- Joined
- Nov 3, 2011
- Messages
- 23,996
- Reaction score
- 5,084
I don't call it asspull without a good reason, minamoto. Plot twists always have subtle hints, but the points you bought into your theory are not sufficient, due the straightforward interpretation that was reflected on most of readers, me included.
There are not even a piece of hint pointing towards the possibility of the existence of a second Madara.
Personally, I don't discard this possibility, it is against my policy to discard possibilities without definite proof.
BUT, all things said in manga until this point is interpretable just as Obito being able to perfectly imitate Madara, just as Yamato was able to imitate Sasori. Also, it points towards the fact that Obito lived a lot of years with Madara, meaning that Obito had access to all the intel needed to speak as if he was Madara himself, just because Madara gave Obito the legacy of the "Savior", and Obito played this role perfectly until the point of Obito betraying him.
The reason of why I don't believe that Zetsu has anything to do with Madara at this point (referring to all kinds of zetsu, Spiral included):
You must be registered for see links
"BZ: I'm Kaguya's child"
You must be registered for see links
"BZ: Right before the sealing, I was born"
You must be registered for see links
"Not even Hagoromo knows this" <- Hagoromo doesn't know that he has a second brother, ergo, he doesn't know what happened to the Uchiha Monument, and not even Madara knows about this. Plus, as Hagoromo's brother, BZ has to have enough power to trick any Uchiha, even Madara. He isn't fodder, he is like the third Sage of Six Paths, it's Kaguya's will after all... her third son.
You must be registered for see links
And here... Madara was tricked.
You must be registered for see links
You must be registered for see links
...Because in reality, they are the result of IT:
You must be registered for see links
You must be registered for see links
And that's all.
Madara was just another puppet of BZ. These are just manga facts. Rejecting these at this point would only be playing to be in denial.
If your point is to tell that Madara was able to see through the deception and decyphered BZ's plan, well, bring proof of this statement.
Every theory is based on facts and speculation, but your theory doesn't have facts as pillars. Can you prove that Madara saw through deception and decyphered this plan? Bring manga pages! That's how I will be going to believe you!
ok i get it you disagree with my theory..its fine...i respect your opinion