[Discussion] I really tried to like Fairy Tail...

Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
251
Reaction score
33
.but all I see is rip offs from other successful manga that came first, just with more boobs.

Not trying to put a bash thread here but all the names from Kenichi, the entire theme from naruto with literal name alterations magic - jutsu, hidden village- guild, dragon - tailed beast, more ninja cats, etc.

A lot of one piece too.

I don't know. Think it would be interesting to point out some of te similarities in a single thread. I want to write a manga and it turns out that the theme I wanted has been done in a smaller manga already but much different than I was thinking. I want to see how similar it can be before it's considered a blatant rip off. Lol
 

Zanithe

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Apr 10, 2014
Messages
4,865
Reaction score
174
They offer something Naruto didn't offer:

FANSERVICE
 

Mattek2008

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
2,290
Reaction score
242
I've never tried to read it, but i've heard so much negativity about it, so i i don't think i'll start ;)
 
Last edited:

Aoihime

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
5,432
Reaction score
637
Yep natsu is like a fusion of Naruto and Sakura looks wise and personality wise:bouncy:

But I actually like fairy tail but your right it does copy the theme of Naruto I kinda noticed that

And there's that orange haired player dude is it just me or does he look kinda like ichigo
 

Umari Senju

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
12,535
Reaction score
1,192
I've never tried to read it, but i've heard so much negativity about it, so i i don't i'll start ;)

I read it, And I don't hate it. At the same time the OP is right though. You just have to know what your getting into when reading/Watching Fairy Tail.

Aside the fan service. the good guys always win even when they are outmatched the power of friendship is extremely prevalent in FT and is the deciding factor in almost every battle.

The plus side? At least the females are as strong as the boys if not stronger. Erza is pretty consistant with her power. She has been one of the most powerful mages since the begining of the manga without any new powerups. Her arsenal is just vast so she has a weopn/armor for pretty much every situation.

Natsu isn't so bad....that's all I can say.

I am disappointed in Gajeel. Wendy the damn kid dragon Slayer is more badass then him now. He hasn't really been getting any panel time which is lame.

Lucy?....well they need to add more to her stellar lineup and stop using her just to be naked XD

Laxus-badass from the getgo

But as far as the story and plot go? Bleach has a better story....That would be an insult to those of you who don't read Bleach XD
 

Mattek2008

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
2,290
Reaction score
242
I read it, And I don't hate it. At the same time the OP is right though. You just have to know what your getting into when reading/Watching Fairy Tail.

Aside the fan service. the good guys always win even when they are outmatched the power of friendship is extremely prevalent in FT and is the deciding factor in almost every battle.

The plus side? At least the females are as strong as the boys if not stronger. Erza is pretty consistant with her power. She has been one of the most powerful mages since the begining of the manga without any new powerups. Her arsenal is just vast so she has a weopn/armor for pretty much every situation.

Natsu isn't so bad....that's all I can say.

I am disappointed in Gajeel. Wendy the damn kid dragon Slayer is more badass then him now. He hasn't really been getting any panel time which is lame.

Lucy?....well they need to add more to her stellar lineup and stop using her just to be naked XD

Laxus-badass from the getgo

But as far as the story and plot go? Bleach has a better story....That would be an insult to those of you who don't read Bleach XD

I own the first 6 or so volumes of bleach. Just can't find the time to get into it xD

I own the first 6 or so volumes of bleach. Just can't find the time to get into it xD

yeah it starts somewhat slow. But once Ichigo heads to Soul Society things really start to pick up from there. Alot of volumes to go through. They are on their last volume now so it will rap up sometime next year I think.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Erebus

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
4,274
Reaction score
312
I read it because I want to see what my fav character(Gray) would do, unfortunately he hasn't has the spotlight in like forever :shy: Haha, but know that i think about it, it's what i usually wake up to every Friday morning, that's good
 
Last edited:

Royal Uchiha

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Mar 29, 2014
Messages
675
Reaction score
68
I read FT but it has ups and downs, as example, I haven't seen Natsu losing yet and the manga is contradicting realism, girls that have more raw power than boys c'mon, I better go watch a pointless action movie.
 

