why do people take away minato's feat as a jin?

[The Necromancer]

all perfect jins chakra control was not affected, neither was naruto's before being a perfect jin. naruto had perfect control over his chakra until orochimaru placed the seal on him.

and the other point is that minato and kurama didnt seem to be enemy's they seem neutral like kurama had nothing against him. while i cant tell you for certian that he wasnt taking minato's chakra im suggesting that he wasn as hateful as yin kurama.

what do you mean canonically it has been shown not to? he never used its power while he was alive. the gold and silver brothers were just fine going 6 tails. and this all ties into yang kurama maybe being nicer then yang kurama

1. Minato would not be a perfect jin. He would have KCM at most in which the Kyuubi would take his chakra as well.
2. There's nothing to suggest he wouldn't.
3. He couldn't even handle it for 5 seconds after sealing it within himself. His body is not suitable.

You must be registered for see images

 

[ShiroT]

1. Minato would not be a perfect jin. He would have KCM at most in which the Kyuubi would take his chakra as well.
2. There's nothing to suggest he wouldn't.
3. He couldn't even handle it for 5 seconds after sealing it within himself. His body is not suitable.

You must be registered for see images

1. all people with a biju in them have never shown problems controlling there chakra is what i meant to say.
2. just a suggestion. yang kurama did seem nicer then yin kurama.
3. you also have to take into account that he was dieing. who knows if baby naruto felt the same way? its not like he could tell us. minato was still able to place his chakra in naruto as he was dieing.

also another point is that kurama has given naruto chakra before without taking it so it wouldnt be that hard to believe that a nicer kurama would do the same

 

[lilenesaron]

Ok. And how would his chakra control be affected?
How much time until his chakra reserves are depleted in a fight while Kurama is leaching off of them?
What makes you think his mortal body can handle the kyuubi, when canonically it has been shown not to?

c'mon dude if naruto (one of the poorest chakra handlers in the series) could handle nine tails chakra i think minato should be able to without sweat. he's a kage. chakra control should be the least of his detriments. as for how long can he maintain. for as long as he needs to. kyuubi can give him chakra without taking his. you mean to tell me that before naruto got hagoromo's power he's been fighting while exchanging chakra with kyuubi?, not even hashirama's or madara's chakra pool is that much

 

[ShiroT]

c'mon dude if naruto (one of the poorest chakra handlers in the series) could handle nine tails chakra i think minato should be able to without sweat. he's a kage. chakra control should be the least of his detriments. as for how long can he maintain. for as long as he needs to. kyuubi can give him chakra without taking his. you mean to tell me that before naruto got hagoromo's power he's been fighting while exchanging chakra with kyuubi?, not even hashirama's or madara's chakra pool is that much

yea what this guy said. kurama has given naruto chakra before without taking some

 

[The Necromancer]

1. all people with a biju in them have never shown problems controlling there chakra is what i meant to say.
2. just a suggestion. yang kurama did seem nicer then yin kurama.
3. you also have to take into account that he was dieing. who knows if baby naruto felt the same way? its not like he could tell us.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Nattana]

And to think I thought Minato wank couldn't get any more ridiculous.

 

[lilenesaron]

Is anyone else wondering why Minato's Kurama is so well behaved and not all angry and angsty?

he's got the yang side. naruto got the dark side

 

[Sir Cool Blizzard]

Well......may be they feel uneasy about their favs being soloed!! XD
Although I don't understand the double standards of these people!!

 

[ShiroT]

And to think I thought Minato wank couldn't get any more ridiculous.

its not wank i just asking a question

 

[Nattana]

its not wank i just asking a question

Then the answer is simple.
Minato died seconds after he sealed the Kyuubi. He wasn't able to fight and died. How can you consider it an 'alive feat'?

 

[Draphsin]

Nobody takes away his edo feats.

There's a difference between nerfing a character & distinguishing between two different versions of that character.

Alive minato isn't a jin, edo minato is.

 

[Filo]

"Alive Minato" and "Jinchuriki" do not belong in the same sentence.

Alive Minato as a Jinchuriki has seconds to live and can't feel his body.

that was funny Minato was like "This chakra is so heavy my body has gone numb"

 

[ShiroT]

You must be registered for see images

naruto had alot of stamina and he turned out pretty well before becoming a perfect jin.

its been stated that if you learn sagemode then you have a large chakra supply meaning minato has one. if kid naruto didnt really have a problem controlling his chakra after learning good chakra control, i dont see why minato who has alot of chakra(and being a kage he would already have good chakra control) would be effected to much by having a bijuu

 

[ShiroT]

Nobody takes away his edo feats.

There's a difference between nerfing a character & distinguishing between two different versions of that character.

Alive minato isn't a jin, edo minato is.

that was funny Minato was like "This chakra is so heavy my body has gone numb"

and alive nagato is crippled and alive itachi has aids. just like you can consider two versions of itachi(one sick and one healthy) you could consider two minato's one without kurama and one who is a perfect jin.

also you could take into account that he was almost dead, he wouldnt have the strength to do anything after sealing in kurama as he was dieing(and im pretty sure kurama put a hole in his stomach to)

 

[xxxLegacy]

Because they know Minato solos Itachi low difficulty. Thats why.

Edit-


And he obviously did fight Kurama while sealed in the death gods stomach. The same way Naruto did, which is how he can use the KCM.....

Without Kushinas Help man dat Minato ; ) and gr is a Jin only haters would deny it

 

[Draphsin]

and alive nagato is crippled and alive itachi has aids. just like you can consider two versions of itachi(one sick and one healthy) you could consider two minato's one without kurama and one who is a perfect jin.

First of all alive nagato isn't crippled due to asura path, bad example.

Second of all itachi was healthy in part 1, & he became sick in part 2. Healthy & sick itachi are two different versions.

Alive minato only has one version, & that's the version before he sealed kurama inside of himself. Once he used RDS the alive version of minato died, because by default RDS is a suicide jutsu.

It doesn't matter what he used the RDS for, even if he used it to become the next sage of six paths he still doesn't have access to any abilities because he's dead.

also you could take into account that he was almost dead, he wouldnt have the strength to do anything after sealing in kurama as he was dieing(and im pretty sure kurama put a hole in his stomach to)

As I said nothing matters once he uses RDS, a suicide jutsu means that he is going to die, so he automatically loses access to the powers of a jin.

 

[xxxLegacy]

Because he wasn't a Jin when he was alive, that's like, if there existed a Edo Tensei Guy, you counting his almost invincible feats with alive Guy

He was a Jin befor he died.

 

[Draphsin]

He was a Jin befor he died.

No he wasn't, he killed himself to become the jin because RDS is a suicide jutsu.

 

[lilenesaron]

people be like minato this minato that. i mean this guy deflected a full kurama TBB. that's a crazy feat on its own. within seconds owned obito, teleported a tailed beast as heavy and big as kurama , and used a death reaper seal. very few characters can pull that off. he sealed half in him self and half in kurama. 3rd hokage couldn't even manage to seal orochimaru yet minato sealed (arguably the most powerful) tailed beast completely. and y'all should know that most people usually have it seal in them by somebody else. he sealed it in himself by himself. if an ordinary guy without any rare bloodline could put all those off. then i see why people will be afraid of talking of him as a perfect jin. like someone said 'FTG+ TBB' not good news for his opponent

 

[Valhorus]

No he wasn't, he killed himself to become the jin because RDS is a suicide jutsu.

He was for a few minutes . He showed the feats in Edo form . So lets take all Edo feats from all other characters out too .