[Discussion] Best one piece plot twist you can think of

[Tomato God]

---

This is a contest to see who can come up with the most mind screwing curve ball plot twist in one piece.

---

​

Rules

1. Has to be in the future of the manga cannot involve or change past events
2. No lewd or disrespectful things I.e. Sanji and zoro both die because they are noobs
3. No trolling or s!@# posting
4. Will award rep for the Top three Plot twist. And then Quote them in the OP to show they won.

---

WINNERS

---

​

First Place

My second plot twist is rather badass. Zoro in one battle has both arms/hands severed. The entire fanbase is in an uproar; did Oda just restrict Zoro and theoretically destroy his dream to be the greatest swordsman? Even if he can wield a sword in his mouth this greatly hinders and hampers Zoro from making any real strides. Then to our bafflement Zoro contrives one of the most sick badass bounce backs ever: he attaches the blades of his two swords to his missing arms/hands!! This shows the sheer resolution and resilience of Zoro and makes it interesting Zoro adapt with two blades as prosthetic limbs. Here's my inspiration for this idea:

You must be registered for see links

And here's what will make it a viable idea. Oda loves to infuse historical, especially occidental history, into OP. Galvariano happened to be an enemy of the SPANISH during the AGE OF EXPLORATION!! This fits perfectly in my opinion

2nd Place

Plot Twist : A new guy joins the SHC and later turns out to be the 7th Shichibukai

3rd Place

Shanks is a villain and is using Luffy to find the OP.

Special Mention

Plot Twist : Tomato King is actually Oda reading this thread for some ideas

 

[Limbo]

Roger & Dragon were brothers

The D i the names of Luffy, Ace, Dragon, Roger etc. was the name of one of the founders of the World goverment.


thats all i cna think of...i have little to none imagination

 

[DonDiegoJayGardouqi]

One of the straw hats is bribed by the WG to act as a double agent and spy on the straw hats clandestinely. This straw hat isn't from the current core straw hats but from a new straw hat in the future. The day of the betrayal will sort of parallel the betrayal of judas who betrays Jesus by selling him out to the Romans, and in this case this straw hat will sell luffy and the crew out to the WG. Like Judas he will be filled with guilt and repentant but to no avail.

BTW I'm not a Christian and know little Biblical history so i hope my knowledge on this isn't too shabby

 

[Savage Predator]

Sanji kicking woman U_U

 

[Tomato God]

One of the straw hats is bribed by the WG to act as a double agent and spy on the straw hats clandestinely. This straw hat isn't from the current core straw hats but from a new straw hat in the future. The day of the betrayal will sort of parallel the betrayal of judas who betrays Jesus by selling him out to the Romans, and in this case this straw hat will sell luffy and the crew out to the WG. Like Judas he will be filled with guilt and repentant but to no avail.

BTW I'm not a Christian and know little Biblical history so i hope my knowledge on this isn't too shabby

That was pretty much it.
1. judas was all cool.
2. Judas got money in exchange for Jesus.
3. Judas went and killed himself.

Only difference is Judas was there from the beginning.
Vivi could do it... That would make me cry though.
Good Plot twist.

 

[DonDiegoJayGardouqi]

That was pretty much it.
1. judas was all cool.
2. Judas got money in exchange for Jesus.
3. Judas went and killed himself.

Only difference is Judas was there from the beginning.
Vivi could do it... That would make me cry though.
Good Plot twist.

I'm glad my knowledge isn't that sub par. And thanks

 

[Edward Snowden]

Teach turns out to be directly related to Luffy.

 

[Tomato God]

Teach turns out to be directly related to Luffy.

Teach is luffy's mom. He just got lots of body work done so he could hold More DFs and be a strong Male.

 

[Hexuze]

Shanks is a villain and is using Luffy to find the OP.

 

[Kai NB]

One of the straw hats is bribed by the WG to act as a double agent and spy on the straw hats clandestinely. This straw hat isn't from the current core straw hats but from a new straw hat in the future. The day of the betrayal will sort of parallel the betrayal of judas who betrays Jesus by selling him out to the Romans, and in this case this straw hat will sell luffy and the crew out to the WG. Like Judas he will be filled with guilt and repentant but to no avail.

BTW I'm not a Christian and know little Biblical history so i hope my knowledge on this isn't too shabby

If I may, I'd just like to offer some critique of my own. This does seem fairly reminiscent of Water 7 Arc similar to how Robin "betrayed" her crew, though obviously this case is different as the crew member is purposely fooling the entire Straw Hat Crew

OT: I'd say this
Plot Twist Ideas:

Spoiler

• Law and Luffy are fighting in the Pirate Alliance and Law joins the other side (In the end, it is revealed he purposely chose to go against Luffy in order to make Luffy even stronger, but Law legit goes the whole way and tries to kill Luffy along with Kid and the other Supernovas)
• Kuma kills Vegapunk, a character who will be revealed to be as an honest man despite his work and involvement with the WG
• Shanks is arrives at Raftel again (because he actually knows life Luffy) at the same time as Luffy, and steals One Piece from him, revealing that he's been waiting for someone to find it because he did not know the specific whereabouts. In the end, Shanks will undoubtedly ask for forgiveness from Luffy and is sincere when he says how proud he is of Luffy (so like Obito basically)

 

[Kai NB]

Shanks is a villain and is using Luffy to find the OP.

