[Theory] Rayleigh got his eye scar from Mihawk beating him.

[ultraChalk]

How plausible to you think this is? People theorize he was the greatest swordsman before being beat by Mihawk, where he claimed the coat that he used to wear.

It's unclear how he got that eye scar so this is my prediction. Nothing big

What do you think?

 

[Hexuze]

Many people theorized that. I think it's possible, there's no flaws with it.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

That king baboon could have done it.

 

[ultraChalk]

That king baboon could have done it.

I don't believe so... didn't part 1 Zoro beat him?

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

I don't believe so... didn't part 1 Zoro beat him?

I don't think they showed the fight.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Cool if he got it from Shiki or something.

But ye, I do believe he was the WsS before Mihawk.

 

[minatoisagod]

no he had it when he was facing shiki so i doubt it was from mihawk.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Nvm me saying the king baboon did it, I thought this was about Zoro.

 

[TheHokage]

No Rayleigh had his scar long before Shanks and Mihawk rose to power.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Can't really remember, but didn't he had that scar, while still being First Mate of Roger's crew, at that time Mihwak was very young rookie.

So, Prime Silvers to got scar from very young Pirate, is very unlikely, from my point of view.

Tho, I believe that he was former Best Swordsman.

 

[Reaper]

tbh you would think that a fight between 2 op swordsmen would leave a bigger wound than just a cut.
If it really did happen I am amazed they both have all their limbs

 

[SSS12]

As fascinating as it sounds, probably not. Rayleigh simply retired to a quieter life. I really don't think a much younger Mihawk could stand a chance against prime Rayleigh.

 

[beck26]

was this theory made because of luffy=roger thing again?

so just because roger got rayleigh does it mean that zoro needs to parallel rayleigh so much?

and both person injures their eye?

i mean, wtf is this parallel thing about luffy and roger that people are so forceful about?

 

[crono0929]

nope, look at the chapter 0, rayleigh had his scar while fighting shiki, long before mihawk and shanks were somebody.

 

[Fireplay]

Im surprised that people actually believe that Mihawk has beaten/can beat Prime Rayleigh. Hell no. Mihawk was still a kid when Rayleigh got that scar (Roger's execution).