Is Itachi a criminal?

[Aikor]

As per se USSJ suggests, I believe so.

How in the world did u get tht "Grim" status?? .___.

 

[Sound]

He's a hero who became a criminal to save a greater good.​

 

[BLAZE]

Yes;all hail lord USSJ
he should have at least killed Danzo

 

[Ageha Jaeger]

He did what he had to do to save lives. If that means he's a criminal by man made concepts then so be it. And maybe he didn't have to kill the children, but they probably would have grown to hate the village like Sasuke if they ever found out the truth.

 

[Mellanoma]

Manga and kishi illustration: He killed few to save many and was a hero of the village

USSJ Illustration: Mass murdering psychopath who was also sadistic and selfish

 

[ᖇ α z m α η]

Depends on the eyes of the beholder

Most shinobis doesn't know the whole story, so they judge him as a criminal...

On the other hand, the people who acknowledge him knows what he have sacrificed for the village and in their point of view he's a hero .​

 

[SuperChief]

Whatever his reasons or motivations, Itachi is a criminal. Even if you absolve him of his crime insofar as killing his own clansmen, he joined Akatsuki and was party to numerous kidnappings and murders.

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

It was the only option he had

wrong. it was the worst option he had and it was the worst atrocity in konohas history

so yeah, he's a hero considering his clan was done anyway and he stopped the next shinobi war from occuring, Uchiha rep, and one Uchiha.

hes a villain considering his clan coula hve been saved yet he murdered them anyway in cold blood, then lied about it rather than trusting konoa with the truth. he caused the next shionobi war to occur by aiding obito to obtain nukes.

On the other hand, the people who acknowledge him knows what he have sacrificed for the village and in their point of view he's a hero .

on the other hand hes a complete psychopath supervillain who has sacrificed nothing for the ivllahge and only ensured its destruction. people calling him a hero are as insane as he is

Manga and kishi illustration: He killed few to save many and was a hero of the village

reality: he killed innocent people to exterminate humanity and hand nuks over to terrorists, mindraped and tortured innocent people and helped exterminate and annhilate half the world. one of the worst and msot evil men in history, who doesnt regret in the least brutally torturing and mentally raping innocent people in cold blood.
btw mental rape is as bad as physical rape.
so yeah the "hero of the village" raped 3 people, gave terrorists bijuus, murdered innocent people, did nothing to stop orochimaru or danzo, committed genocide, unleashed sasuke by torturing him to madness, and participated in many horrific atrocities which caused unending suffering and death worldwide

e did what he had to do to save lives

he did what he wanted ot do to exterminate lives and ensure that the world is exterminated in a destructive world war.
losing uchihas means konoha is open to attack since no village is going to think konoha wasnt weakened by such an atrocity and loss of life.
and then the akatsuki thing and itachi declaring war on humanity.

And maybe he didn't have to kill the children, but they probably would have grown to hate the village like Sasuke if they ever found out the truth.

which cements itachi as one of the most insane and brtually evil men in history. he slaughtered children because they MIGHT be a possble threat to a corrupt evil government in the future?
this is absolutely insane and one of the worst things anyone could possibly decide to do. if this is itachis logic he should kill everyone in the world besides the govenrment if he fears so much that people might hate and attack the govenrment so easily.
sasuke only decided on genociding the village due to years of conditioning, abuse, wallowing in hatred and loneliness, and torture. and because of obitos deceptive speeches about how uchihas are so great and senjus were so bad.
so no i dont think that every single surviving young uchiha would turn out to be sasukes.

He's a hero who became a criminal to save a greater good.

hes a villain who tortured, raped and killed innocent people and declared war on humanity.

. However at least in my opinion he could still be considered a hero since he saved the lives of future konoha citizens.

not when he did nothing to stop orochimaru or danzo, and did jackshit to even slow down akatsuki, even helping akatsuki become stronger than ever.
plus he raped 3 innocent people for no reason.

He sacrificed him self to save the village ( or there would be war )

he committed the worst atrocitiy and act of mass murder in konohas history, to doom the village, given there will still be war eventually. but with no uchiha clan to save them givne he killed them all needlessly.
itachi declared war on humanity when he murdered gaara

and even when he joined the Akatsuki he was working for the village

no he wasnt. he was working for himself. the village didnt know anything about akatuski meaning itachi betrayed them and left them with nothing. he was working to exterminate humanity which is why he got bijuus to akatsuki rather than doing something to stop them.

Killing is commonplace in the Narutoverse. Is Kakashi a criminal? Is Neji a criminal? Is Guy a criminal? Is Naruto a criminal? Is Hashirama a criminal? They are all murderers, just like Itachi.

itachi is also a sadistic rapist, terrorist and traitor

. He´s one of the ninjas who wanted peace

and made sure peace could not be achieved at every opportunity.

