Dead Demon Consuming Seal perk for Edo Minato/Hiruzen?

[Theory]

For those who don't recall the jutsu "Sealing Technique: Dead Demon Consuming Seal" it was used by Hiruzen & Minato in both manga and anime. The sealing technique summons a Demon Shinigami (soul reaper) that devours the targets soul, completely sealing it for eternity in the shinigami's stomach. This technique is double edged as the user is also engulfed by the summoned demon making it a forbidden jutsu.

So what I wanted to debate on would be: What happens if Minato got his arms back and in Edo mode summons the Demon Shinigami? Will his soul be taken again? or because he is an edo he'll have the perk of using that jutsu as many times as he possibly wants meaning he becomes the most OP char in the Naruto world apart from Hiruzen (who not only knows the jutsu but also is an Edo, and has both arms).

Tell me what you think guys!

 

[Filo]

he can't summon the RDS as an EDO you need a living body to sacrifice

 

[The Amazing Spider Man]

He is not living therefore he has nothing to sacrifice making summoning it useless.

 

[Madara ibn Lahad]

Not living so no dead seal....

 

[Torche]

he can't summon the RDS as an EDO you need a living body to sacrifice

He is not living therefore he has nothing to sacrifice making summoning it useless.

Not living so no dead seal....

These, though if via asspull it worked, it would take his soul too.

 

[Hàdes1]

he can't summon the RDS as an EDO you need a living body to sacrifice

^ this.....

 

[snake orochimaru]

RDS requires a soul; what do edos have in their fake bodies? souls!


the only problem would be the conflict that appears due to the fact that the edo is under a contract with the summoner, which means that he probably won't be able to make a contract himself with the demon;

it could happen if the edo knows how to break the contract, like Madara did.


OT: one soul -> one use. it's simple. therefore, Minato can't be OP as f**k.


cheers!

 

[KisuneUchiha]

RDS requires a soul; what do edos have in their fake bodies? souls!


the only problem would be the conflict that appears due to the fact that the edo is under a contract with the summoner, which means that he probably won't be able to make a contract himself with the demon;

it could happen if the edo knows how to break the contract, like Madara did.


OT: one soul -> one use. it's simple. therefore, Minato can't be OP as f**k.


cheers!

^^^^ this.

 

[Lay]

He can't without a soul

 

[Asmodai]

RDS requires a soul; what do edos have in their fake bodies? souls!


the only problem would be the conflict that appears due to the fact that the edo is under a contract with the summoner, which means that he probably won't be able to make a contract himself with the demon;

it could happen if the edo knows how to break the contract, like Madara did.


OT: one soul -> one use. it's simple. therefore, Minato can't be OP as f**k.


cheers!

this one ^_^

 

[Nattana]

Technically they should be able to.

 

[Exaar]

He should be able to. The cost of the seal if the users soul.

Edo tensei's are basically souls of the dead (Hiruzen/Minato in this case) placed in living bodies. It doesn't matter if the body is dead or not, Aslong as there is a soul to offer the jutsu should work.