Is Sakura good at CQC?

Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276
I decided to read the re-read the manga from the beginning of Shippuden, about a month or two ago. So I've saved some particular manga panels that involve Sakura's abilities in close combat, and she seems un-trained at the sort.

/Inb4 Sasori scans -- These are post-Sasori, meaning up-to-date information on her abilities

Anyway I'm going to break some of these manga panels down

I.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

I don't know what was going through her mind at this time, but she definitely wasn't using her brain. I would just like to explain the events afterwards, but I also wanted everyone to peak into the mind of Sakura when she is forced to think in such situations. The tails seem to move at a normal speed, especially towards their pivot. However through the shifts Sakura SHOULD have been able to notice the tail aiming at her with a horizontal swing. At least, she could of punched it, instead she ran directly at it. I don't understand.


II.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Now what we have here is Naruto/Sai/Sakura vs Omoi and Karui. Mind you these two were feat-less at this time (I believe)

Now to break down the fight: Naruto really is a genius here..

First, Naruto grabbed Sai's katana with his left hand (referring size is a normal chokutō), at that same second he pivoted his body towards the left, as his right hand reached Sakura's mid-section he pushed her outwards with his following right hand. He then proceeded to swing the sword vertically aiming a lowering positioning to counter-strike the sword that was pointed at Sakura at a second before.

Karui was shocked, indefinitely as you see her face through the panel she almost did not notice the transition as Naruto is experienced in close combat. Naruto then quickly began to move forward while pointing out his right elbow to slam directly into her upper chest. However, Omoi who was standing beside her quickly took action. He knew he couldn't stop Naruto with his weapon because he had to unsheathe it, so he took the handle and countered the elbow with it alone.

After getting countered Karui then uses Omoi as a way of turning her body against his own, Naruto noticing their movement proceeds to use the Shadow Clone seal with his hands which are positioned directly near each-other
Making her on his right side now, she decides to strike Naruto with a horizontal arc swing. The clone comes at the same second the arc is forming, and the Clone slams both his hands directly at the swing and stops it.

Mind you only a few seconds have passed since Naruto took Sai's sword. Then, Sai and Sakura proceed to take the enemy down by circling around them to strike at their sides. Which was smart. However, Omoi again much like what Karui did a moment ago, uses her as a stool to jump passed Sai's initial mid-roundhouse kick, and aims a direct kick at Sakura who yelled charging in to strike Karui. She then flies backwards while the real Naruto moves at a rate where he was able to catch her before she stops, take notice that he started moving after she was sent flying.

Now I don't really understand Sakura here. Neither of the shinobi yelled or provided the other with a notion that they were going to strike. They just moved. Omoi was able to jump from Karui to strike Sakura, the same shinobi that tried the same thing on Naruto, except it was Karui using Omoi. She should have noticed his linear jump towards her, instead she got sent flying. Which is truly disappointing.



I'll wrap it up here because I noticed I wrote too much. The last few manga panels were going to be about Sakura's mentality and physical abilities in the Sasuke fight, but I'll end it on a recent panel.

III.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Now let's scratch off Sakura's mental strategy here. Any focus on that will result in me sounding as if I am character bashing, which is not my initial basis here.

Sakura begins the initiation by running towards Madara with her hands at her side. Now look above again when she reaches Madara: As she reaches Madara's vicinity, she performs a jump while keeping a foot distance between them. I don't understand why. Sakura has shown to be extremely powerful, but she also must know by now that Madara is immortal and can possibly regenerate. However, with or without that information her bodily reaction and reactions towards this scene are completely unorthodox. Shinobi know better than to jump at an enemy who has a weapon at-hand, as obvious to the scene, Madara strikes Sakura without trying. Literally as skillful as Madara is in close combat, in the Manga panel he only raised his hand in conjunction to her attack.

