[Discussion] Rank the SHs and DD Pirates

Uzumaki Macho

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Reaction score
299
Here's my list.

1. Doflamingo
2. Luffy
3. Zoro
4. Vergo
5. Sanji
6. Pica
7. Trebol
8. Diamanté
9. Gladius
10. Franky
11. Lao G
12. Robin
13. Brook
14. Dellinger
15. Señor Pink
16. Monet
17. Chopper
18. Baby 5
19. Jora
20. Nami
21. Usopp
22. Sugar
23. Machvise
24. Viola
25. Buffalo
 
Last edited:

A v i

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Reaction score
175
I pretty much agree with your list. We haven't seen anything from Sanji that could take down Pica though.
 

Venomous Cobra

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
15,664
Reaction score
1,229
God USSOP 5000000 beri
Doffy
Luffy
Zoro
Sanji/vergo
Vergo/sanji
Pica
Gladius
Terbol
Franky
Senor pink
Diamante
Lao G
Robin
Brook
Monet
Nami
Sugar
Dellinger
Viola
 

Limbo

Banned
Elite
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
6,889
Reaction score
589
*****h i dont know all da names of dat fodder dd

sh are
1. Luffy
2. Zoro

3. Sanji
4. doesn't matter
5. doesn't matter
6. doesn't matter
 

Venomous Cobra

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
15,664
Reaction score
1,229
I pretty much agree with your list. We haven't seen anything from Sanji that could take down Pica though.

Pre skip sanji deflected oz bazooka with only one kick.The big chunk of rock isn't doing anything to him That's if he can even see sanji while using sky walk. Lol
 

Tomato God

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
3,421
Reaction score
185
Pre skip sanji deflected oz bazooka with only one kick.The big chunk of rock isn't doing anything to him That's if he can even see sanji while using sky walk. Lol

This.


OT: I agree With your list but I would put a fresh sanji above a fresh vergo

Sanji was so weak that name could put him down with a punch and he still managed to beat vergo into a wall then fight with him on par with a shattered leg still save everyone and stop vergo from killing the G5. On one foot

Get out my face if you think a fully charged sanji couldn't demolish vergo.

Also I would put robin above trebol. There is no reason she can't use giantos manos to just squish him.

And You forgot the w3
But If I would add them it would be like this

1. Doflamingo
2. Luffy
3. Zoro
4.Sanji
5. Vergo
6. Pica
7. Diamanté
8. Robin
9. Trebol
10. Franky
11. Brook
12.Gladius
13.Lao G
14. Monet
15. Dellinger
16. Señor Pink
17. Chopper
18. Nami
19. Usopp
20. Baby 5
21. Jora
22. Sugar
23. Machvise
24. Viola
25. Buffalo

Actually Now that I think about it... I completely disagree with your list
 

Uzumaki Macho

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Reaction score
299
This.


OT: I agree With your list but I would put a fresh sanji above a fresh vergo

Sanji was so weak that name could put him down with a punch and he still managed to beat vergo into a wall then fight with him on par with a shattered leg still save everyone and stop vergo from killing the G5. On one foot

Get out my face if you think a fully charged sanji couldn't demolish vergo.

Also I would put robin above trebol. There is no reason she can't use giantos manos to just squish him.

And You forgot the w3
But If I would add them it would be like this

1. Doflamingo
2. Luffy
3. Zoro
4.Sanji
5. Vergo
6. Pica
7. Diamanté
8. Robin
9. Trebol
10. Franky
11. Brook
12.Gladius
13.Lao G
14. Monet
15. Dellinger
16. Señor Pink
17. Chopper
18. Nami
19. Usopp
20. Baby 5
21. Jora
22. Sugar
23. Machvise
24. Viola
25. Buffalo

Actually Now that I think about it... I completely disagree with your list

Yea being hit by Gastanet must have done a whole lot of damage. How does Robin, Franky, or Brook beat Gladius? How does Nami or Usopp beat Baby 5?
 

chopstickchakra

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Reaction score
1,012
Here's my list.

1. Doflamingo
2. Luffy
3. Zoro
4. Vergo
5. Sanji
6. Pica
7. Trebol
8. Diamanté
9. Gladius
10. Franky
11. Lao G
12. Robin
13. Brook
14. Dellinger
15. Señor Pink
16. Monet
17. Chopper
18. Baby 5
19. Jora
20. Nami
21. Usopp
22. Sugar
23. Machvise
24. Viola
25. Buffalo

I'm not gonna sit here and nit pick or argue about placing but I do want to point out a list like this may not be that meaningful when lower characters could beat higher characters.

First I would like to ask though, why Doffy over Luffy? We all know Luffy's gonna beat him and he'll do it tired and injured. Wouldn't that stand to reason then that healthy Luffy>healthy Doffy(who hadn't taken any real damage especially when compared to Luffy)

Secondly, you've said and it seems the consensus agrees that Gladius is DD's sniper(not arguing) so if he's the sniper we know Usopp is a greater sniper than he is and we arguably knew that in Part 1 at Enies Lobby. In a sniper battle Usopp would definitely take him.

You put Pink under Dellinger, Dellinger had a weaker showing fighting Bellamy where Pink fought Franky, Franky is definitely the tougher opponent in those scenarios. Pink had a better skill and would be able to hide from Dellinger. Why is Dellinger above Pink? Also Dellinger was one shotted while Pink went toe to toe round for round with a cyborg powered by Vegapunk tech.

