Hinata and Sakura comparison

[Complex]

He did not state that at all. Go find the link, I dare ya. He only drew the cover art, much like he has done for the other novels that are not canon either.

Considering that he actually worked on the script and called it 699.5, I would suppose it is

It was stated in December. I got no time to search that way back, but kish confirmed he had some involvement with the novels.

 

[lndra]

It was stated in December. I got no time to search that way back, but kish confirmed he had some involvement with the novels.

False. December was when the Last information was coming out, and Kishimoto had also stated that he was working on Part 3. The novels are not canon, and were proved so by an article of him not involvedin them. Other authors were.

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

Kishimoto contributed to the artwork. A man known around the Naruto community known as OrganicDinosaur who has translated 2 already, also stated that Kishimoto had not worked, nor helped in any way, shape, or form. So, come again?

 

[Complex]

False. December was when the Last information was coming out, and Kishimoto had also stated that he was working on Part 3. The novels are not canon, and were proved so by an article of him not involvedin them. Other authors were.

You must be registered for see links

Kishimoto contributed to the artwork. A man known around the Naruto community known as OrganicDinosaur who has translated 2 already, also stated that Kishimoto had not worked, nor helped in any way, shape, or form. So, come again?

I'm pretty sure it was the novels or was it the last novel

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Its officially approved by Kishi and dubbed by him chapter 699.5. He also reviewed and wrote the script several times for the film. Show me anywhere Kishi approved of these novels. Their basically fanfiction from different authors.

It's obvisouly not fan fiction if it's taken so seriously, it's an official novel for the series, it was never stated that it's not canon, plus he worked on the art, he had some influence on it

 

[Guitar Hero]

It was stated in December. I got no time to search that way back, but kish confirmed he had some involvement with the novels.

Are you actually gonna provide a source or simply state baseless assumptions? These novels are nothing but fanfiction until shown otherwise .

It's obvisouly not fan fiction if it's taken so seriously, it's an official novel for the series, it was never stated that it's not canon

And it was never as canon. Are the shippuden fillers canon because they were never stated otherwise. These are fanficiton, try again

 

[Complex]

Are you actually gonna provide a source or simply state baseless assumptions? These novels arenothing but fanfiction until shown otherwise .

They're not fanfiction, kishi obviously had some involvement in these novels

 

[SPIRTofleo]

False. December was when the Last information was coming out, and Kishimoto had also stated that he was working on Part 3. The novels are not canon, and were proved so by an article of him not involvedin them. Other authors were.

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

Kishimoto contributed to the artwork. A man known around the Naruto community known as OrganicDinosaur who has translated 2 already, also stated that Kishimoto had not worked, nor helped in any way, shape, or form. So, come again?

Where in this article does it say, that kishimoto never contributed to it?, he included it as the "Naruto franchise" and said that he has other things that he's working on

 

[lndra]

They're not fanfiction, kishi obviously had some involvement in these novels

He had only made the cover art. These novels are not canon. Each novel is written by a different author who is not Kishimoto.

Use some common sense.

Where in this article does it say, that kishimoto never contributed to it?, he included it as the "Naruto franchise" and said that he has other things that he's working on

Do you want every article that states he never wrote them, nor helped write them? Are you serious? Anything that has NARUTO in it is in the Naruto Franchise, same with the Sasuke novel that came out so many years ago. Was not canon either.

Exactly. He is working on Part 3.

 

[Guitar Hero]

They're not fanfiction, kishi obviously had some involvement in these novels

Again can you prove it, apparently he even said he did? Give me a source or statement other than your baseless assumptions.

 

[Complex]

He had only made the cover art. These novels are not canon. Each novel is written by a different author who is not Kishimoto.

Use some common sense.


Do you want every article that states he never wrote them, nor helped write them? Are you serious? Anything that has NARUTO in it is in the Naruto Franchise, same with the Sasuke novel that came out so many years ago. Was not canon either.

Exactly. He is working on Part 3.

You're obviously not using common sense. You think that if they were to have questions they wouldn't ask kishi? I'm pretty sure kishi had involvement in the novels, just like he had involvement in the last novel

 

[SPIRTofleo]

Are you actually gonna provide a source or simply state baseless assumptions? These novels are nothing but fanfiction until shown otherwise .