Now, I believe that Sakura jumped at Madara knowing she could possibly heal her injuries in case this situation came into play, which it did. She then begins to punch, however as her arm moves backwards, Madara's manga panel has the exclamation mark. This should be obvious, but with her speed she should never have the capabilities to surprise Madara with that attack. Knowing that much, she again seems to be underestimating her battle prowess and she isn't making it easier on herself by being holstered in the air by his black rod alone. Though he stands there knowing fully that Limbo would tank her hits, which they did. Whether Limbo Madara got sent back flying is speculation, however if I remember correctly those black rods might of disrupted her chakra flow resulting in her attacks being less potent.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Conclusion:
Without a doubt Sakura is a strong shinobi; Being a disciple of Tsunade that alone ranks her above her peers in the K11. When it comes to actual combat, fighting skill, and ability Sakura does not seem to have that expertise to fight against shinobi. I feel as if that is her strongest weakness. She may be strong enough to destroy an enemy with one hit, but she yet provides any growth in which she can fight an actual shinobi with feats by herself or with teammates giving her an edge (Excluding Kaguya. That one was ... rigged lol.)

So I can say with actual confidence that most shinobi can actually take down Sakura with skill, but Sakura herself is negated from that outcome by having regenerative properties. If someone was able to stop the flow of her chakra, it would most definitely be game over. Thanks for reading my thread, I hope you enjoyed it.

Note: Please no character bashing comments.
 
Last edited:

To Whatever

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 27, 2013
Messages
18,010
Reaction score
1,512
Seeing how most of her fans' counter to a justu is either:

"Punch the ground"

Or

"She heals because of her seal."

I say not.



Well worded thread and I agree with all points.
 
Last edited:

Gerkak

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
16,382
Reaction score
1,192
Nope, her taijutsu is nothing special. She uses chakra enhanced strength to punch simple as that.

Even superman before learning kryptonian CQC is better than her.
 

BLAZE

Sage of Six Posts 🔮
Immortal
Joined
Apr 4, 2014
Messages
59,497
Reaction score
3,577
Yes and keep low or ur obsession with sakura will get u banned again
 
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276
Yes and keep low or ur obsession with sakura will get u banned again

Agreed. Does this look like character bashing? I really just wanted a discussion on her abilities, but nothing short of attacking her character or calling her "useless".

Thanks!
 

BLAZE

Sage of Six Posts 🔮
Immortal
Joined
Apr 4, 2014
Messages
59,497
Reaction score
3,577
Agreed. Does this look like character bashing? I really just wanted a discussion on her abilities, but nothing short of attacking her character or calling her "useless".

Thanks!
Nah just freindly advice
I m only saying if this turn into bash thread u will be responsible and an infraction takes 10 days to expire.So all ur infraction will be cuurently active.One more will give u a longr ban :|

OT: Yes
 
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276
Nah just freindly advice
I m only saying if this turn into bash thread u will be responsible and an infraction takes 10 days to expire.So all ur infraction will be cuurently active.One more will give u a longr ban :|

OT: Yes

I'll see if I can control the comments. Thanks for the info Shiro, I didn't know that lol.
 

Awkward Linguist

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 13, 2012
Messages
24,034
Reaction score
1,958
It's a trait all female characters have in NV. They're not as fast when it comes to taijutsu compared to the males. Take Sakura and Tsunade as an example. Almost always they will dive forward with a punch, and that gets them no where except for with zetsus. Hinata is a lot better and faster close combat with her twin dragons, but even then she's still slow. The males out compete them when it comes to speed/agility/balance etc.​
 

SSStylish

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
3,467
Reaction score
597
CQC? As in how good she can fight? Well, Naruto himself has very little swag to his fighting style most of the time tbh. I don't recall it ever being really important in Naruto at all. Strength, Speed and Endurance always seemed to be way more important than "skill" in CQC (Taijutsu). So yeah, it really doesn't even matter.
 

-Akuma-

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,315
Reaction score
263
She's not good I CQC...Fore some reason people assume that because she has good strength that equates to good in CQC.​
 
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276
CQC? As in how good she can fight? Well, Naruto himself has very little swag to his fighting style most of the time tbh. I don't recall it ever being really important in Naruto at all. Strength, Speed and Endurance always seemed to be way more important than "skill" in CQC (Taijutsu). So yeah, it really doesn't even matter.

