[Discussion] One Piece Tier List(Majority Vote)

[Dr Strangelove]

You nicked this from OpB xD
But yeah, I dislike these kinda things. Seems to me you're not allowed to disagree with them :/

 

[Olorin]

It was. But that could be because Roger had maybe just got out of a fight? SO an injured Roger took on Garp. The difference in power is isn't substantial at all. But I think it's more sensible to go on an airtight 'Only WB could match Roger in a fight' rather than a little more vague 'almost killed each other'. Don't you think? That's what I think anyway.

maybe this, maybe that, ...

maybe when Buggy said that WB and Roger weren't yet in their prime, maybe YYYYYY, maybe XXXXXX, maybe ZZZZZZZ

lex parsimonia

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

middle high tier and top high tier need to be combined. Get rid of top of the top tier and move everyone between there and top high tier down one to adjust.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

middle high tier and top high tier need to be combined. Get rid of top of the top tier and move everyone between there and top high tier down one to adjust.

If you can 2 serious votes then it becomes law.

You nicked this from OpB xD
But yeah, I dislike these kinda things. Seems to me you're not allowed to disagree with them :/

:stfu:
Oh I can disagree. This government is stubborn and doesn't listen to retardation.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

:stfu:
Oh I can disagree. This government is stubborn and doesn't listen to retardation.

...so you're like Stalin now? :|

 

[SSS12]

maybe this, maybe that, ...

maybe when Buggy said that WB and Roger weren't yet in their prime, maybe YYYYYY, maybe XXXXXX, maybe ZZZZZZZ

lex parsimonia

Well, maybe Roger wasn't in his prime when Garp and Roger nearly killed each other.

My point is of course I'm going to assume things and use words like 'maybe' or 'could be'. Because we have never seen either Roger, Prime Garp/WB fight now, have we? I could always use the definite scenarios if you wish. But then I bet you'll demand proof. And it's not my style to state assumptions in the definite sense.

But like I said, between the two statements, 'Only WB could match Roger in battle' is more definite and airtight. But I don't think you are going to buy that? Am I right? That's alright, it's your interpretation.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Please move Sentomaru up 1 tier he was low diffing Pre-TS Luffy at Sabaody and he is somehow in the same tier?

 

[Magi]

I'll just post it like this

Top of the Top Tier
- Gol D Roger
- Monkey D Dragon
- Monkey D Garp (prime)
- Edward Newgate (Prime)

Upper Top Tier
- Shanks

Middle Top Tier
- Akainu
- Big Mom
- Kaido
- Mihawk
- Kuzan
- Rayleigh (prime)
- Shiki (prime)
- Marshall D Teach

Lower Top Tier
- Kizaru
- Fujitora
- Ryokugyu

Upper High Tier
- Marco
- Sabo

Middle High Tier
- Ace
- Doflamingo
- Jozu
- Magellan
- Shiliew
- Kuma
- Don Chinjao (prime)

Lower High Tier
- Monkey D Luffy
- Crocodile (yes, you saw right, Crocodile)
- Hancock

Upper Mid Tier
- Jinbe
- Trafalgar Law
- Eustass "Captain" Kidd
- Roronoa Zoro
- Sanji
- Smoker
- Vergo
- Emporio Ivankov
- Pica, Trebol, Diamante (may move one down)

Middle Mid Tier
- Scratchman Apoo
- Magician" Basil Hawkins
- X. Drake
- Bartolomeo

Lower Mid Tier
- Cavendish
- Caesar Clown

If Luffy per chance defeats Dofy alone the tiers below Middle High Tier will mix up a lot

^^^^^^^^^^

 

[SSS12]

Please move Sentomaru up 1 tier he was low diffing Pre-TS Luffy at Sabaody and he is somehow in the same tier?

I second this.

And Zoro up 1 tier.
Prime Rayleigh up 1 tier.
Kizaru up 1 tier.
Kizaru and Aokiji should be in the same tier.

 

[Hexuze]

I second this.

And Zoro up 1 tier.
Prime Rayleigh up 1 tier.
Kizaru up 1 tier.
Kizaru and Aokiji should be in the same tier.

Kizaru is the weakest admiral from the pre-TS trio. He's fine where he is.

