[roncato]

Nope U_U

Well, ok I exaggerated a little bit here.

Croc is highly underestimated

But Jinbei is really much stronger than Croc.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Well, ok I exaggerated a little bit here.



But Jinbei is really much stronger than Croc.

Marineford and Impel Down arcs disagree