[Discussion] One Piece Tier List(Majority Vote)

[Tomato God]

Notto mention he put John Giant above Luffy. John Giant is just like every other giant, he relies on his size way too much and hasnt shown any good skills with weapons or hand to hand combat. G3 makes quick work of him.

Broggy and Dory cut the ocean in half. That is one of the biggest feats in the series so far.

 

[ultraChalk]

The battle in the anime was way longer than it happened in the manga. Even if he can beat Sanji that doesnt make him a tier higher, he needsto be able to beat someone in that tier or push one of them to very high diff, which I dont think Smoker could do.

You must be registered for see images

Cmon man you can't use a rebuttal like that when I make a point. What was even the point in bringing Sanji into this if 'beating him doesnt put him a league higher', wtf.

And he took a deadly haki infused attack from him in the manga as well, that was much stronger than the casual kick Sanji took.

Smokers durability is up there, it's very high. He's being underrated.

 

[Bogard]

errr.rebecca was able to dodge hakuba.not to mentioin hakuba is a short term state.luffy was able to put down rebecca while eating and not giving a ****.with sanji's observation haki +speed and zoro's arament+reaction speed hakuba is no match

She trained her observation haki during her entire life, so in terms of observation haki, she is top notch, yet even with observation haki activated she barely noticed a glimpse of Hakuba's speed and would have still died if not her helmett. Rebecca had no intent to kill against Luffy, so wasn't combat oriented(he said so himself). Once again, Sabo hyped his speed. Bartolomeo(who fodderized a vice admiral) and everyone in the stadium who was capable to follow all Luffy fights couldn't see a glimpse of Hakuba's speed. If you think it#s a small deal, then you're a fool

 

[U mAd]

She trained her observation haki during her entire life, so in terms of observation haki, she is top notch, yet even with observation haki activated she barely noticed a glimpse of Hakuba's speed and would have still died if not her helmett. Rebecca had no intent to kill against Luffy, so wasn't combat oriented(he said so himself). Once again, Sabo hyped his speed. Bartolomeo(who fodderized a vice admiral) and everyone in the stadium who was capable to follow all Luffy fights couldn't see a glimpse of Hakuba's speed. If you think it#s a small deal, then you're a fool

still saying hakuba>luffy is more foolish

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Broggy and Dory cut the ocean in half. That is one of the biggest feats in the series so far.

What? They cut a giant fish in half not an entire ocean.

I believe so. Hakuba is 2 times stronger than Cavendish who was capable to rival Chinjao(who was rivalling Luffy), has a speed so great even someone like Sabo was baffled about. I also consider the fact that since it has a timelimit, it must be a strong monster when it appears

Yami Teach was careless. It wasn't that great of a feat. He got fodderised later on by level 6 prisoners nowhere near Yami Teach level
Luffy wouldn't have a performance even close to John Giant's against Whitebeard, who ressorted to 2 islands attacks just to put the dude down

Not all of WBs punches are island level, he can decide how much tremor from his DF he puts into a punch, as seen when he attacked Ronse and the island didnt shake.

You must be registered for see images

Cmon man you can't use a rebuttal like that when I make a point. What was even the point in bringing Sanji into this if 'beating him doesnt put him a league higher', wtf.

And he took a deadly haki infused attack from him in the manga as well, that was much stronger than the casual kick Sanji took.

Smokers durability is up there, it's very high. He's being underrated.

I said "if" seriously wtf is wrong with this base no one seems to understand what a hypothetical situation is.

 

[Bogard]

still saying hakuba>luffy is more foolish

Depends on how you view it

Not all of WBs punches are island level, he can decide how much tremor from his DF he puts into a punch, as seen when he attacked Ronse and the island didnt shake.

I know that and it's exactly why i rate John Giant that highly. Against Ronse, a small quake to the head was enough, but against John Giant(who clashed evenly with him btw), he ressorted to 2 island level attacks to defeat him, the former used to destablize his balance beforehand. Whitebeard struggled much more to defeat him than he would ever struggle against a Luffy level opponent

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Depends on how you view it
I know that and it's exactly why i rate John Giant that highly. Against Ronse, a small quake to the head was enough, but against John Giant(who clashed evenly with him btw), he ressorted to 2 island level attacks to defeat him, the former used to destablize his balance beforehand. Whitebeard struggled much more to defeat him than he would ever struggle against a Luffy level opponent

The 1st attack just tilted the island, even marine fodders survived that and the 2nd attack K.O.d John Giant and it wasnt an island level attack. Replace Luffy with John Giant and Luffy would be K.O.d too.