 

[shon93]

I'm going to be extremely agressive with my list but this is what I believe

God Tier
1)Gol Roger
2)Edward Newgate(Prime)
3)Monkey D Dragon
4)Red Hair Shanks
5)Garp(Prime)
6)Shiki

Reasoning:I believe these charcaters are unbeatable 1v1 unless its from a characater in that tier. So it would take 2 v 1 or even more to drop these guys

Top Top Tier
1)Blackbeard
2)Kaido
3)Big Mom
4)Kong
5)Akainu
6)Aokiji

Reasoning:These are all the charcaters that are the best of the best but they are not on god status yet...it would take an extreme diff to beat them whether it be 1 v 1 or 2 v 1

Mid Top Tier
Kizaru
2)Fujitora
3)Green Bull
4)Marco(PostTimeSkip)
5)Ben Beckman(No feats but speculation)

Reasoning:These are the admiral level chacters...who stands a 50/50 chance of beating an admiral..basically on par or an admiral themselve. These charcaters beat each other at an extreme diff

Low Top Tier
1)Sabo(flirting with mid top tier butneeds more feats to get in the mid top tier and probably mastery)
2)Doflamingo(A total beast but it wouldnt be 50/50 fight vs an admiral)
3)Marco(Pretimeskip)..(Despite the hype he couldn't hurt or beat an admiral)

Reasoning:These are the guys who can fight an admiral to a 60/40 result and lose a high diff fight with an admiral

High Tier
1)Luffy
2)Zoro
3)Kid
4)Law
5)Drake

Reasoning:These are the guys that will graduate to low top tiers in a couple of years. It would take 2 of them to beat or face any low top tier)

 

[U mAd]

I'm going to be extremely agressive with my list but this is what I believe

God Tier
1)Gol Roger
2)Edward Newgate(Prime)
3)Monkey D Dragon
4)Red Hair Shanks
5)Garp(Prime)
6)Shiki

Reasoning:I believe these charcaters are unbeatable 1v1 unless its from a characater in that tier. So it would take 2 v 1 or even more to drop these guys

Top Top Tier
1)Blackbeard
2)Kaido
3)Big Mom
4)Kong
5)Akainu

Reasoning:These are all the charcaters that are the best of the best but they are not on god status yet...it would take an extreme diff to beat them whether it be 1 v 1 or 2 v 1

Mid Top Tier
Kizaru
2)Fujitora
3)Green Bull
4)Marco(PostTimeSkip)
5)Ben Beckman(No feats but speculation)

Reasoning:These are the admiral level chacters...who stands a 50/50 chance of beating an admiral..basically on par or an admiral themselve. These charcaters beat each other at an extreme diff

Low Top Tier
1)Sabo(flirting with mid top tier butneeds more feats to get in the mid top tier and probably mastery)
2)Doflamingo(A total beast but it wouldnt be 50/50 fight vs an admiral)
3)Marco(Pretimeskip)

Reasoning:These are the guys who can fight an admiral to a 60/40 result and lose a high diff fight with an admiral

High Tier
1)Luffy
2)Zoro
3)Kid
4)Law
5)Drake

Reasoning:These are the guys that will graduate to low top tiers in a couple of years. It would take 2 of them to beat or face any low top tier)

your list is absolutely busllshit.

1st:shanks and dragon on the same tier as WB and roger WTF.
2nd:where the fu*k is aokiji
3rd:no way in hell doflimango vs an admiral would be 50/50 more like 70/30
4th:marco is at least=to kizaru and fuji

 

[shon93]

your list is absolutely busllshit.

1st:shanks and dragon on the same tier as WB and roger WTF.
2nd:where the fu*k is aokiji
3rd:no way in hell doflimango vs an admiral would be 50/50 more like 70/30
4th:marco is at least=to kizaru and fuji

I totally forgot Aokiji bro and my list is legit. I have post timeskip Marco in the same tier as them what are you talking about. Also I do have Dragon and Shanks in the same tier as Roger and Prime Whitebeard

Firstly Dragon is the son of garp and he is in his prime which means he is (prime garp) or above going from the three lines of the Monkey D family..and Garp and Roger fought death matches..And Shanks stop wars when top teirs are on the island..I see him being a god tier charcater also..it doesn't mean they can beat roger tho..it just means 1 v 1 they are impossible to beat

 

[U mAd]

I totally forgot Aokiji bro and my list is legit. I have post timeskip Marco in the same tier as them what are you talking about. Also I do have Dragon and Shanks in the same tier as Roger and Prime Whitebeard

Firstly Dragon is the son of garp and he is in his prime which means he is (prime garp) or above going from the three lines of the Monkey D family..and Garp and Roger fought death matches..And Shanks stop wars when top teirs are on the island..I see him being a god tier charcater also..it doesn't mean they can beat roger tho..it just means 1 v 1 they are impossible to beat

so your just putting people on highest tiers based on family tree and baseless assumptions.i do agree that shanks and dragon are strong but i think they should be a tier below roger and whitebeard.marco showed equal footing vs kizru and aokiji in marinefold suggesting that he's above flamingo who ran away upon encountering aokiji

 

[shon93]

so your just putting people on highest tiers based on family tree and baseless assumptions.i do agree that shanks and dragon are strong but i think they should be a tier below roger and whitebeard.marco showed equal footing vs kizru and aokiji in marinefold suggesting that he's above flamingo who ran away upon encountering aokiji

The man is the father of the main charcater and the son of a legendary marine but I understand what you are saying maybe God Tier is too much but thats what I believe..and you are fanboying over marco..he didn't hurt any admiral at MF...the man couldn't beat an injured Akainu with his commanders..Akainu comment towards Marco and Vista was like they were insects too him afyer they attacked with haki

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Heres mine I also prefer to use the marine ranking level + yonkou, PK, and God Tier

God Tier: Anyone who could beat Roger.

