why do people take away minato's feat as a jin?

[AlphaScythian]

What feats he got as a jin? Those power ups were more of a fan service as all he did was failed U_U

 

[ShiroT]

What feats he got as a jin? Those power ups were more of a fan service as all he did was failed U_U

a huge power boast and immunity to gen. thats all he needed. not to mention cloak gives extra defense

 

[Gold Lightning]

a huge power boast and immunity to gen. thats all he needed. not to mention cloak gives extra defense

And tailed beast bomb and chakra arms

 

[AlphaScythian]

a huge power boast and immunity to gen. thats all he needed. not to mention cloak gives extra defense

And tailed beast bomb and chakra arms

Because this power up he achieved in afterlife, which is unique plot BS.
Feat is actual accomplishment, he still hasnt accomplished anything with this power, but dont worry in VS threads people do include his new power.

 

[Ovan]

It's not a feat he had living.

 

[ShiroT]

It's not a feat he had living.

same for itachi yet people are fine with using healthy itachi

 

[RikudoKami]

just wanted to ask, do you agree with quoted or think im wrong?

You mentioned Hashirama and Madara didn't have the same volume of chakra as the kyuubi I was showing you Hahirama does. I agree though.

 

[ShiroT]

You mentioned Hashirama and Madara didn't have the same volume of chakra as the kyuubi I was showing you Hahirama does. I agree though.

that was someone else lol but thx nice to know what i said made sense

 

[lilenesaron]

No one can take away Minato feat as a jinn. Cause he has none while alive. That's a fact. It's obvious
He was only alive for a few moments after receiving kurama. So technically he died as a jinn . But. He didn't live as a. Jinn

how is it possible to die as something you didnt live as? you mean to tell me the transformation occurred during death?

 

[lilenesaron]

You mentioned Hashirama and Madara didn't have the same volume of chakra as the kyuubi I was showing you Hahirama does. I agree though.

nope. hashirama has the same volume of chakra as nine tails? really c'mon dude because he can fight it doesn't make them both level on chakra. he thought that was naruto's chakra then he said this is nine tails. no shinobi has that much chakra. it's self regenerating. until hashirama can regen his chakra he doesn't

 

[blackstar9]

same for itachi yet people are fine with using healthy itachi

Minato and itachi is not the same . Healthy or sick he used the same jutsu. Minato has no jinnchuriki feats until edo form . Why are you trying to make that comparison ?

 

[Logical Chaos]

An alive Jin Minato?
Isn't that like saying an alive Madara (b4 resurrected) has the rinnigan becuz he unlocked it at an old age just befor he died

 

[ShiroT]

Minato and itachi is not the same . Healthy or sick he used the same jutsu. Minato has no jinnchuriki feats until edo form . Why are you trying to make that comparison ?

i already explained it. only sick itachi was shown to be the strongest itachi. anbu itachi has never shown any jutsus. anytime you say healthy itachi you are referring to edo itachi or giving anbu itachi feats he has never shown

 

[apsri]

Because he didn't have it while alive. He became a jinchuuriki when he died. And his death was inevitable. All of his feats as a jinchuuriki have been as an Edo. That doesn't count.

It's like me saying Itachi > Minato because as an Edo he can spam Susano'o without passing out from chakra exhaustion or going blind.

That said, Sage Mode should be included as part of his repertoire, since he obviously must have had that while he was alive as well, despite the fact that he doesn't have much experience with it. That's because it's an ability that he obviously had while alive, despite the fact that we didn't see him using it while alive.