Lyke

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Jan 18, 2013
Messages
12,598
Reaction score
1,361
Fairy Tail best Anime without doubt.. Seriously
 

Caliburn

𝕷𝔢𝖔 𝕭𝔢𝖑𝔤𝖎𝔠𝖚𝔰
Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,944
Reaction score
4,197
.but all I see is rip offs from other successful manga that came first, just with more boobs.

Not trying to put a bash thread here but all the names from Kenichi, the entire theme from naruto with literal name alterations magic - jutsu, hidden village- guild, dragon - tailed beast, more ninja cats, etc.

A lot of one piece too.

I don't know. Think it would be interesting to point out some of te similarities in a single thread. I want to write a manga and it turns out that the theme I wanted has been done in a smaller manga already but much different than I was thinking. I want to see how similar it can be before it's considered a blatant rip off. Lol

Everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion, but for some reason it happens a lot with FT, more so than with other series, that people are seeing what they want to see just so that they could say it's ripped off, while it isn't or in the least it's something so universal that saying it's ripped off can only be seen as a sign of ill will.

Names?

I'm not going to start searching for all the names and compare them, but the only one that comes to mind are Natsu Tanimoto and Natsu Dragneel and Natsu isn't really a unique name. Sorry, but that is not even remotely a rip off. Have you any idea how many Yamato's, Sengoku's, Sakura's and Minato's are out there? Many of these Japanese names are like the equivalent of an American character being named Jack or John. Fact is that FT even has quite a large variety of names. Hiro so far has used Japanese, Dutch, German, English, American, Spanish etc. names.

There are no names being ripped off in FT, that's just you thinking because a name that appears there also appears somewhere else, it must be a rip off.

Ninja Cats?

Where are there ninja cats? The Exceed? Sorry, but other than that both have the ability to speak -and Naruto isn't the first series with talking animals and cats- there is nothing really that makes them the same. Not to mention I seriously wonder if Naruto was even the first one of the two to have a talking cat in the series as Happy was introduced in chapter one, though I'm not really going to bother to check that. The two concepts are very different.

Tailed beasts and dragons?

Are you now serious? Have you any idea how many series there are with monsters like that? And their concepts are completley different. Dragons are an actual species in FT, while the Tailed Beasts have a set number, were created and play an important role in the entire concept of Jinchuriki's and the like. They are not the same. It's impossible to even consider that as a rip off.

Magic and jutsu?

Ki, reatsu, chakra, magic...this is one of the most recurrent concepts in manga series. This is something so universal it's impossible to steal it unless it would be word for word. The concept of 'jutsu' isn't even something Kishi created, it already existed in real life and nearly every manga that is of the fantasy/supernatural genre has people running around that spam elements, control shadows and whatnot which originate from a 'source'.

Guilds and villages?

If anything they are the complete opposite. Ninja villages are hidden, are practically a military and do even assassination jobs. Guilds are right in the middle of the cities, are in the hands of individual persons, they can't fight among each other, belong under the same organization, can not take things like assassination jobs etc.


What you did was intentionally trying to see things of FT being ripped off from other series, while the reality is that none of the things you listed got stolen. FT and OP have the same vibe, but that's very superficial and comes from the whole 'nakama' theme, which comes from Goku of Dragonball. There isn't any significant thing in FT that could be considered being ripped off from OP as it's too common. Same thing with people who claim that OP has been ripping off from FT.
 
Last edited:

YellowFang

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 16, 2010
Messages
9,806
Reaction score
704
Just when I try to focus on storyline and characters... Boobs come in and make me distracted...
 

Dãrth1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
7,548
Reaction score
255
Just when I try to focus on storyline and characters... Boobs come in and make me distracted...

Why everytime someone comments something about Fairy Tail someone has to say something about this...
 

Memento Mori

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
12,577
Reaction score
612
Everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion, but for some reason it happens a lot with FT, more so than with other series, that people are seeing what they want to see just so that they could say it's ripped off, while it isn't or in the least it's something so universal that saying it's ripped off can only be seen as a sign of ill will.

Names?