Joyboy: This guy was the king of the AK idk I just think he could beat Roger in a fight for some reason.
All Gorosei together: All 5 together will be immensly strong and probably Luffys final opponents.
EoS Luffy: He's the MC so its pretty obvious he will surpass Roger.

PK Tier: Anyone who can med diff a Marine Admiral

Roger: Obvious
Prime WB: He was only slightly weaker than Roger.
Garp: Same with WB, but the gap between him and Roger was a little bigger.

In between PK and yonkou level is Dragon.

Yonkou level: Anyone who can beat a FA level fighter but not a PK level fighter

All 4 yonkou: Obvious
An individual Gorosei in their prime: A guess.
Shiki: Obvious
Prime Sengoku: Obvious
Mihawk: Rivals Shanks
Prime Rayleigh:First Mate of a PK.


Fleet Admiral Level: Anyone between yonkou and admiral level

Post-TS Akainu: He is stronger than all admirals but weaker than a yonkou.

High Admiral level: Slightly stronger than your average admiral.

Pre TS Akainu: Obvious
Aokiji: Obvious

Med Admiral level: Your average admiral

All current admirals: Obvious

Yonkou first mates: Marco fought on par with Kizaru, Beckman could apparently fight on par with Kizaru, Shiryuu was Top VA level Pre TS and then has been in the the NW for 2 years. Other 2 are just because of hype.

Sabo: Is not going to get med diffed by Issho like people say, if the fight were to conclude Issho would win high diff.

Old Rayleigh:Fought equally with Kizaru.
Low admiral level: Could become an admiral if they were in the Marines, but would be lower than average for an admiral.

Doflamingo: Stronger than everyone who is Top VA level.
Kuma with a brain: OP DF.

Top VA level: Strongest of the VAs

Buster Call VAs(except Yamakiji): They performed the best at MF. They are Momonga, Doberman, Strawberry, and Onigumo.
Dalmation: One of the best VAs at MF.
Luffy: Can beat everyone in this level but not Doflamingo from current feats.
Vergo: Mid diffed Smoker, if not low diff.
Zoro: Can beat Sanji and Smoker, I can see him beating Vergo high diff.
Magellan: Very OP DF.
Law: Very close to Luffy.
Kidd: Same with Law.
X Drake: One of Kaido's high ranking officers.

High VA level: Beats mid VA level opponents.

Smoker: More impressive than most VAs.
Yamakiji: Hype
Hancock: Obvious
2 more VAs: I believe that every VA level has 5 of the 20 VAs.
Sanji: Can definitely beat any Mid VA level fighter, very close to Top VA level.
John Giant: Seems to be the strongest of the VA Giants.
Jinbe:I can see Luffy and Zoro beating him, and maybe Sanji can extreme diff.
Hawkins: One of the middle level Supernovas.
Apoo: Seems to be as strong as Hawkins.
Killer: Is the Zoro of the Kidd Pirates but lacks feats

Med VA level: Your average VA.

Enel: His strongest attack can destroy small islands, only lost at Skypiea because his attacks dont work on Luffy since he is rubber.
Bartolomeo: Low diffed Maynard.
5 more VAs: Mentioned why above.
Cavendish: Could probably low diff Maynard like Bart.
Franky: His General Form has been very impressive.
Robin: Probably close to Frankys level.
Pre TS Croc:Low diffed Luffy 2 times and only lost the 3rd time because of plot.
Capone: Spent 2 years in the NW
Bonney: Same as Capone
Urouge: Same as Capone.

Low VA level: Weakest VAs.

Maynard: Nuff said.
Brook: Weakest of the SH's Mid Trio
Pacifistas: Got in between mid and high diffed in a fight against all Pre TS Straw Hats. One shotted by Post TS Luffy.
4 more VAs: Mentioned why before.

In between are Pre TS Luffy and Lucci.

 

[U mAd]

Heres mine I also prefer to use the marine ranking level + yonkou, PK, and God Tier

God Tier: Anyone who could beat Roger.

Joyboy: This guy was the king of the AK idk I just think he could beat Roger in a fight for some reason.
All Gorosei together: All 5 together will be immensly strong and probably Luffys final opponents.
EoS Luffy: He's the MC so its pretty obvious he will surpass Roger.

