[Discussion] One piece vs naruto [review]

[bdm]

started one piece around feb 1st week and finished on 23 feb. [both animie and manga].without skipping any episode or chapter and updated myself to the current scenario.
imagine on which rate i was watching it.

btw my ratings are-

comedy- op>>>>>naruto
story- naruto>=op
emotion- naruto>>>op.[but some scenes are way too better then naruto]
power distribution - naruto>>>>>>>>op
character drawing - image wise- naruto>>>op
character importance /development- op>>>>naruto
character sexiness - op>>>>naruto
anime quality - naruto>>>op
music - op>>>naruto
main char - naruto > op
villeins - naruto > op [till now ,bt currently doffy is doning excellent and i m just waiting for kaido ans black beard.]

conclusion- op is more interesting.but naruto was more touching.

 

[iNotorious]

That grammar is a let down.

But yeah I do agree with your score of drawing/animation.

 

[Hexuze]

One Piece beats Naruto in all aspects IMO.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

One piece is overall better

 

[FubukiShirou]

Soundtracks? I'm pretty sure Naruto has one of the most amazing soundtracks made in the anime industry... so I dont even know what you're talking about.

 

[Olorin]

this thread is a really bad idea but still, for me (and only me) ...

comedy: OP > Naruto
story: OP > Naruto
emotion: OP > Naruto
power distribution: I have no idea what you mean, but sensible power scale OP > Naruto
character designs: OP > Naruto
art: OP > Naruto
character development: OP > Naruto
anime quality: neither does the manga justice
music: I honestly have no idea
main character: OP > Naruto
villains: OP > Naruto>every villain ever>Obito

 

[P3ĮÑ]

this thread is a really bad idea but still, for me (and only me) ...

comedy: OP > Naruto
story: OP > Naruto
emotion: OP > Naruto
power distribution: I have no idea what you mean, but sensible power scale OP > Naruto
character designs: OP > Naruto
art: OP > Naruto
character development: OP > Naruto
anime quality: neither does the manga justice
music: I honestly have no idea
main character: OP > Naruto
villains: OP > Naruto>every villain ever>Obito

For me as well.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Naruto doesn't have better emotional scenes.

 

[silmarill]

For me as well.

for me to only OP music > Naruto aswell .-. If there is one thing the anime does justice it's the absolutely phenomonal ost's
It's a friggin symphony like u see in those big hollywood movies like LOTR or jurasic park
anyway like Algalon said , this thread is a bad idea

 

[iNotorious]

Although naruto is better than one piece.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

*thread reported

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

villains: OP > Naruto>every villain ever>Obito>>>>>>>Kaguya

Fixed it for you.

 

[Red Flag X Drake]

... how does Naruto have a better story and better power distribution?

 

[Desiigner]

The only thing that Naruto has over OP is the art and Sasuke.

 

[Hexuze]

Lol at people saying Naruto has better art.

 

[Desiigner]

Lol at people saying Naruto has better art.

And? Some people like it, Some Not. What is there to laugh about ?

 

[I'm stupid real stupid]

OP>Naruto, It is the best selling manga
Thank you for sharing and its cute if you think this would change somebody's opinion :vision:

Also you forgot to mention Zoro>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Narutoverse neg diff

 

[Red Flag X Drake]

The only thing that Naruto has over OP is the art and Sasuke.

Not really. The art in naruto isn't that great. In one piece Oda goes all out. The background is always hella detailed. Also Zoro> emo kid who ran away from home

 

[Hexuze]

And? Some people like it, Some Not. What is there to laugh about ?

Yeah, I understand it's your opinion and all but Naruto's art feels pretty lazy at times.

 

[Desiigner]

Not really. The art in naruto isn't that great. In one piece Oda goes all out. The background is always hella detailed. Also Zoro> emo kid who ran away from home

How exactly did He ran away from home, even though He didn't have one to begin with?
And just because you simply don't understand his character, there's no need to try to downgrade him. If you don't like him, just keep your mouth shut. This is not a Zoro vs Sasuke thread.

Yeah, I understand it's your opinion and all but Naruto's art feels pretty lazy at times.

True, Naruto's Art is a lot simpler, while OP's' is more detailed.