who has the most originaly personality between naruto ichigo and luffy

[Thekiddreamer]

i say naruto by far, most of the shonen manga u see these days there are characters who's been copied by naruto

example black star from soul eater and there's many more i can state

ichigo personality is lame and annoying at the point it made me stop watching bleach,asspulls also count ,anyway his personality is a mixture of loads of characters so its not original and thus loses

now luffy from op , his is annoying mostly at the ebginning where he kept saying i am strong and nakama,though its better now but its still copied loads from differnt manga and has the same shonen cliche thus i'd say its alight



naruto top

luffy 2nd

ichigo out of 100

remember naruto personality got top spot when he faced nagato and didn't kill him even though i wanted him to kill nagato

do u agree

 

[Jimmy page]

Ichigo's is the most original. He's kinda lame imo though. Naruto and luffy are goku copies.

 

[Dannie]

Naruto is a half assed cop out of Goku.

Ichigo is the blond version of Sasuke

Luffy is the only one out of the three that is original from most shounen protagonists.

 

[ShiroShonen]

Ichigo imo

 

[ThatOfLegend]

Luffy's is my favorite but admittedly Naruto's is probably the best

 

[Young Vongola]

From what I've seen of Bleach, Ichigo is a pretty bland protagonist.

 

[King Kendrick]

Ichigo , imo luffy and naruto are little gokus .

 

[jimbobbity]

Am i the only one here who cant get through the first 5 episodes of OP :|

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

I don't see how Ichigo is like Goku.

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

Naruto is a half assed cop out of Goku.

Ichigo is the blond version of Sasuke

Luffy is the only one out of the three that is original from most shounen protagonists.

Deos having a few similarities and differences make him a half ass copy? He has to be completely different inorder to not be a copy?

 

[Nidds]

Naruto is the most consistent out of all of them and Luffy (especially Post-Timeskip) is alright. Ichigo is just flat out annoying

 

[SuperChief]

Naruto has by far the most depth and realism of any of them. He is flawed, he makes mistakes that matters, and he learns from his experiences. Compare Part I Naruto to Part II Naruto. There's a world of difference.

Luffy and Ichigo barely changed.

Naruto is a half assed cop out of Goku.

Ichigo is the blond version of Sasuke

Luffy is the only one out of the three that is original from most shounen protagonists.

Are you serious? Luffy is the most blatant copy of Goku, down from the looks to the techniques (Gear 2nd? More like Kaiōken) and the crew personalities. His stupidity is self imposed. There's no cause for it, unlike Goku who lived alone in the mountains for years.

 

[Jimmy page]

Am i the only one here who cant get through the first 5 episodes of OP :|

One of the few flaws of op. Oda had a weak beginning watch until mid baratie arc(around ep 24 or so) and you'll be hooked. After that it's just great all around

 

[rollin]

im gonna say naruto

 

[SyriousNaru]

All of them have equally original characters.

 

[Dannie]

Deos having a few similarities and differences make him a half ass copy? He has to be completely different inorder to not be a copy?

Kishimoto is a fan of Toriyama
> Naruto is loud, goofy, stupid and wants to protect his friends
> Goku is loud, goofy, stupid and wants to protect his friends
> They both wear bright clothes that standout

Go figure.
And yes, Naruto is a lesser cheesier version of Goku, so it makes it that much less enjoyable to look at him when I have seen the exact same thing when watching DBZ, but the only difference is that Goku was actually cool with his actions.
His first awakening of SSJ1 and SSJ3 were awesome.
Naruto is a second rate hack that tries to exemplify Goku but at the same time failed.

So, to answer your question, yes, he is a half assed copy.

Are you serious? Luffy is the most blatant copy of Goku, down from the looks to the techniques (Gear 2nd? More like Kaiōken) and the crew personalities. His stupidity is self imposed. There's no cause for it, unlike Goku who lived alone in the mountains for years.

Naruto is way more similar to Goku than Luffy is. I'm sorry that your fanboyish fapping of Naruto makes you cloud your judgment but this parallel of Naruto and Goku has been proven many times. They even have Naruto in the same exact costume as Goku in Storm 3. This proves how much they resemble each other.

Luffy's character is only similar to Goku when it comes to being stupid and protecting his friends and eating. Other than that, Luffy is his own person. Luffy doesn't try to instill the essence of peace like Goku and Naruto do. Luffy just wants to achieve one goal and that goal is becoming pirate king. If anyone gets in his way the he resumes to "kicking their ass" to get to where he needs to go.

Naruto and Goku are loving and care about everything. Luffy only cares about his goals and his nakama. Luffy doesn't go out of is way to help strangers that aren't connected to his life.

That's the difference, now leave me alone, fanboy.

 

[demon sage]

I'd say ichigo like most already said naruto is a mini version of goku . Luffy I really don't no about him it's just hard for me to actually get into op.

 

[cptenn94]

Naruto is a half assed cop out of Goku.

Ichigo is the blond version of Sasuke

Luffy is the only one out of the three that is original from most shounen protagonists.

Naruto is more annoying, but he is not that much of a goku copycat.(compared to luffy)

I dont watch bleach

Luffy is so similar to goku.(compared to naruto at least)
Both like to have fun with their fights. (until someone hurts their nakama, then they go crazy)
Both like to eat absurd amounts of food.
Both are carefree when not in danger.
Both are not very intelligent.
Both have little interest in women.
Both are pure hearted.
etc.


Luffy is the better personality in general I think. But naruto is far more original.

In comparison to the traits above that goku and luffy share here are the traits that naruto has instead.

Naruto doesnt reall have fun or toy around in his fights. He is generall serious in all of his fights.
Naruto doesnt eat absurd amounts of food. He just eats signifigant amounts of ramen.
Naruto can be more relaxed while not in danger. But for most of the series when not in danger he is more seriously focused on other things, such as sasuke etc.
Naruto is not very intelligent usually, but he is very clever and talented at unconventional strategies.
Naruto has a large interest in women. Specifically sakura. He is interested enough at least to invent perverted jutsu.
Naruto isnt pure hearted. He has some issues going on, but his intentions can be pure.


Unique traits of naruto
He is a prankster/troublemaker(troublemaker as in he specifically would go out and cause trouble)
He was crazy reckless, and would often fight people even though he had no chance against them. Goku/luffy on the other hand would be more confident in their abilities, and would have the strength to back it up.
He was a complete failure.(luffy and goku from the start were strong. Not meeting any serious opposition for many arcs.)
He has deep character depths. Naruto was much more darker compared to goku and luffy. He was quick to anger, and had some serious issues earlier on in life.
Naruto likes to resolve his conflicts by diologue. (see the many talk no jutsu) Goku and luffy just fight till they defeat or kill the enemy.)
Naruto specifically wants to help people. He wants to help them let go of their hate and pain. Goku and luffy do not. Helping people, etc us just a byproduct of their loyalty and love for their friends.


If you disagree and really think naruto is more like goku, then please provide specific examples of why he is like goku.

Until then, I will stick to my opinion, that luffy is the most goku like between the two.

And narutos personality is more original than luffy.(note, i am not saying who has the better personality. Just the most original.)

I really dont know much about bleach other than the general plot line. So obviously, I cannot make a opinion on something in which I am clueless about.


(I like luffys personality more by the way. He is more simple and I can laugh at him much easier than naruto.)

 

[Omega]

Luffy has got to be the most original I have ever seen. xD

 

[Dannie]

Snip

Cool story bro.

Not that it will change my opinion.

Naruto is a shitty boring character with one dimensional thirst for Sasuke.
At least Luffy is actually tolerable to look at.