chaos control
Anbu Operative 🎭
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2013
- Messages
- 4,586
- Reaction score
- 433
Here is the argument that you guys are using: "Kaguya was a human before she ate the fruit. She didn't get her power and appearance until after she ate it."
My response: The belief that Kaguya is an alien doesn't come from her byakugan or her power or even her appearance. It comes from that whole comment about Kaguya wanting to turn everybody into soldiers. If the Naruto universe only has Earth, and everybody on Earth is under the infinite tsukuyomi and being turned into white Zetsus, then who the heck would Kaguya be fighting for her to need soldiers? There would be nobody to fight.
Plus, Hagoromo said that he himself was not an alien when Naruto asked him that (and then he went on to say that Naruto was not far off). This could simply mean that Hagoromo and Hamura were born on Earth (as opposed to where ever Kaguya was born) and as a result, he doesn't consider himself an alien since he was born here (on Earth). He never stated that Kaguya was not an alien.
Furthermore, when Madara told Hashirama about Kaguya, he just said that Kaguya was a princess. He never said that she was a human princess.
Many of you may use the argument that she did not have her power before eating the fruit, but who is to say that her alien race would automatically have power? There is no law that says that aliens can't be powerless like humans. Kaguya simply could have been a very human-like alien that had no powers before eating the fruit.
Hagoromo even said to Naruto: "My mother came to "your land" from a far away place to pluck the fruit of the shinju".
Now tell me people: What could Hagoromo have possibly been referring to when he said "your land" (and he said "your land directly to Naruto)? Could he have been referring to Konoha perhaps? No! Konoha was not even close to existing back then! Perhaps the land of fire in general? I doubt it!
Also, Naruto was not born back then, so what land could Hagoromo have referred to while being correct in using the word "your" to Naruto (who wasn't born and therefore could not possibly own or share any land)? Well, what is the only piece of land that all humans collectively share?
The answer: Earth! Also, "your land" implies that it was not Kaguya's land. Therefore, it was either bad word choice on Kishi's part to use the word "your", or Kaguya is not from Earth.
Do you see? It is not based on Kaguya's looks or power. Her looks only add fuel to the fire. It is really the soldiers comment and the "your land" comment that really propagate the "ninja star wars" theories.
If you still disagree with me, share your thoughts and give your explanation about the soldiers comment and the "your land" comment.
My response: The belief that Kaguya is an alien doesn't come from her byakugan or her power or even her appearance. It comes from that whole comment about Kaguya wanting to turn everybody into soldiers. If the Naruto universe only has Earth, and everybody on Earth is under the infinite tsukuyomi and being turned into white Zetsus, then who the heck would Kaguya be fighting for her to need soldiers? There would be nobody to fight.
Plus, Hagoromo said that he himself was not an alien when Naruto asked him that (and then he went on to say that Naruto was not far off). This could simply mean that Hagoromo and Hamura were born on Earth (as opposed to where ever Kaguya was born) and as a result, he doesn't consider himself an alien since he was born here (on Earth). He never stated that Kaguya was not an alien.
Furthermore, when Madara told Hashirama about Kaguya, he just said that Kaguya was a princess. He never said that she was a human princess.
Many of you may use the argument that she did not have her power before eating the fruit, but who is to say that her alien race would automatically have power? There is no law that says that aliens can't be powerless like humans. Kaguya simply could have been a very human-like alien that had no powers before eating the fruit.
Hagoromo even said to Naruto: "My mother came to "your land" from a far away place to pluck the fruit of the shinju".
Now tell me people: What could Hagoromo have possibly been referring to when he said "your land" (and he said "your land directly to Naruto)? Could he have been referring to Konoha perhaps? No! Konoha was not even close to existing back then! Perhaps the land of fire in general? I doubt it!
Also, Naruto was not born back then, so what land could Hagoromo have referred to while being correct in using the word "your" to Naruto (who wasn't born and therefore could not possibly own or share any land)? Well, what is the only piece of land that all humans collectively share?
The answer: Earth! Also, "your land" implies that it was not Kaguya's land. Therefore, it was either bad word choice on Kishi's part to use the word "your", or Kaguya is not from Earth.
Do you see? It is not based on Kaguya's looks or power. Her looks only add fuel to the fire. It is really the soldiers comment and the "your land" comment that really propagate the "ninja star wars" theories.
If you still disagree with me, share your thoughts and give your explanation about the soldiers comment and the "your land" comment.