PK Tier: Anyone who can med diff a Marine Admiral

Roger: Obvious
Prime WB: He was only slightly weaker than Roger.
Garp: Same with WB, but the gap between him and Roger was a little bigger.

In between PK and yonkou level is Dragon.

Yonkou level: Anyone who can beat a FA level fighter but not a PK level fighter

All 4 yonkou: Obvious
An individual Gorosei in their prime: A guess.
Shiki: Obvious
Prime Sengoku: Obvious
Mihawk: Rivals Shanks


Fleet Admiral Level: Anyone between yonkou and admiral level

Post-TS Akainu: He is stronger than all admirals but weaker than a yonkou.

High Admiral level: Slightly stronger than your average admiral.

Pre TS Akainu: Obvious
Aokiji: Obvious

Med Admiral level: Your average admiral

All current admirals: Obvious

Yonkou first mates: Marco fought on par with Kizaru, Beckman could apparently fight on par with Kizaru, Shiryuu was Top VA level Pre TS and then has been in the the NW for 2 years. Other 2 are just because of hype.

Sabo: Is not going to get med diffed by Issho like people say, if the fight were to conclude Issho would win high diff.

Low admiral level: Could become an admiral if they were in the Marines, but would be lower than average for an admiral.

Doflamingo: Stronger than everyone who is Top VA level.
Kuma with a brain: OP DF.

Top VA level: Strongest of the VAs

Buster Call VAs(except Yamakiji): They performed the best at MF. They are Momonga, Doberman, Strawberry, and Onigumo.
Dalmation: One of the best VAs at MF.
Luffy: Can beat everyone in this level but not Doflamingo from current feats.
Vergo: Mid diffed Smoker, if not low diff.
Zoro: Can beat Sanji and Smoker, I can see him beating Vergo high diff.
Magellan: Very OP DF.
Law: Very close to Luffy.
Kidd: Same with Law.

High VA level: Beats mid VA level opponents.

Smoker: More impressive than most VAs.
Yamakiji: Hype
Hancock: Obvious
2 more VAs: I believe that every VA level has 5 of the 20 VAs.
Sanji: Can definitely beat any Mid VA level fighter, very close to Top VA level.
John Giant: Seems to be the strongest of the VA Giants.

Med VA level: Your average VA.

Enel: His strongest attack can destroy small islands, only lost at Skypiea because his attacks dont work on Luffy since he is rubber.
Bartolomeo: Low diffed Maynard.
5 more VAs: Mentioned why above.
Cavendish: Could probably low diff Maynard like Bart.
Franky: His General Form has been very impressive.
Robin: Probably close to Frankys level.

Low VA level: Weakest VAs.

Maynard: Nuff said.
Brook: Weakest of the SH's Mid Trio
Pacifistas: Got in between mid and high diffed in a fight against all Pre TS Straw Hats. One shotted by Post TS Luffy.
4 more VAs: Mentioned why before.

In between are Pre TS Luffy and Lucci.

i mostly agree with this list.the charectera are perfectly placed in their respected tiers.just some missing.like rayleigh and hancock i think should be doffy level.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

i mostly agree with this list.the charectera are perfectly placed in their respected tiers.just some missing.like rayleigh and hancock i think should be doffy level.

We have only seem Hancock fight fodder so its hard to rate her, besides I think CoA can block her Mero Mero no Mi from turning you to stone. I didnt have enough time to include every character I am going to go back and add some later. Btw any other placements that you dont agree with?

 

[U mAd]

We have only seem Hancock fight fodder so its hard to rate her, besides I think CoA can block her Mero Mero no Mi from turning you to stone. I didnt have enough time to include every character I am going to go back and add some later. Btw any other placements that you dont agree with?

no i agree with all else just think x drake should be up there with law/kid and other spernovas should have been mentioined

 

[bajram]

This can be called a fan made top tier list, the **** so many things wrong here , give me a proof that shanks is above old WB give me a proof that teach is above old WB, how can u put up such featless characters without showing ever anything to the WSM confirmed by manga itself, basically this list is made based on ur logic>manga facts, and Mihawk is lower top tier while shanks is upper top tier when Mihawk is WSS and shanks is a swordsman, these 2 were rivals and u actually put on to low while the other to upper, so much wrong her, prime rayleigh weaker then yonkos, this is laughable simply laughable and borsalino isnt even a top tier, the shanks wank is so great that even with 0 feats/hype u get to know that he is levels above current fighters.

Jozu at a level of zoro and supernovas, again this list is laughable really, "rob lucci(post-ts)" pure gold, hahahaha do u guys have close contacts with oda or u chat with him when making this list, so much fanboism in his tier list, terrible.