Why do people think Madara didn't have his own Rinne Sharingan?

[griffnat13]

Title. He opened his own. Kaguya used his when she took over. Hers was sealed long ago... Why do people think there was only one?

 

[Mikeuhsomething36]

Actually the rinne sharnningan madara opened was from the juubi, which is technically from Kaguya, so Madara didn't awaken his own, that's like saying Madara's rinnegan stemmed from his own power when in reality it stemmed from hagoromo's.

 

[Limbo]

They're haters, they are still butthurt from when Madara negged their fave.

 

[V h o]

Because Madara absorbed kaguya prior to awakening that eye Lol

 

[Chaosmark101]

What Mikehue said. Every ninja, and human in this manga borrowed from the Juubi since Hagoromo spread his Chakra amongst everyone when teaching ninshu

 

[griffnat13]

Actually the rinne sharnningan madara opened was from the juubi, which is technically from Kaguya, so Madara didn't awaken his own, that's like saying Madara's rinnegan stemmed from his own power when in reality it stemmed from hagoromo's.

What Mikehue said. Every ninja, and human in this manga borrowed from the Juubi since Hagoromo spread his Chakra amongst everyone when teaching ninshu

That'd be like saying sasuke's sharingan isn't his own??

 

[Itachi 4 life]

They're still bitter that Madara negs their faves.

 

[rinnegan human puppet]

madara negged their fav.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

That'd be like saying sasuke's sharingan isn't his own??

Well it isn't anymore. It's Itachi's.

 

[Zawerni]

The Rinne Sharingan is the Juubi's eye.

Kaguya is the Juubi.

 

[griffnat13]

Well it isn't anymore. It's Itachi's.

Is it?

 

[Deadmed]

It could be either way, we can't know for sure because madara didn't use it. If he had and its powers were different than Kaguya's it'd be safe to say he had his own.

 

[Seventh Sama]

He did awaken it but he can't use it's main abilities.

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

Is it?

Pretty Much.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[griffnat13]

Pretty Much.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

lol clever but Sasuke's eye is just a rinnegan

 

[WalksInShadows]

Actually the rinne sharnningan madara opened was from the juubi, which is technically from Kaguya, so Madara didn't awaken his own, that's like saying Madara's rinnegan stemmed from his own power when in reality it stemmed from hagoromo's.

Because Madara absorbed kaguya prior to awakening that eye Lol

seeing as though that eye appeared when Madara got close enough to the moon and not when he became JJ/absorbed the Shinju, it's his. More to the point, if it wasn't his, the DB would've stated such a thing by not listing Madara as a separate user of that eye or by stating it in his article. You 2 are basically saying Madara's Rinnegan pair isn't his own and someone else's, despite having to personally go through all of the trouble and effort it took to have those as well.

 

[V h o]

seeing as though that eye appeared when Madara got close enough to the moon and not when he became JJ/absorbed the Shinju, it's his. More to the point, if it wasn't his, the DB would've stated such a thing by not listing Madara as an separate different user of that eye or by stating it in his article. You 2 are basically saying Madara's Rinnegan pair isn't his own and someone else's, despite having to go personally through all of the trouble and effort it took to have those as well.

It's his regardless, he had it in his possession. I'm just highlighting the fact that Madara absorbed Kaguya prior to the eye showing, and his reasoning (getting close to the moon) was whispered by BZ-the grand architect to revive his mother Lol