Close Quarters Combat! Really? Naruto has been relying on close combat, hell he rarely uses ninja weapons. He has been trying to master it ever since his first Naruto Rendan xD. The reason the newer arc overshadows that is because of the powers ups given. However SageMode - Frog Kumite should provide with enough background information to put him on the top in terms of Taijutsu and skill.

Let alone the example I showed in "II" which showcased Naruto's supremacy in hand-to-hand combat, and skill. That was impressive.

Anyway back to to your post, I definitely respect that opinion. As you said she can easily endure more than they can throw at her, to an extent anyway. Ninjutsu techniques can really put her off the game: Lava release, fire release, and lightning release. She can't tank those and expect to heal and stand up at full strength. Every technique has a weakness.
 
Last edited:

Aznkidd

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
7,437
Reaction score
401
i believe that kishi having some nightmare with his wife at home so once he goes to work he humiliates his heroine. The only way to revenge his wife. He even gave us the biggest hint in the last chapter, a message to his wife that "you should stay at home like a housewife and know your place".
The evident that sakura should be very talented, all the comments about her is being the smartest, but none of those "smart" taken place in the manga (not so useful to her combat)
 

To Whatever

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 27, 2013
Messages
18,010
Reaction score
1,512
CQC? As in how good she can fight? Well, Naruto himself has very little swag to his fighting style most of the time tbh. I don't recall it ever being really important in Naruto at all. Strength, Speed and Endurance always seemed to be way more important than "skill" in CQC (Taijutsu). So yeah, it really doesn't even matter.

What? Naruto's CQC game strong af.



You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
 
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276
i believe that kishi having some nightmare with his wife at home so once he goes to work he humiliates his heroine. The only way to revenge his wife. He even gave us the biggest hint in the last chapter, a message to his wife that "you should stay at home like a housewife and know your place".
The evident that sakura should be very talented, all the comments about her is being the smartest, but none of those "smart" taken place in the manga (not so useful to her combat)

i believe that kishi having some nightmare with his wife at home so once he goes to work he humiliates his heroine. The only way to revenge his wife. He even gave us the biggest hint in the last chapter, a message to his wife that "you should stay at home like a housewife and know your place".
The evident that sakura should be very talented, all the comments about her is being the smartest, but none of those "smart" taken place in the manga (not so useful to her combat)

Right? I expect so much more in close ranged combat with her skills. If she was actually showcased with Taijutsu abilities like Lee for instant. That puts her on the top ten lists without a doubt.

I don't really understand why Kishimoto gave her such power, but forgot to give her the skill to use it correctly.
 

SSStylish

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Oct 28, 2014
Messages
3,467
Reaction score
597
Close Quarters Combat! Really?



All I'm saying is that CQC/Skill is the most important thing in real life fights, but not in the Naruto ones. I just can't remember that a character had to get more skillfull in CQC (Taijutsu) in order to defeat someone or someone getting overpowered by pure CQC skill while being faster and stronger than the skilled CQC fighter. It just seems not very importan in the NV.
 
Joined
Jan 13, 2015
Messages
252
Reaction score
276


All I'm saying is that CQC/Skill is the most important thing in real life fights, but not in the Naruto ones. I just can't remember that a character had to get more skillfull in CQC (Taijutsu) in order to defeat someone or someone getting overpowered by pure CQC skill while being faster and stronger than the skilled CQC fighter. It just seems not very importan in the NV.

I meant in terms of Sakura alone as she has no Ninjutsu abilities. She is strictly hand to hand combat. In Sakura's case it looks as if that those with higher skill can destroy her, but her regenerative properties save her from defeat.

Yes she is

Could I get some examples? Thanks
 
Last edited:

Amaterasu

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
4,894
Reaction score
410
I have to say that was an impressive post, well developed and I have to agree, with all the strenght she has, she could havr used a lot more skills compared to Naruto (his brain goes too fast)
 
Top