 

[Bogard]

The 1st attack just tilted the island, even marine fodders survived that and the 2nd attack K.O.d John Giant and it wasnt an island level attack. Replace Luffy with John Giant and Luffy would be K.O.d too.

- Like you said it tilted the island, so the 1st attack is a island level attack. Marine fodders surviving that doesn't mean much considering Whitebeard's only concern was John Giant, not the marine fodders

- 3 admirals were needed to stop the second attack and it was heavily implied it would have destroyed their stands if it wasn't stopped. So if it wasn't island level, it was close to it and so powerful it required 3 admirals to stop

Of course Luffy would have been ko'd by the attack, but it's not my point. My point is that Whitebeard wouldn't even have ressorted to island level attacks to defeat him, so John Giant forcing him to use them to defeat him is impressive in my eyes

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

- Like you said it tilted the island, so the 1st attack is a island level attack. Marine fodders surviving that doesn't mean much considering Whitebeard's only concern was John Giant, not the marine fodders

- 3 admirals were needed to stop the second attack and it was heavily implied it would have destroyed their stands if it wasn't stopped. So if it wasn't island level, it was close to it and so powerful it required 3 admirals to stop

Of course Luffy would have been ko'd by the attack, but it's not my point. My point is that Whitebeard wouldn't even have ressorted to island level attacks to defeat him, so John Giant forcing him to use them to defeat him is impressive in my eyes

The 1st attack is an aoe, it effected everyone equally. Defeating JG wasn't WBs reason for using a powerful attack, he did it to get rid of JG and to free Ace, but the Admirals blocked it. We dont know if JG could have withstood a weaker attack from WB.

 

[Red Swag]

what in the hell is this bullshit?

anyway heres my take (all in their prime)

Top of the Top Tier
-"Pirate King" Gol D. Roger
-Edward "Whitebeard" Newgate
-"Hero" Monkey D. Garp "The Fist"

Upper Top Tier
-"Red Hair" Shanks
-Monkey D Dragon
-Kaido

Middle Top Tier
-"Blackbeard" Marshall D. Teach aka "Kurohige"(2 DF)
-"Akainu" Sakazuki
-"Buddha" Sengoku(prime)
-"Aokiji" Kuzan
-"Big Mam" Charloutte Linlin
-"Hawk Eye" Dracule Mihawk
-Kizaru
- -"Dark King" Silvers Rayleigh

Lower Top Tier
-"Fujitora" Issho
-Ryokygou
-Doflamingo
-Marco
-Shiryu

 

[bajram]

God tier:

"Pirate King" Gol D. Roger
Edward Newgate "Whitebeard"

High Top Tier:

Edward Newgate "Whitebeard" (old)
"Red-Haired" Shanks
Fleet Admiral "Akainu" Sakazuki
Kaido "of the hundred beasts"
Kuzan (former admiral "Aokiji")

Monkey D. Dragon
Dracule Hawk-Eyes "Mihawk"
"The Dark King" Silvers Rayleigh
Former Fleet Admiral Sengoku "the Buddha"
"Big MoM" Charlotte Linlin

Vice Admiral Monkey D. Garp "the fist"
Admiral "Kizaru Borsalino"
"Gold Lion" Shiki
Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard" (2 DF, Post TS)

Middle top tier:

Admiral "Fujitora" Issho
Commander-in-Chief Kong
Former Admiral "Black-Arm" Zephyr(prime)

Marco "the Phoenix"
Ben Beckman

Lower top tier:

Sabo
"Diamond" Jozu
"Flower Sword" Vista
Lucky Rou
"Chaser" Yassop
Don Chinjao " the Drill" (prime)

High High tier:

"Heavenly Demon" Donquixote Doflamingo
Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard" (pre-Gura)
"Champion" Jesus Burgess
Shiryuu "of the Rain"
"Pirate Empress" Boa Hancock

Vice Admiral Onigumo
Vice Admiral John Giant
Vice Admiral Doberman

Portgas D. "Fire Fist" Ace
"Maelstrom Spider" Squardo
Oars Jr.