I'm not going to start searching for all the names and compare them, but the only one that comes to mind are Natsu Tanimoto and Natsu Dragneel and Natsu isn't really a unique name. Sorry, but that is not even remotely a rip off. Have you any idea how many Yamato's, Sengoku's, Sakura's and Minato's are out there? Many of these Japanese names are like the equivalent of an American character being named Jack or John. Fact is that FT even has quite a large variety of names. Hiro so far has used Japanese, Dutch, German, English, American, Spanish etc. names.

There are no names being ripped off in FT, that's just you thinking because a name that appears there also appears somewhere else, it must be a rip off.

Ninja Cats?

Where are there ninja cats? The Exceed? Sorry, but other than that both have the ability to speak -and Naruto isn't the first series with talking animals and cats- there is nothing really that makes them the same. Not to mention I seriously wonder if Naruto was even the first one of the two to have a talking cat in the series as Happy was introduced in chapter one, though I'm not really going to bother to check that. The two concepts are very different.

Tailed beasts and dragons?

Are you now serious? Have you any idea how many series there are with monsters like that? And their concepts are completley different. Dragons are an actual species in FT, while the Tailed Beasts have a set number, were created and play an important role in the entire concept of Jinchuriki's and the like. They are not the same. It's impossible to even consider that as a rip off.

Magic and jutsu?

Ki, reatsu, chakra, magic...this is one of the most recurrent concepts in manga series. This is something so universal it's impossible to steal it unless it would be word for word. The concept of 'jutsu' isn't even something Kishi created, it already existed in real life and nearly every manga that is of the fantasy/supernatural genre has people running around that spam elements, control shadows and whatnot which originate from a 'source'.

Guilds and villages?

If anything they are the complete opposite. Ninja villages are hidden, are practically a military and do even assassination jobs. Guilds are right in the middle of the cities, are in the hands of individual persons, they can't fight among each other, belong under the same organization, can not take things like assassination jobs etc.


What you did was intentionally trying to see things of FT being ripped off from other series, while the reality is that none of the things you listed got stolen. FT and OP have the same vibe, but that's very superficial and comes from the whole 'nakama' theme, which comes from Goku of Dragonball. There isn't any significant thing in FT that could be considered being ripped off from OP as it's too common. Same thing with people who claim that OP has been ripping off from FT.

Well said as always

*Saw the thread title*Scrolled down a bit*Seen Berimbolo No Jutsu's post*Scrolled down to Solo his post*Seen Caliburn-sama already solo'ed his post*Leaves thread*

For me FT is my Number one manga/Anime out there,Honourable mention FT is my first Manga not to mention DB
 

Forbidden Tale

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,423
Reaction score
239
Everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion, but for some reason it happens a lot with FT, more so than with other series, that people are seeing what they want to see just so that they could say it's ripped off, while it isn't or in the least it's something so universal that saying it's ripped off can only be seen as a sign of ill will.

Names?

I'm not going to start searching for all the names and compare them, but the only one that comes to mind are Natsu Tanimoto and Natsu Dragneel and Natsu isn't really a unique name. Sorry, but that is not even remotely a rip off. Have you any idea how many Yamato's, Sengoku's, Sakura's and Minato's are out there? Many of these Japanese names are like the equivalent of an American character being named Jack or John. Fact is that FT even has quite a large variety of names. Hiro so far has used Japanese, Dutch, German, English, American, Spanish etc. names.

There are no names being ripped off in FT, that's just you thinking because a name that appears there also appears somewhere else, it must be a rip off.

Ninja Cats?

Where are there ninja cats? The Exceed? Sorry, but other than that both have the ability to speak -and Naruto isn't the first series with talking animals and cats- there is nothing really that makes them the same. Not to mention I seriously wonder if Naruto was even the first one of the two to have a talking cat in the series as Happy was introduced in chapter one, though I'm not really going to bother to check that. The two concepts are very different.

Tailed beasts and dragons?

Are you now serious? Have you any idea how many series there are with monsters like that? And their concepts are completley different. Dragons are an actual species in FT, while the Tailed Beasts have a set number, were created and play an important role in the entire concept of Jinchuriki's and the like. They are not the same. It's impossible to even consider that as a rip off.

Magic and jutsu?

Ki, reatsu, chakra, magic...this is one of the most recurrent concepts in manga series. This is something so universal it's impossible to steal it unless it would be word for word. The concept of 'jutsu' isn't even something Kishi created, it already existed in real life and nearly every manga that is of the fantasy/supernatural genre has people running around that spam elements, control shadows and whatnot which originate from a 'source'.