I would Machvise should probably be up at 19 and everyone pushed down a number since he's stronger than them(and don't bring up that same tired he hurts his belly stuff)
 

24 12 11 to troll

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Dec 24, 2011
Messages
11,214
Reaction score
486
1. Donquixote Doflamingo
2. Monkey D. Luffy
3. Trafalgar Law (defected)
4. Roronoa Zoro
5. Sanji
6. Vergo
7. Pica
8. Diamante
9. Trebol
10. Donquixote Rosinante (defected)
11. Monet
12. Caesar (defected)
13. Franky
14. Senor Pink
15. Gladius
16. Nico Robin
18. Lao G
19. Brook
20. Machvise
21. Dellinger
22. Bellamy
23. Sugar
24. Chopper
25. Baby 5
26. Buffalo
27. Nami
28. Usopp
29. Kyuin
 

Uzumaki Macho

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Reaction score
299
I'm not gonna sit here and nit pick or argue about placing but I do want to point out a list like this may not be that meaningful when lower characters could beat higher characters.

First I would like to ask though, why Doffy over Luffy? We all know Luffy's gonna beat him and he'll do it tired and injured. Wouldn't that stand to reason then that healthy Luffy>healthy Doffy(who hadn't taken any real damage especially when compared to Luffy)

Secondly, you've said and it seems the consensus agrees that Gladius is DD's sniper(not arguing) so if he's the sniper we know Usopp is a greater sniper than he is and we arguably knew that in Part 1 at Enies Lobby. In a sniper battle Usopp would definitely take him.

You put Pink under Dellinger, Dellinger had a weaker showing fighting Bellamy where Pink fought Franky, Franky is definitely the tougher opponent in those scenarios. Pink had a better skill and would be able to hide from Dellinger. Why is Dellinger above Pink? Also Dellinger was one shotted while Pink went toe to toe round for round with a cyborg powered by Vegapunk tech.

I would Machvise should probably be up at 19 and everyone pushed down a number since he's stronger than them(and don't bring up that same tired he hurts his belly stuff)

Doflamingo was injured by Law before the fight.

Usopp has more skills in marksmanship, but Gladius is definitely stronger than Usopp.

Dellinger negged Ideo and several others. He is faster than Pink and has stronger attacks. The only thing Pink has over him is endurance.

Jora and Sugar turn Machvise into a toy or art. Nami or Usopp are debatable.
 

Uzumaki Macho

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Reaction score
299
1. Donquixote Doflamingo
2. Monkey D. Luffy
3. Trafalgar Law (defected)
4. Roronoa Zoro
5. Sanji
6. Vergo
7. Pica
8. Diamante
9. Trebol
10. Donquixote Rosinante (defected)
11. Monet
12. Caesar (defected)
13. Franky
14. Senor Pink
15. Gladius
16. Nico Robin
18. Lao G
19. Brook
20. Machvise
21. Dellinger
22. Bellamy
23. Sugar
24. Chopper
25. Baby 5
26. Buffalo
27. Nami
28. Usopp
29. Kyuin

Pink is way too high.
 

chopstickchakra

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Reaction score
1,012
Doflamingo was injured by Law before the fight.

Usopp has more skills in marksmanship, but Gladius is definitely stronger than Usopp.

Dellinger negged Ideo and several others. He is faster than Pink and has stronger attacks. The only thing Pink has over him is endurance.

Jora and Sugar turn Machvise into a toy or art. Nami or Usopp are debatable.

Doffy's injuries can't really be compared to Luffy's he fought the entire time while Doffy essentially tortured Law while Law was lucky to get a few hits in. But it's your opinion so fair enough we'll leave it there.

Gladius is stronger and if he got in CQC of course he'd win but in a battle between snipers that point is moot, IF Usopp and Gladius got into a fight with their skills they're recognized for(sniping) Usopp would beat Gladius that's all I'm saying I think we can both acknowledge that to be true, yeah?

He negged nobodies though, none of those people would have beaten Franky or are at his level of skill. We only really saw one attack from Pink I'm sure he has others everybody in the manga has a variation of attacks. Pink also has his DF over Dellinger, Dellinger would have to kick through the Earth to hit a swimming Senor.

Sugar could in theory but that's what his shield is for, it would stop her from touching him during his attack. Plus he's stronger, and could beat more opponents than she could beat doesn't that in and of itself mean he should have a higher ranking? But then again that would just prove my point earlier that lower rankings can beat higher rankings in a fight.

I guess I'm confused about the criteria for the list is the placement dependent on how they would fair against the others listed or in general? Because like I said Vise could beat more people than Sugar. You may be right about Jora beating Vise since her style is more distance(not a great distance but still a distance) while Vise has to jump on you to fight.
 

A v i

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Reaction score
175
Pre skip sanji deflected oz bazooka with only one kick.The big chunk of rock isn't doing anything to him That's if he can even see sanji while using sky walk. Lol

Oz gets crushed by Pica. Oz is nowhere near Pica.Sanji used one of his best moves to deflect Oz where as Zoro casually did it and same Zoro post TS was forced to use some of his best moves to beat Pica. Latest chapter pretty much conformed that it was Pica,Diamante and Trebol that trained Vergo and Joker means that Vergo and Joker learned haki from Pica.

Besides I said Sanji didn't display anything that makes him beat Pica so I don't give two craps about Pica not being able to see Sanji while using sky walk. All of Cp9 members can use it before TS still they didn't managed to do jack to SH's yet out of nowhere it makes a difference when Sanji uses sky walk? wow
 

Hexuze

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Reaction score
1,533
Gladius wank is strong with that list.
 
Top