[Discussion] Stawhat ranking

[OG sama]

The first thing you said was that Zoro/Sanji were stronger than Robin. I'm assuming you meant physically, and asked does Robin need to be physically stronger for her df to work? I was basically implying physical strength doesn't matter in this case. She can just make more hands or target an area(like the head) where needing to overpower them doesn't matter.

Oh my bad then. Her abilities are truly formidable, I don't really know what can cause her not to be able to clutch anyone though.

 

[mishoa]

Oh my bad then. Her abilities are truly formidable, I don't really know what can cause her not to be able to clutch anyone though.

I don't know either there is a lot of PIS on Oda's part involving Robin. She should be really hax in most situations if she is using it right. My ranking for the her is mostly based on the mechanics of how her fruit works ,and not her actual portrayal in the story. Zoro/Sanji would always beat her and are more powerful going by the way she is written.

 

[bajram]

I don't know either there is a lot of PIS on Oda's part involving Robin. She should be really hax in most situations if she is using it right. My ranking for the her is mostly based on the mechanics of how her fruit works ,and not her actual portrayal in the story. Zoro/Sanji would always beat her and are more powerful going by the way she is written.

If anyone could use his power at full in OP then Kizaru in a matter of seconds would solo OP verse, WB would quake the whole world etc... Its how oda uses it not how u think it.

 

[jiraiya lives]

No, because sword users are a bad match up against Robin. She would disarm Zoro than proceed to finish him. Sanji gets the clutch treatment ,and he does nothing to stop it.

Her abilities work best against people like them so.......

"people like them"...that's a very vague and flawed way to look at matchups, If that's the case then she would disarm any swordsmen. Just because she deflected an unspecting Diamante's sword doesn't mean the same will happen with an aware Zoro. It's like you completely ignored speed, attack power, AoE, Haki and so on just because you think that Robin>people with a sword...

 

[bajram]

"people like them"...that's a very vague and flawed way to look at matchups, If that's the case then she would disarm any swordsmen. Just because she deflected an unspecting Diamante's sword doesn't mean the same will happen with an aware Zoro. It's like you completely ignored speed, attack power, AoE, Haki and so on just because you think that Robin>people with a sword...

According to her logic Robin>Mihawk.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Flip Usopp and Nami. Oda said Usopp will always be the weakest no matter who joins. Idk about Franky and Robin for now, might go either way.

- I don't remember Oda saying that. Even if he did he can always change his opinion of that. Nami never showed anything that would put her over Usopp IMO.
- I ranked Franky higher, prior to latest chapter.

 

[Punk Hazard]

- I don't remember Oda saying that. Even if he did he can always change his opinion of that. Nami never showed anything that would put her over Usopp IMO.
- I ranked Franky higher, prior to latest chapter.

Luffy's Japanese VA confirmed that Oda said that was a rule he had in regards to the Strawhats. She's pretty damn credible, seeing as she works with Oda, and I'm gonna take his word over yours.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Luffy's Japanese VA confirmed that Oda said that was a rule he had in regards to the Strawhats. She's pretty damn credible, seeing as she works with Oda, and I'm gonna take his word over yours.

It still don't say that Oda can't change his opinion about that.

I never said that you need to take my words over hers, or anyone's from Oda's editor team. I even said "IMO", usually I go with their's opinion, but really Nami never showed anything that would put her over Usopp, maybe when she show more, I will change my opinion just like I changed opinion about Franky and Robin.

 

[Punk Hazard]

It still don't say that Oda can't change his opinion about that.

I never said that you need to take my words over hers, or anyone's from Oda's editor team. I even said "IMO", usually I go with their's opinion, but really Nami never showed anything that would put her over Usopp, maybe when she show more, I will change my opinion just like I changed opinion about Franky and Robin.

I don't see why Oda would change his rules. It'd be like him making it so that only sal****er affects DF users rather than all water out of the blue.

 

[Zantos]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Sanji

Top 3 will never change from this.

4. Robin
5. Franky
6. Brook
7. Chopper
8. Usopp
9. Nami

you are basically right ! just on mistake : Usopp is last and always will be ! oda mentioned that he would be the weakest straw hat.

 

[OG sama]

you are basically right ! just on mistake : Usopp is last and always will be ! oda mentioned that he would be the weakest straw hat.

Well I doubt he at every moment is the weakest. Right now because of feats I would rate him higher than Nami.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

see told you guys i am not alone
SUCK IT

Dude, please just stop.

 

[Tomato God]

Dude, please just stop.

HEY ONVE A WEEK EVERYONE GETS TO FAN OVER THEIR FAVORITE! This is my week so suck it.

 

[Anduril]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Robin
4. Sanji
5. Franky
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Nami

Insert chopper anywhere. And I think the bounties are the correct order of the strawhats powerscale. (Except chopper, that was comic relief) Jus sayin.

 

[-Akuma-]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Robin
4. Sanji
5. Franky
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Nami

Insert chopper anywhere. And I think the bounties are the correct order of the strawhats powerscale. (Except chopper, that was comic relief) Jus sayin.

Sanji below Robin are you ****ing kidding me...smh

OT:
Luffy>Zoro>Sanji>Franky>Robin>Brook<Chopper>Nami>***** with the long nose.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

1. Luffy
2. Zoro
   [*]Robin
   [*]Sanji
3. Franky
4. Brook
5. Usopp
6. Nami

Insert chopper anywhere. And I think the bounties are the correct order of the strawhats powerscale. (Except chopper, that was comic relief) Jus sayin.

Last time I checked, the Monster Trio was stated to contain the crew's 3 strongest fighters and Sanji is a member of the M3, not Robin. You Robin fapboys are escalating quickly on my list of most annoying fanbases.

 

[mishoa]

Last time I checked, the Monster Trio was stated to contain the crew's 3 strongest fighters and Sanji is a member of the M3, not Robin. You Robin fapboys are escalating quickly on my list of most annoying fanbases.

Get over it. Robin is a hard counter for Sanji. All his strength is focused on his lower body, which doesn't help him if she decided to clutch his torso. Go to any review on youtube of the recent chapter, you will see quite a few people have similar opinions.

 

[Gintõki1]

HEY ONVE A WEEK EVERYONE GETS TO FAN OVER THEIR FAVORITE! This is my week so suck it.

To fan over or wank the shit out of their favorite character is far from being the same.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Get over it. Robin is a hard counter for Sanji. All his strength is focused on his lower body, which doesn't help him if she decided to clutch his torso. Go to any review on youtube of the recent chapter, you will see quite a few people have similar opinions.

Sanji can just use Hells Memories to burn Robin's arms off. Remember that Robin can feel pain whenever a sprouted arm/leg/other body part gets hurt.

 

[-Akuma-]

LOL PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY TRYING TO DEBATE THIS......Sanji blitzes Robin and one shots her.