When did Madara became 'haunted' by Indra??

[NarutoWA]

Is it that reincarnation as stated in the Manga is right from birth? I don't think so.

At an early age Madara fought for his brother, and his clan too. That's why he was made leader of Uchihas.He shared his dreams with Hashirama of all people living peacefully together atleast till the age of having Sake. He also settled with Senjus to create a village. These are not the works of Indra's reincarnation. But, more or less Ashura's.

Now when his brother was killed, what happened to him that he changed his views towards life?
Its not that his brother's death changed him because, as itachi said to Sasuke that Madara got the eyes of his younger brother to get the EMS. So, the change had to come before his brother's death.

What in the world happened to Madara that he changed his views?

 

[-immortal-]

when he heard about Tobirama. that he doesnt want someone like madara to become hokage

 

[Xāvî1]

when he reached puberty --- just joking

from the very beginning i guess

 

[Curteth]

Good question.... I wonder if we'll find these answers...

 

[NarutoWA]

didn't u read with those Facking eyeballs u got? when he heard about Tobirama. that he doesnt want someone like madara to become hokage

No, I didn't. (with the Facking Eyeballs that I have got)

And why would he take eyes of his own brother just because he heard Tobirama's views. He wasn't insane I think.

 

[-immortal-]

No, I didn't. (with the Facking Eyeballs that I have got)

And why would he take eyes of his own brother just because he heard Tobirama's views. He wasn't insane I think.

sorry for my behaviouur U_U.

OT: that time he saw the light and what his daddy wanted

 

[NukaCola]

From birth.
seriously people do a research on reincarnation

 

[Simbv]

Since the beginning, he's is the Reincarnation of Indra, so that means Indra was already within him from birth. He wasn't possessed by him like some kinda ghost.

 

[Yuse]

probly since birth since indra was reincarnated into his soul

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

You dont understand the meaning of Reincarnation, he is born within Madara, Indra's ghost is inside madara from the beginning.
Madara=Indra, only inside another (Madaras) body

 

[NukaCola]

Madara=Indra, only inside another (Madaras) body

Not really, souls don't have an identity

 

[NarutoWA]

Since the beginning, he's is the Reincarnation of Indra, so that means Indra was already within him from birth. He wasn't possessed by him like some kinda ghost.

If he was Indra's reincarnation from birth? Why his deeds didn't match Indra's when he was a child. If he was Indra himself, Why he changed a little, just at beginning of his life and got back to his own theories and views once he matured? And that too all of a sudden?

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

Not really, souls don't have an identity

If you know something about Reincarnation then you know what i meant

 

[Xlad]

Madara being his reincarnation does not make him Indra. Same for Hashirama, he was born with power that made him superior during childhood, even though he's Ashura's (Good-for-nothing) reincarnation.

 

[NukaCola]

Madara=Indra, only inside another (Madaras) body

If you were trying to say that Indra and Madara share a soul then i agree.

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

If he was Indra's reincarnation from birth? Why his deeds didn't match Indra's when he was a child. If he was Indra himself, Why he changed a little, just at beginning of his life and got back to his own theories and views once he matured? And that too all of a sudden?

If you are Reincarnated after you die inside another body then that doesnt mean you lead the exact same life like your past life

 

[Tobi98]

Just because they have the same chakra doesn't mean they've the same personalitys and ideals

 

[Simbv]

If he was Indra's reincarnation from birth? Why his deeds didn't match Indra's when he was a child. If he was Indra himself, Why he changed a little, just at beginning of his life and got back to his own theories and views once he matured? And that too all of a sudden?

You forget that the brothers were really close with each other until their dad chose Ashura over Indra. I could also add that Sasuke isn't following in Indras footsteps(yet)even though he is the second reincarnation of him.

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

If you were trying to say that Indra and Madara share a soul then i agree.

No that was not what i was trying to say

 

[NarutoWA]

If you are Reincarnated after you die inside another body then that doesnt mean you lead the exact same life like your past life

Just because they have the same chakra doesn't mean they've the same personalitys and ideals

What are you saying? The whole theory of reincarnation Hagoromo stated was for one brother to prove his ideals better against the other.