And it was never as canon. Are the shippuden fillers canon because they were never stated otherwise. These are fanficiton, try again

Unlike fillers, the events sound realistic and shows actual times of what has happened in the manga, (Naruto becoming hokage, Kakashi becoming Hokage, Sasuke going on his journey, everyone k11 kids) and etc, it would be different if the novels were about something illogical, like Naruto going on a journey to the underwater kingdom or something, but it's telling about real things that happened

 

[Complex]

Again can you prove it, apparently he even said he did? Give me a source or statement other than your baseless assumptions.

I'll try

 

[lndra]

You're obviously not using common sense. You think that if they were to have questions they wouldn't ask kishi? I'm pretty sure kishi had involvement in the novels, just like he had involvement in the last novel

Kishimoto was not involved in the novels at all. He was involved in the Last of course, but the novels are not canon. Aside from the cover art, he contributed to nothing. Of course they could of asked him for help, but that still does not change the outcome. The Sasuke novel was not made by Kishimoto either, and it was not canon either. Come again? Use some common sense

Go look for information on it being canon. You won't find anything

 

[Guitar Hero]

Unlike fillers, the events sound realistic and shows actual times of what has happened in the manga, (Naruto becoming hokage, Kakashi becoming Hokage, Sasuke going on his journey, everyone k11 kids) and etc, it would be different if the novels were about something illogical, like Naruto going on a journey to the underwater kingdom or something, but it's telling about real things that happened

None of these even happens in the novels, alot of the shippuden have realistic events and have actual times of what happened in the manga Lol. Yet they arent canon. They are written by several different authors that arent Kishimoto, these novels are fanfiction and you cant prove otherwise(other that your baselss assumptions and delusions).

 

[Complex]

Kishimoto was not involved in the novels at all. He was involved in the Last of course, but the novels are not canon. Aside from the cover art, he contributed to nothing. Of course they could of asked him for help, but that still does not change the outcome. The Sasuke novel was not made by Kishimoto either, and it was not canon either. Come again? Use some common sense

Go look for information on it being canon. You won't find anything

Okay I will look

 

[Arima]

bullshit thread

 

[Melanin]

Sakura holds down a medical career, parental duties, beauty and the domestic care for her home.

Hinata?

 

[SPIRTofleo]

None of these even happens in the novels, alot of the shippuden have realistic events and have actual times of what happened in the manga Lol. Yet they arent canon. They are written by several different authors that arent Kishimoto, these novels are fanfiction and you cant prove otherwise(other that your baselss assumptions and delusions).

Just because kishimoto did not write them, that doesn't mean they can't be Canon, he just has to give them permission for it to be in the story, that's just like his editors giving him ideas for the story and possibly writing them down for him, does that mean it's not canon because he did not think of the ideas?, no, he just has to allow it to be in the story, plus this is not the main component of my thread of saying Sakura>Hinata, so we're just getting off topic of the main source

 

[lndra]

Just because kishimoto did not write them, that doesn't mean they can't be Canon, he just has to give them permission for it to be in the story, that's just like his editors giving him ideas for the story and possibly writing them down for him, does that mean it's not canon because he did not think of the ideas?, no, he just has to allow it to be in the story, plus this is not the main component of my thread of saying Sakura>Hinata, so we're just getting off topic of the main source

Except the fact that if Kishimoto does not write them, they are not canon. The novelists who wrote the past novels were given permission to, yet they were not canon. I agree if you like Sakura, then you must think she is above Hinata. Go figure, no one cares. Both females are arguably horrible characters.

Sakura holds down a medical career, parental duties, beauty and the domestic care for her home.

Hinata?

Sakura holds down a medical career? Possibly, given that she is one of the best female medical shinobi in the land.
Parental duties? I would believe they are both great mothers.
Beauty? They are both beautiful. Well Kishimoto stated that he had to make one gorgeous to combat the hate. How do you think it is working as a Sakura fan?
Domestic care for the home? I would believe it would both be the same, considering the type of house Naruto lives in now. I would assume they are all happy.

 

[Zef]

Another thread in which Indra is asshurt over these novels. Lol

As usual everything you're saying is outdated, and false.