Based on true story

The Dreamer

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jun 29, 2013
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
177
I'm not sure into wich section to put this so I put it here. (It's probably wrong tough.) Here's the deal. If I want to make a movie/book/comic etc. based on a real thing that happened but someone already made their own version of it, do I need to pay any copyright laws or am I free to make my own thing. Let's say we're talking about a story that happened like 2 decades ago and there were movies about it and I want to make my own movie version of it. So do I need to go by the copyright or am I free to make it? Any help is appreciated. :/
 
Last edited:

Ginyu Force

Banned
Joined
May 28, 2014
Messages
78
Reaction score
5
Mine would be so epic that profit money would consume you!
 

Tsunade123

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jun 18, 2014
Messages
2,363
Reaction score
140
U would need a copy right law so no one will copy u and urs can't be similar to the other but u can recreate one like planet if the aps was a really old movie then people changed it up
 

donnic

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 9, 2009
Messages
1,077
Reaction score
56
So Long as you give credit to ALL sources it should be fine. and Unless you plan on putting it in mass production, the copywrite laws should not effect you because you are making it "for your own enjoyment"
 

Sakuto

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Apr 30, 2014
Messages
887
Reaction score
78
If the idea is not your own, it is very well likely that you may end up stealing someones intellectual property (essentially, their idea).

As an example, say my idea was a movie where a computer virus that turns social media into physical manifestations of evil that are able to control technology throughout the world to end human society.

This would be my intellectual property, and because I have written it here it is technically proven to be my intellectual property unless this idea is found elsewhere with an earlier timestamp. Considering that I just made this up at the time of this post, it is still possible that another person has said it before me and therefore it is their intellectual property, though I have not stolen at, because we simply thought of the same thing.

Then there is copyright, which is a whole other story. Apple tried to copyright the word "pad", but they couldn't because it was a word. To circumvent this, they simply put the letter "i" in front of it to make iPad. This is not a real word, and therefore they were able to copyright such things. However, I believe it was a couple years ago that a company in China had copyright claims on the word "iPad" many years before Apple even made the copyright. This means that they were trying to copyright a copyrighted thing (stealing), so they were sued.

To answer your question directly...

- You can do this so long as the person has not claimed copyright or other anti-infringement claims.
- You do not plagiarise and otherwise steal any of the content the other party(s) have made.
- You do not create the exact same thing.
- You do not include anything that you do not permission for, such as titling a character "Superman" as it is a copyrighted term and I believe a trademarked character name.

However, to take the title from your thread "based on true story", if you're talking about writing a book, making a film or anything other than that having it based on a true story, as long as the story isn't copyrighted I'm fairly certain that you are allowed to make an adaptation of that story, however you can generally not entirely copy the story. There'd be no point in doing that, anyway...

If you were able to provide what exactly you were talking about (for example, an idea for a film) to put this in perspective. You can always visit government websites for plenty more information because all of these laws tend to work on county-wide regulations/laws.
 
Last edited:

The Dreamer

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jun 29, 2013
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
177
If the idea is not your own, it is very well likely that you may end up stealing someones intellectual property (essentially, their idea).

As an example, say my idea was a movie where a computer virus that turns social media into physical manifestations of evil that are able to control technology throughout the world to end human society.

This would be my intellectual property, and because I have written it here it is technically proven to be my intellectual property unless this idea is found elsewhere with an earlier timestamp. Considering that I just made this up at the time of this post, it is still possible that another person has said it before me and therefore it is their intellectual property, though I have not stolen at, because we simply thought of the same thing.

Then there is copyright, which is a whole other story. Apple tried to copyright the word "pad", but they couldn't because it was a word. To circumvent this, they simply put the letter "i" in front of it to make iPad. This is not a real word, and therefore they were able to copyright such things. However, I believe it was a couple years ago that a company in China had copyright claims on the word "iPad" many years before Apple even made the copyright. This means that they were trying to copyright a copyrighted thing (stealing), so they were sued.

To answer your question directly...

- You can do this so long as the person has not claimed copyright or other anti-infringement claims.
- You do not plagiarise and otherwise steal any of the content the other party(s) have made.
- You do not create the exact same thing.
- You do not include anything that you do not permission for, such as titling a character "Superman" as it is a copyrighted term and I believe a trademarked character name.

However, to take the title from your thread "based on true story", if you're talking about writing a book, making a film or anything other than that having it based on a true story, as long as the story isn't copyrighted I'm fairly certain that you are allowed to make an adaptation of that story, however you can generally not entirely copy the story. There'd be no point in doing that, anyway...

If you were able to provide what exactly you were talking about (for example, an idea for a film) to put this in perspective. You can always visit government websites for plenty more information because all of these laws tend to work on county-wide regulations/laws.
Tnx a lot but just to be sure I'll give a clearer image of what I mean. Let's take this as an example. There was a dog in Japan wich waited for his deceased owner until he died and this phenomena had captured the attention of people all over the world and there was a movie based on this event Hachiko: Dog's story. Now if I wanted to make a story based on that (not on the movie but on the actual dog) do I need to ask anyone for the permission? It's a situation like that really... :/
 

chopstickchakra

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Reaction score
1,012
Tnx a lot but just to be sure I'll give a clearer image of what I mean. Let's take this as an example. There was a dog in Japan wich waited for his deceased owner until he died and this phenomena had captured the attention of people all over the world and there was a movie based on this event Hachiko: Dog's story. Now if I wanted to make a story based on that (not on the movie but on the actual dog) do I need to ask anyone for the permission? It's a situation like that really... :/

No, as long as it's a real life event it's open for the taking. You can mkae 50 movies based off of WW2 without needing to get any permissions for the story. You genereally have to get in touch with the people the movie will be about though. I.E. if company A made a Lance Armstrong movie, company B could also make one but only with Lance's approval.
 

The Dreamer

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Jun 29, 2013
Messages
2,202
Reaction score
177
No, as long as it's a real life event it's open for the taking. You can mkae 50 movies based off of WW2 without needing to get any permissions for the story. You genereally have to get in touch with the people the movie will be about though. I.E. if company A made a Lance Armstrong movie, company B could also make one but only with Lance's approval.

Great. Good thing this isn't going to be about the people, let alone living things so I guess I'm free to start making sketches. Tnx! n.n
 
Top