Shikamaru's novel has incorrect facts

[Icelerate]

How could that not be enough to discredit it when the information is based of non-canon material?

Because it doesn't contradict manga canon. The 4th databook has information that didn't happen in the canon manga but happened in fillers, yet because it doesn't contradict the manga, it can be included.

 

[lndra]

Because it doesn't contradict manga canon. The 4th databook has information that didn't happen in the canon manga but happened in fillers, yet because it doesn't contradict the manga, it can be included.

How does it not contradict with the manga when Naruto is performing jutsu by twisting his fingers, Gai is walking despite his legs being broken or shattered during Madara vs. Gai, and the list goes on?

 

[Icelerate]

How does it not contradict with the manga when Naruto is performing jutsu by twisting his fingers, Gai is walking despite his legs being broken or shattered during Madara vs. Gai, and the list goes on?

I haven't read that but those are minor details that can be overlooked. Didn't the manga say that Hagoromo sealed the Juubi by himself on his death bed and created the Moon as a result but then it was stated him and Hamura used their seals to seal away Kaguya and form the Moon that way.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

The novels are not canon. So not sure why you are suprised?

 

[lndra]

I haven't read that but those are minor details that can be overlooked. Didn't the manga say that Hagoromo sealed the Juubi by himself on his death bed and created the Moon as a result but then it was stated him and Hamura used their seals to seal away Kaguya and form the Moon that way.

Then you are wasting my time. You should have read them before to figure out why the entire book is not canon. Right?

 

[Ken Kaneki]

The novels are not canon. Of course there will be inconsistencies.
Watch the Last. Some parts of it are canon.

(Hahahahahaha)

 

[Angelic.]

probably got his info wrong and means 10,000 survivors. good job author guy

 

[Icelerate]

probably got his info wrong and means 10,000 survivors. good job author guy

That would make sense or it might be a translation error.