Middle High tier:

Monkey D. "Strawhat" Luffy
"Pirate Hunter" Roronoa Zoro
"Black Leg" Sanji
Eustass "Captain" Kid
"Surgeon of Death" Trafalgar Law

Don Chinjao "the Drill" (old)

Pica
Diamante
Trebol

Vice Admiral Momonga
Vice Admiral Strawberry
Vice Admiral "Demon Bamboo" Vergo
Vice Admiral Jaguar D. Saul
Vice Admiral "White Hunter" Smoker
Vice Admiral "Shark-Cutter" Bastille
Vice Admiral Stainless
Sentomaru
Magellan

Baron Tamago
Pekoms

"Knight of the Sea" Jinbei
"The Tyrant" Bartholemew Kuma

"Heavy Drinker" Vasco Shot
"Supersonic" Van Auger
"Colossal Battleship" San Juan Wolf
"Crescent Moon Hunter" Catarina Devon
"Corrupt King" Avalo Pizarro
"Reaper" Doc Q
Lafitte

"Pirate Prince" Cavendish
"Bohemian Knight" Doma
"Okama King" Emporio Ivankov

Nightmare Luffy
Calgara
Montblanc Norland

Lower High tier:

"God" Enel

Vice Admiral Cancer

Sai
"Destroying Cannon" Ideo
"Pirate Mercenary" Hajrudin
Blue Gilly
Hack

"Cyborg" Franky
"Devil's Child" Nico Robin
"Soul King" Brooke

Gekko Moriah
"Continent-puller" Oars

Caesar Clown
Monet
Lao G
Gladius
Machvise
Senor Pink
Yeti Cool Brothers (Rock and Scotch)

Hody Jones (ES)

"Fox-Fire" Kinemon
Bartolomeo "The Cannibal"

Stronger


I dont really care for lower rank so this is my list I think...

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Can a mod please sticky this?

 

[TheHokage]

Smoker and Sanji should be in the same tier as Luffy and Zoro.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Smoker isnotin the same tier as Luffy!

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

Smoker and Sanji should be in the same tier as Luffy and Zoro.

Sanji??? Maybe but smoker is not in the same league

 

[TheHokage]

Smoker isnotin the same tier as Luffy!

Well neither is Zoro, besides we've seen nothing from Luffy as of yet to put him in a tier above.

Sanji??? Maybe but smoker is not in the same league

So putting on a better display against someone Sanji fought against doesn't put Smoker above Sanji, being Luffy's rival doesn't put Smoker above Sanji? Please.

 

[ultraChalk]

Smoker and Sanji should be in the same tier as Luffy and Zoro.

...Zoro shouldn't be in the same league as Luffy in the first place... Sanji definitely shouldn't... and Smoker should be in Zoros' league... imo.

I think Smoker should be considered for Luffys league once he proves himself an island buster.

 

[TheHokage]

...Zoro shouldn't be in the same league as Luffy in the first place... Sanji definitely shouldn't... and Smoker should be in Zoros' league... imo.

I think Smoker should be considered for Luffys league once he proves himself an island buster.

Agree with this 100%.

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

Well neither is Zoro, besides we've seen nothing from Luffy as of yet to put him in a tier above.



So putting on a better display against someone Sanji fought against doesn't put Smoker above Sanji, being Luffy's rival doesn't put Smoker above Sanji? Please.

Sanji was trying to protect the marines also he did more damage and luffy's rival is coby and still that doesn't mean he is in his league also don't forget how he was ownd by law who is barely stronger than luffy

 

[ultraChalk]

Just gonna bring this post over here.

No Crocodile is still something luffy couldnt beat. The only reason he won is cause he can't die. Not plot. Not strength. Just kept getting back up.

Luffy simmers Crocodile on the stove at medium low.

The Idea of the M3 getting pummeled was interesting but I seriously don't believe Spring boy will join.

Also Bellamy joining wouldn't disrupt the M3, they're all far, far above him.

Dang TK you've been derping today