If Itachi wasn´t there who would stop Kabuto? He´s not a criminal.

no but hes a rapist sociopath.
stopping kabuto meant the doom of the entire alliance. you dont go after the subordinate when the leader is the real threat. obuto should have been itachis priority. with him there obito would be dead and madara and kabuto are only a matter of time

if you know the whole story he did it to save sasuke and the village from civil war and possibly shinobi world war,

if you know the whole story, youd realise there were easier less costly ways of doing that, and that itachi ended up causing a shinobi world war anyway.
he should not have just saved sasuke, but his entire clan.

He's a hero no doubt, but to become a hero, he had to murder. There's no justification for that. Therefore, he's a criminal. All of them are criminals to a certain degree.

hes a mass murdering terrorist raping manipulative lying psychopath

No, He was a loyal Konoha Shinobi till the end.

and yet did nothing about konohas enemies and let oro kill half the village

So, he's both. He's an antihero who played the villain role to protect people. Naruto said it here best

naruto said nothing best. hes nothing but a mass murdering raping sociopath who tortured killed and massacred thousands to start a world war and destroy humanity alongside obito. he raped 3 innocent people, naruto being one of them.

but he went undercover in Akatsuki, as a spy, to serve the village.

he went into akatuski to help them kill everyone in the world and start the worst war in history. he did the opposite of serving the village and instead ensured that theyd be massacred by obito and pain via telling them nothing.

 

[Tennis Robot]

itachi is also a sadistic rapist, terrorist and traitor

I was waiting for this...In what way is Itachi a rapist? Also, if Itachi is a traitor, then Hiruzen and Danzo are traitors too.

 

[Tenshi Hikari]

A HERO for me.

 

[Ageha Jaeger]

he did what he wanted ot do to exterminate lives and ensure that the world is exterminated in a destructive world war.
losing uchihas means konoha is open to attack since no village is going to think konoha wasnt weakened by such an atrocity and loss of life.
and then the akatsuki thing and itachi declaring war on humanity.

So I guess you missed the part when he was crying before his parents? Saying he actually wanted to do that is nonsense. The whole point was to reduce the amount of bloodshed there would have to be in the long run.

which cements itachi as one of the most insane and brtually evil men in history. he slaughtered children because they MIGHT be a possble threat to a corrupt evil government in the future?
this is absolutely insane and one of the worst things anyone could possibly decide to do. if this is itachis logic he should kill everyone in the world besides the govenrment if he fears so much that people might hate and attack the govenrment so easily.
sasuke only decided on genociding the village due to years of conditioning, abuse, wallowing in hatred and loneliness, and torture. and because of obitos deceptive speeches about how uchihas are so great and senjus were so bad.
so no i dont think that every single surviving young uchiha would turn out to be sasukes. .

Oh yes, they would have been future Sasuke's if they learned the truth, which they inevitably would.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You're renowned for saying nonsense though (Itachi raped people...?) so I won't put too much effort in discussing this.

 

[Red Slayer]

he was more hero than criminal IMO

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

So I guess you missed the part when he was crying before his parents? Saying he actually wanted to do that is nonsense. The whole point was to reduce the amount of bloodshed there would have to be in the long run.

youd have to want to do something that you have a choice in.
i want to kill a defenceless murderer, but it doesnt mean i have to. even if letting him go leads to more deaths.
the whole point was to be a hypocrite because itachi caused said long run bloodshed.
what was the point of sparing orochimaru and danzos lives if itachis whole goal in life was reducing death and blood? surely taking down such evil scum would be beneficial.
oh right, itachi only kills when its conveniant

Oh yes, they would have been future Sasuke's if they learned the truth, which they inevitably would.

already explaind why they would not be. it took years of abuse and torture to make sasuke sasuke.

You're renowned for saying nonsense though (Itachi raped people...?) so I won't put too much effort in discussing this.

rape does not have be physical.
the unlawful compelling of a person through physical force or duress to have sexual intercourse.
2.
any act of sexual intercourse that is forced upon a person.
3.
statutory rape.
4.
an act of plunder, violent seizure, or abuse; despoliation; violation:
the rape of the countryside.
itachi did the fourth one. an act of forced violation and abuse of another human being.

.In what way is Itachi a rapist?

rape: an act of violent seizure, abuse despoilation or violation.
itachi mentally and emotionally tortured an innocent child, and forcibly made him endure abuse

o, if Itachi is a traitor, then Hiruzen and Danzo are traitors too.

hiruzen and danzo cant betray their own people because they are already the commanders in control of the land and make all the laws and rules. but they are genocidal lying manipulating snakes.
itachi betrayed and committed high treason against both konoha and the other allied nations of konoha by murdering jinchurikis and attempting to kill kakashi in cold blood.