Did Madara know that the shinju was kaguya?

[Seventh Sama]

Hi everyone, I'll cut to the chase.

I'm in argument with this dude who believes that madara absorbing the shinju somehow knew that kaguya was the tree herself and i'm here saying that's impossible since madara thought it was the actual shinju thus he didn't know kaguya somehow merged with the tree.

So, I'll just end this argument with a poll.

P.S if you have anything to add to my or his agrument please post what you think.

 

[Gein]

Im pretty sure he figured it out when she said absorb the tree or whatever

 

[Grammar Nazi]

IMO he had an idea ever since obtaining the third eye. However, he knew nothing about the betrayal and BZ backstory.

 

[Fex]

If the guy was not smart enough to know that absorbing the tree will change his will then I'm not sure he knew that that same tree was Kaguya.

 

[ugh]

You must be registered for see images

just drop this off

 

[Calpal]

He had no idea. he thought that the voice that spoke to him was the Shinju, almost right after that he absorbs the tree and rants about being the saviour.
The eye, he thought, was the strongest technique obtained by absorbing the Shinju.

 

[Shadow Phantasm]

Probaly not,he might have suspected something though.

 

[Kyuubi99]

Most likely, he didn't know it was Kaguya talking to him, and probably thought it was the juubi itself. Then after having absorbed the shinju/kaguya, he changed.:hyper:

 

[Bulldawg]

Hi everyone, I'll cut to the chase.

I'm in argument with this dude who believes that madara absorbing the shinju somehow knew that kaguya was the tree herself and i'm here saying that's impossible since madara thought it was the actual shinju thus he didn't know kaguya somehow merged with the tree.

So, I'll just end this argument with a poll.

P.S if you have anything to add to my or his agrument please post what you think.

The Orange Kage Solo'd it,
With that being said no, madara thought it was the beast that told him to absorb the tree but a lot of ppl think kaguya was inside the shinju flower form but she's really in the juubi.

 

[XY iNVeRSe]

You must be registered for see images

just drop this off

YOU BEAT ME TO IT!

this/thread

i'm gonna drop this off too

You must be registered for see images

 

[XY iNVeRSe]

I'M TYPING IN ALL CAPS SO THIS DOESN'Y GET IGNORED.

WE DID HAVE A BRIEF DEBATE ABOUT THIS.

MY ARGUMENT IS: AFTER MADARA ABSORBED THE SHINJU (AFTER MADARA ABSORBED IT, NOT BEFORE) HE KNEW THAT KAGUYA WAS THE SHINJU. THESE SCANS SHOULD BE VALID EVIDENCE OF THAT.

You must be registered for see images

THEN AFTER HE COMPLETED INFINITE YSUKUYOMI, HE SAID THIS.

You must be registered for see images

IF YOU GUYS DONT THINK THAT HE KNEW IT WAS KAGUYA AND THAT HE THOUGHT HE WAS TALKING TO THE JUUBI ITSELF. I CAN BRING UP SCANS ON HOW OBITO, KURAMA ETC. STATED THAT THE JUUBI DIDN'T FUNCTION RIGHT (BASICALLY HE WAS RETARTED) AND TO ADD ON, DOESN'T KAGUYA HAVE A WOMEN VOICE?? AND ANOTHER THING IS THAT MADARA HAD ALREADY ABSORBED THE JUUBI BEFORE HE EVEN ABSORBED THE SHINJU. I THINK I'VE SAID ALL THAT I CAN WITHOUT REPEATING MYSELF.

THX IF YOU READ.

 

[Seventh Sama]

I'M TYPING IN ALL CAPS SO THIS DOESN'Y GET IGNORED.

WE DID HAVE A BRIEF DEBATE ABOUT THIS.

MY ARGUMENT IS: AFTER MADARA ABSORBED THE SHINJU (AFTER MADARA ABSORBED IT, NOT BEFORE) HE KNEW THAT KAGUYA WAS THE SHINJU. THESE SCANS SHOULD BE VALID EVIDENCE OF THAT.

You must be registered for see images

THEN AFTER HE COMPLETED INFINITE YSUKUYOMI, HE SAID THIS.

You must be registered for see images

IF YOU GUYS DONT THINK THAT HE KNEW IT WAS KAGUYA AND THAT HE THOUGHT HE WAS TALKING TO THE JUUBI ITSELF. I CAN BRING UP SCANS ON HOW OBITO, KURAMA ETC. STATED THAT THE JUUBI DIDN'T FUNCTION RIGHT (BASICALLY HE WAS RETARTED) AND TO ADD ON, DOESN'T KAGUYA HAVE A WOMEN VOICE?? AND ANOTHER THING IS THAT MADARA HAD ALREADY ABSORBED THE JUUBI BEFORE HE EVEN ABSORBED THE SHINJU. I THINK I'VE SAID ALL THAT I CAN WITHOUT REPEATING MYSELF.

THX IF YOU READ.

No double posting and pls tell me just because he heard a women's voice he's going to automatically know its kaguya? Oh dam I must've missed the part where kaguya and madara had a legit conversation and recognized each other.

 

[zorakovic]

yes , he does
static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/4/47703/3778650-untitled-3.jpg

 

[XY iNVeRSe]

No double posting and pls tell me just because he heard a women's voice he's going to automatically know its kaguya? Oh dam I must've missed the part where kaguya and madara had a legit conversation and recognized each other.

He knows about kaguya. who else would he expect it to be? the juubi? because he already absorbed the juubi chapters before that and no one spoke until he obtained the shinju tree.

 

[Seventh Sama]

He knows about kaguya. who else would he expect it to be? the juubi? because he already absorbed the juubi chapters before that and no one spoke until he obtained the shinju tree.

Bruh, did kaguya introduce herself to madara? He assumed the shinju was sentient not mindless like how he thought the bijuu's were.

 

[XY iNVeRSe]

Bruh, did kaguya introduce herself to madara? He assumed the shinju was sentient not mindless like how he thought the bijuu's were.

why are you ignoring those scans. lemme ask you a question. what did madara mean when he said. "I see..... the holy tree itself"? then outta nowhere kaguya shows up.

 

[Seventh Sama]

why are you ignoring those scans. lemme ask you a question. what did madara mean when he said. "I see..... the holy tree itself"? then outta nowhere kaguya shows up.

has a mind, I mean wouldn't he be questioning the stone tablet if he found ou kaguya really is the shinju? Since the tablet stated the shinju transformed into the juubi? Anyways madara isn't the type of guy who would share his power with someone or he would be suspicious of kaguya if he knew it was her.

 

[demon sage]

I don't think knew

 

[XY iNVeRSe]

anyways madara isn't the type of guy who would share his power with someone or he would be suspicious of kaguya if he knew it was her.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Seventh Sama]

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images