[Question] What is the most illogical moment in One Piece?

[ayush0735]

For me, it is related to the Dressrosa arc where Sugar was unconscious because Usopp blurted out 'FIRE'

 

[Punk Hazard]

For me, it is related to the Dressrosa arc where Sugar was unconscious because Usopp blurted out 'FIRE'

That's...not what happened but alright.

OT: Anytime Sanji bursts into flames when angry. I'm sure Oda has an explanation for it, and I really hope he does, but this takes the cake.

 

[Complex]

That's...not what happened but alright.

OT: Anytime Sanji bursts into flames when angry. I'm sure Oda has an explanation for it, and I really hope he does, but this takes the cake.

Guys it's just for a comedic relief

 

[ayush0735]

Umm..what happened then reli? In the anime, they showed it this way

 

[Punk Hazard]

Guys it's just for a comedic relief

Do you mean the Sugar thing, or the Sanji thing? Either way, ¨for comedic relief¨ doesn't mean it's not illogical.

Umm..what happened then reli? In the anime, they showed it this way

Usopp's face while yelling fire terrified Sugar, causing her to faint.

 

[ayush0735]

Usopp's face while yelling fire terrified Sugar, causing her to faint.

Ohkk.. Will still say its illogical for someone strong to faint like that.. Otherwise girls would have ruled the OP world..lol

 

[xanonymosx]

Guys it's just for a comedic relief

but that comedic relife burnt a giant fish and that did hurt :|

 

[Punk Hazard]

Ohkk.. Will still say its illogical for someone strong to faint like that.. Otherwise girls would have ruled the OP world..lol

Strong? Not really the word to describe Sugar. Hax is more accurate. Plus she has the body of a child so

 

[Complex]

but that comedic relife burnt a giant fish and that did hurt :|

Really? My memory is horrible when it comes to pre time skip, or did this happen in the time skip?

 

[ayush0735]

Strong? Not really the word to describe Sugar. Hax is more accurate. Plus she has the body of a child so

Well she is not strong like Trebol..but she is still able to fight well..I will put her on par with Nami (chapter 738)

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Both Zoro's Asura and Sanji's Diable Jambe was illogical to me. If you assume Asura was the curse of Sandai Kitetsu then maybe. Only answer I can come up with that both techniques are the physical manifestations of Zoro and Sanji's CoC.

 

[ayush0735]

Both Zoro's Asura and Sanji's Diable Jambe was illogical to me. If you assume Asura was the curse of Sandai Kitetsu then maybe. Only answer I can come up with that both techniques are the physical manifestations of Zoro and Sanji's CoC.

Do you mean CoA? Samji and Zoro have not shown to be using CoC

 

[Complex]

Idk why people be adding logic to fiction

 

[ayush0735]

Idk why people be adding logic to fiction

Because a good fiction should not have plot holes or things that cannot be explained with the hypothetical universe

 

[Punk Hazard]

Idk why people be adding logic to fiction

It's sure better than accepting every inconsistency and illogical event by going ¨It's fiction.¨ A good author should be able to explain most things, if not everything, within the logic of the universe of his work.

 

[xanonymosx]

Really? My memory is horrible when it comes to pre time skip, or did this happen in the time skip?

post time skip
sanji vs wadatsumi

sanji remembers the hard time in okama land then he set himself on fire and finishs him (hells memory) i mean i would understand if he hit zoro or any other SH and consider it comedic relief but to be used as finisher move against an enemy ...

 

[Complex]

post time skip
sanji vs wadatsumi

sanji remembers the hard time in okama land then he set himself on fire and finishs him (hells memory) i mean i would understand if he hit zoro or any other SH and consider it comedic relief but to be used as finisher move against an enemy ...

Oh yeah now I remember. I actually don't know why, but if sanji could yet his foot on fire without them getting burned, I'm pretty sure he could do the same to his body.

 

[Complex]

It's sure better than accepting every inconsistency and illogical event by going ¨It's fiction.¨ A good author should be able to explain most things, if not everything, within the logic of the universe of his work.

I can't disagree there.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

Do you mean CoA? Samji and Zoro have not shown to be using CoC

I 100% mean CoC as I think both of them will unlock it. The PK crew had 2 CoC users so why not 3 for the SHs? Shanks already shown that CoC can have a physical from of some kind since his CoC caused physical damage to WB's ship.

 

[Dãrth1]

From what I understood, Zoro's Asura was that Kaku was seeing him as the demon Asura, but Zoro was only using 9 swords, Diable Jambe was caused by friction, I really don't know how it didn't burn Sanji