No. Fair. I literally had this typed out and was about to press post, but I went to get some water, and when I came back and pressed post, this was here.

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

Shanks and Dragon are brothers and also Roger's sons. That's why Shanks protects Luffy like a father, because he is aware that Dragon isn't there for him. That would make Shanks a D and whatnot. There's prolly more that could be done with that premise.

I don't know if this is even plausible. I don't follow One Piece too intently/at all anymore, so there are prolly lots of conflict with that twist.

 

[Kai NB]

Shanks and Dragon are brothers and also Roger's sons. That's why Shanks protects Luffy like a father, because he is aware that Dragon isn't there for him. That would make Shanks a D and whatnot. There's prolly more that could be done with that premise.

I don't know if this is even plausible. I don't follow One Piece too intently/at all anymore, so there are prolly lots of conflict with that twist.

Even though you don't know much about it, it's a really good plot twist idea

Sadly, there is a fair amount of conflicts for this to occur

 

[DonDiegoJayGardouqi]

My second plot twist is rather badass. Zoro in one battle has both arms/hands severed. The entire fanbase is in an uproar; did Oda just restrict Zoro and theoretically destroy his dream to be the greatest swordsman? Even if he can wield a sword in his mouth this greatly hinders and hampers Zoro from making any real strides. Then to our bafflement Zoro contrives one of the most sick badass bounce backs ever: he attaches the blades of his two swords to his missing arms/hands!! This shows the sheer resolution and resilience of Zoro and makes it interesting Zoro adapt with two blades as prosthetic limbs. Here's my inspiration for this idea:

You must be registered for see links

And here's what will make it a viable idea. Oda loves to infuse historical, especially occidental history, into OP. Galvariano happened to be an enemy of the SPANISH during the AGE OF EXPLORATION!! This fits perfectly in my opinion

 

[Kai NB]

My second plot twist is rather badass. Zoro in one battle has both arms/hands severed. The entire fanbase is in an uproar; did Oda just restrict Zoro and theoretically destroy his dream to be the greatest swordsman? Even if he can wield a sword in his mouth this greatly hinders and hampers Zoro from making any real strides. Then to our bafflement Zoro contrives one of the most sick badass bounce backs ever: he attaches the blades of his two swords to his missing arms/hands!! This shows the sheer resolution and resilience of Zoro and makes it interesting Zoro adapt with two blades as prosthetic limbs. Here's my inspiration for this idea:

You must be registered for see links

And here's what will make it a viable idea. Oda loves to infuse historical, especially occidental history, into OP. Galvariano happened to be an enemy of the SPANISH during the AGE OF EXPLORATION!! This fits perfectly in my opinion

Give him the win. Don't even bother with any others. Do it now.

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

Even though you don't know much about it, it's a really good plot twist idea

Sadly, there is a fair amount of conflicts for this to occur

Out of curiosity, what are those conflicts?

Do we know Shanks' first name? I was figuring he might be a D because his name hasn't been introduced. So he might be XXXXX D. Shanks, but I have no clue. If has name has been revealed, then whoops. I dun gon fole reetard.

 

[Mellow]

luffy really drowned and went unconscious when fighting Arlong and everything was just a dream.

 

[DonDiegoJayGardouqi]

Give him the win. Don't even bother with any others. Do it now.

Thanks. History has more creativity than fiction.

"There's more in heaven and earth Horatio than is dreamt of in your philosophy"

 

[Kai NB]

Out of curiosity, what are those conflicts?

Do we know Shanks' first name? I was figuring he might be a D because his name hasn't been introduced. So he might be XXXXX D. Shanks, but I have no clue. If has name has been revealed, then whoops. I dun gon fole reetard.

You know, that I think about it, you can work it pretty well actually. There are a few things. Dragon is the son of Garp, that much is fact. Also, Shanks joined Roger's crew and Roger was not known to have any children besides Ace. So Shanks and Dragon are definitely not brothers nor are they the children of Roger.

However, they can be "brothers" in the sake of brotherly bonds like Luffy, Ace, and Sabo. This can work. Also, if that is the case, the reason Shanks is so fond of Luffy the way you explained is plausible. So if you take out what I said before, the rest of your theory works.

Basically, the plot twist would be the Shanks and Dragon are brothers because they shared some sake which parallels how Luffy, Ace, and Sabo became brothers

luffy really drowned and went unconscious when fighting Arlong and everything was just a dream.

No. Just no.

 

[Kai NB]

Thanks. History has more creativity than fiction.

"There's more in heaven and earth Horatio than is dreamt of in your philosophy"

Not a fan of Hamlet, nor tragedies in general. I like Shakespeare's comedies a lot though

Also, history has more "creativity"? Wouldn't that imply that it is false. If that's the case, it wouldn't really be history, but mythology