Guilds and villages?

If anything they are the complete opposite. Ninja villages are hidden, are practically a military and do even assassination jobs. Guilds are right in the middle of the cities, are in the hands of individual persons, they can't fight among each other, belong under the same organization, can not take things like assassination jobs etc.


What you did was intentionally trying to see things of FT being ripped off from other series, while the reality is that none of the things you listed got stolen. FT and OP have the same vibe, but that's very superficial and comes from the whole 'nakama' theme, which comes from Goku of Dragonball. There isn't any significant thing in FT that could be considered being ripped off from OP as it's too common. Same thing with people who claim that OP has been ripping off from FT.

Well explained, people need to stop with that copy things.
 

Pumpkin Ninja

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
15,554
Reaction score
1,857
As Caliburn said they're not even similar in anyway. You aren't watching it, you're looking for similarities, I bet if you do that for almost every new anime that releases you'll feel the way you felt about Fairy Tail.
 
Joined
Apr 12, 2014
Messages
188
Reaction score
16
Everyone is entitled to his/her own opinion, but for some reason it happens a lot with FT, more so than with other series, that people are seeing what they want to see just so that they could say it's ripped off, while it isn't or in the least it's something so universal that saying it's ripped off can only be seen as a sign of ill will.

Names?

I'm not going to start searching for all the names and compare them, but the only one that comes to mind are Natsu Tanimoto and Natsu Dragneel and Natsu isn't really a unique name. Sorry, but that is not even remotely a rip off. Have you any idea how many Yamato's, Sengoku's, Sakura's and Minato's are out there? Many of these Japanese names are like the equivalent of an American character being named Jack or John. Fact is that FT even has quite a large variety of names. Hiro so far has used Japanese, Dutch, German, English, American, Spanish etc. names.

There are no names being ripped off in FT, that's just you thinking because a name that appears there also appears somewhere else, it must be a rip off.

Ninja Cats?

Where are there ninja cats? The Exceed? Sorry, but other than that both have the ability to speak -and Naruto isn't the first series with talking animals and cats- there is nothing really that makes them the same. Not to mention I seriously wonder if Naruto was even the first one of the two to have a talking cat in the series as Happy was introduced in chapter one, though I'm not really going to bother to check that. The two concepts are very different.

Tailed beasts and dragons?

Are you now serious? Have you any idea how many series there are with monsters like that? And their concepts are completley different. Dragons are an actual species in FT, while the Tailed Beasts have a set number, were created and play an important role in the entire concept of Jinchuriki's and the like. They are not the same. It's impossible to even consider that as a rip off.

Magic and jutsu?

Ki, reatsu, chakra, magic...this is one of the most recurrent concepts in manga series. This is something so universal it's impossible to steal it unless it would be word for word. The concept of 'jutsu' isn't even something Kishi created, it already existed in real life and nearly every manga that is of the fantasy/supernatural genre has people running around that spam elements, control shadows and whatnot which originate from a 'source'.

Guilds and villages?

If anything they are the complete opposite. Ninja villages are hidden, are practically a military and do even assassination jobs. Guilds are right in the middle of the cities, are in the hands of individual persons, they can't fight among each other, belong under the same organization, can not take things like assassination jobs etc.


What you did was intentionally trying to see things of FT being ripped off from other series, while the reality is that none of the things you listed got stolen. FT and OP have the same vibe, but that's very superficial and comes from the whole 'nakama' theme, which comes from Goku of Dragonball. There isn't any significant thing in FT that could be considered being ripped off from OP as it's too common. Same thing with people who claim that OP has been ripping off from FT.
PLUS; Mashima is amazing as a mangaka, i mean he releases a bunch of chapters, side stories and even color pages, thats the best thing about fairy tail in my opinion
 

Dãrth1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
7,548
Reaction score
255
PLUS; Mashima is amazing as a mangaka, i mean he releases a bunch of chapters, side stories and even color pages, thats the best thing about fairy tail in my opinion

I agree with this, and he is releasing really a lot of stuff, like bigger chapters and colored pages, he is doing really more than someone like the one that made Nardo
 
Top