[Discussion] Natsu vs Erza who would win now?

mishoa

Member
Joined
May 20, 2014
Messages
247
Reaction score
10
Contains Slight Spoilers


Okay I have been having this debate with my friend who is a total Natsu fan-boy about who would win in a fight in the current arc Natsu or Erza.He told me that a Natsu surpassed her in the Tower of Heaven arc(ridiculous). I just don't think Natsu is a that level yet I really don't think he can beat any of the S class mages ( Erza, Laxus, Mirajane, or Gildarts) Here is a list of Erza's feats and why I don't think he is at her level yet please respond with your own reasons why Natsu is better I would like a lively debate.

1. In terms of durability I put Erza near top of fairy tail I think by now it's clear that she can take an immense amount of damage and still get up(Jupiter, taking over 200 organic link magic hits from thunder palace, hits from great tree arc,etc.)

2. Physical strength is high (able lift lift objects several times her own weight)

3. Swordsmanship( proven to be one of the top swords woman in the world along with Kagura)

3. Leadership ability ( Erza and Gray are usually the ones who came up with plans when in sticky situations, Makarov considered her for guild master but decided that she was just too young)

4. Immense magic power ( was stated to be near Jose a wizard saint in power if she had not taken Jupiter, her and her counter part were able to destroy a whole floating Island, she was the only one not affected by the second origin release, again beat 100 monsters when the stronger ones were stated to be at wizard saint levels of power,was able to keep up with guild ace kagura without using second origin, and and was able to ware an armor that no one else could because it used so much magic power and that let her bend the laws of magic)

5. great strategic mind for battle (is able to pick and use effectively the perfect armor with the right properties that will help her gain an advantage or win the battle)


that's it what do you think?
 
Last edited:

- J AV -

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2012
Messages
5,805
Reaction score
652
Natsu wins very very high diff.
 

cajin

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 31, 2013
Messages
1,208
Reaction score
77
Natsu stomps. But only if Erza doesn't pull some super high power suit out of her a**...
 

A e r o

Member
Joined
May 8, 2014
Messages
419
Reaction score
18
Doesn't Erza troll armor stop magic?

Ezra mid-high difficulty w/o said armor.
 

mishoa

Member
Joined
May 20, 2014
Messages
247
Reaction score
10
When you say natsu stomps there is no evidence in the anime, manga, or otherwise that supports that he is on her level plus 95% of his victories come from random power up's ( Etherion eating, eating Jellal's gold flame, Laxus giving natsu his lightning, etc.) so if anybody is winning with an a** pull it would be natsu
 

Gintõki1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 11, 2014
Messages
8,016
Reaction score
974
Natsu wins but very very close.
 

mishoa

Member
Joined
May 20, 2014
Messages
247
Reaction score
10
Natsu always will win

again there is no logic to this statement I made this post because I honestly wanted to know why Natsu fan-boys believed he would win but if your only basis is he is the main character and he always wins than you don't don't have a very good grasp on the story your supposedly following
 

lubricati0n

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jul 29, 2011
Messages
3,128
Reaction score
205
Wouldn't Erza's Nakagami armor win this for her? That shit is broken.
 

F E A R

Member
Joined
May 11, 2014
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
Because he is the main character of Fairy Tail and is suppose to be stronger than anyone else. And he is the only one that can kill Zeref. Can Erza kill Zeref? No. There are other reasons why he is stronger. Just like Naruto, Luffy, Ichigo are the strongest. But the problem that bugs me is why did he gave up vs Gildarts. By watching Naruto and One Piece. Naruto and Luffy never gave up no matter who they were up against. Like Luffy fought Enel stronger than Gildarts himself. And Naruto vs Pain. Guys like Pain and Enel who are so OP especially Pain and Enel lost to Naruto and Luffy. But Natsu gave up vs Gildarts (it's not like I'm saying Gildarts is an enemy) he should've fought to the end and maybe during the fight he could've unleashed some new power with Igneel appearing behind his back like Kurama did with Naruto. But what can you do Hiro drew that scene. That's the only thing that made me angry seeing the main character giving up.
 

Memento Mori

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
12,577
Reaction score
612
Because he is the main character of Fairy Tail and is suppose to be stronger than anyone else. And he is the only one that can kill Zeref. Can Erza kill Zeref? No. There are other reasons why he is stronger. Just like Naruto, Luffy, Ichigo are the strongest. But the problem that bugs me is why did he gave up vs Gildarts. By watching Naruto and One Piece. Naruto and Luffy never gave up no matter who they were up against. Like Luffy fought Enel stronger than Gildarts himself. And Naruto vs Pain. Guys like Pain and Enel who are so OP especially Pain and Enel lost to Naruto and Luffy. But Natsu gave up vs Gildarts (it's not like I'm saying Gildarts is an enemy) he should've fought to the end and maybe during the fight he could've unleashed some new power with Igneel appearing behind his back like Kurama did with Naruto. But what can you do Hiro drew that scene. That's the only thing that made me angry seeing the main character giving up.

Gildtartz Crash magic will crash any magic........To fight him you must be Acnologia U_U

Gildarts ovrpowered Natsu by his Magical Power
 

Kagerou

Banned
Elite
Joined
Nov 23, 2012
Messages
8,554
Reaction score
812
Half these comments are biased.

Natsu doesn't win because he's the "main character". Everyone in Fairy Tail is the main character, hence the series being called that.
I would have to call this a very very close tie, Natsu rely's alot on willpower, that's his main strength, And that's what got him through most of the series. Natsu would never hurt a teammate's so badly as to put them into a state of death, I don't believe Erza would do that either. Erza has alot of armor that can be strong against Natsu, so Natsu would have to be extra cautious when fighting.
 

Mahesvara

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 5, 2014
Messages
8,453
Reaction score
588
In the end he's going to be the strongest wizard in the series so it really doesn't matter, but for the sake of the thread I'd say Natsu would win mainly due to thunder flame dragon mode. Natsu surpassed her during the battle against Hades when he gained Laxus's power to me.
 

A e r o

Member
Joined
May 8, 2014
Messages
419
Reaction score
18
Well the main character is lucy irc. Story tells her life as a FT member according to the wiki.
 

Kagerou

Banned
Elite
Joined
Nov 23, 2012
Messages
8,554
Reaction score
812
Well the main character is lucy irc. Story tells her life as a FT member according to the wiki.

Lucy is not the main character, She is the female protagonist. Natsu is the male protagonist. The story doesn't really even tell the story through her eyes, it tells it through other people, that's why the whole Fairy Tail guild are the main character themselves.
 
Top