[Discussion] True Story behind Uchiha Clan Massacre

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

Sometime before Konoha's founding , Some members of uchiha clan began to willingly surrender , realising that they were outclassed by the Senju. The senju later grew tired of endless fighting and approached the Uchiha clan with a peace treaty once again. Though rejected time and time before as madara feared an alliance would destroy uchiha clan , he willingly accepted and joined hands with hashirama.


After konoha's formation, Uchiha clan still wants to live outside the village but they wanted to protect leaf at that time. But after some time uchiha clan members were feeling that senju suppressed uchiha clan.

After 2nd's death , hiruzen announced to be a new hokage..
Everyone knows that hiruzen is not from a Senju clan.That means there is a fair equal chance of hokage selection for any shinobi but uchiha clan started to hate village

You must be registered for see images

IMO Uchiha on their own wishes lived outside the village still with the name of uchiha clan which showed that they didn't accept konoha by their hearts and that's the reason their were no hokage selected from uchiha clan and they perceived it as being corned by the senju's but in reality it wasn't true.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

In reality,Madara of the uchiha clan named the village as a Hidden leaf which showed that they were considered equal as to senju's but they didn't accept it.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

When Uchiha clan began planning to overthrow konoha, Itachi, as an Anbu, was tasked with spying on village. Knowing that Coup d'etat would only escalate to the beginning of ninja world war that's why itachi informed third hokage and elders regarding coup d'etat.


Shisui given with the task of spying itachi but he also hates the way of uchiha clan was doing
and he tried to stop coup de'tat by his own but danzo didn't like this and captured shishui's sharingan

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

In short, Shisui entrusted all his hopes to itachi and asked him to protect both village and honour of uchiha clan

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Itachi hates the way uchiha proud on their clan and at one time when ***aku uchiha said about uchiha clan proud history itachi angered and threw a kunai on uchiha clan symbol and at that time ***aku felt that itachi changed a lot .

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Itachi on the orders of danzo slaughtered his own whole clan ...

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

IMO that shouldn't be happened because dialogue with uchiha clan might clear the situation..

But in the given scenario Itachi did his best to protect village and uchiha clan's name both just because only elders of the village knew about true reason behind massacre but whole village sympathies were with uchiha clan even after their massacre and they felt itachi as a traitor.. uchiha clan's true ambitions conceal from villagers and itachi bear the all hatred on himself and protected the name of uchiha's

The way uchiha clan ended Its really what they deserved to be killed like this


This all Cycle of hatred Actually started from hagoromo's decision..


There is a coincidence between hagoromo meeting with sasuke,naruto & ashura,indra


In past, hagoromo met with their children indra and ashura ..and asked from them that how can they achieve peace ?

Indra said that Everything can be achieved by power
Ashura replied that he will achieve peace by love and cooperation

Hagoromo saw new possibilities in how ashura lived his life and he chose ashura as his successor and thought that indra will cooperate too but that wouldn't be the case and unstoppable war started from it.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

This time hagoromo again asked the same question from both Naruto and sasuke

But this time Sasuke agreed with Naruto and they are on same point that's why Hagoromo given his power to both sasuke and naruto..

You must be registered for see images

Now onwards The cycle of hatred will be ended ..Basically that's the Cycle of jealousy started from uchiha's

Now, new Uchiha clan will be born by the efforts of naruto and sasuke

 

[Heisenberg284]

Way too many words for me to read, but I'll give you a rep because it's a long post

 

[Dantee]

Good read and all but I don't remember where it said the Uchiha wanted to remain outside the village. I remember Tobirama placing them in the outskirts because he was a douche. I think Hashirama has some fault to this as well when he decided to kill Madara in the name of protecting the village. Hiruzen let Danzo do w/e he wants so he failed. they all played some part in this.

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

Way too many words for me to read, but I'll give you a rep because it's a long post

Read it ,its really interesting =D and thanks for the rep

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

Good read and all but I don't remember where it said the Uchiha wanted to remain outside the village. I remember Tobirama placing them in the outskirts because he was a douche. I think Hashirama has some fault to this as well when he decided to kill Madara in the name of protecting the village. Hiruzen let Danzo do w/e he wants so he failed. they all played some part in this.

Its in latest episode and IF my memory serves me right this also mentioned in danzo vs sasuke fight

 

[Nocturnal]

Good read and all but I don't remember where it said the Uchiha wanted to remain outside the village. I remember Tobirama placing them in the outskirts because he was a douche. I think Hashirama has some fault to this as well when he decided to kill Madara in the name of protecting the village. Hiruzen let Danzo do w/e he wants so he failed. they all played some part in this.

I was thinking the same.

 

[Heisenberg284]

Read it ,its really interesting =D and thanks for the rep

I'm at school so my brains dead right now, I will when I get out though!

 

[BLAZE]

Nice theory brother but wasn't it tobirama's police force thing keeping them on village corners and fugaku also wanted good relations with konaha but kyuubi attack ,hypocrite elders and uchiha pride didn't mix well

 

[Aquaglow]

Its in latest episode and IF my memory serves me right this also mentioned in danzo vs sasuke fight

I was thinking the same! Danzo deserved to die. I hate him! Seriously he was the main culprit! I actually watched the sasuke vs Danzo episode again! hehehe

 

[Hàdes1]

good theory i like it

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

I'm at school so my brains dead right now, I will when I get out though!

Lol school sucks =D

Nice theory brother but wasn't it tobirama's police force thing keeping them on village corners and fugaku also wanted good relations with konaha but kyuubi attack ,hypocrite elders and uchiha pride didn't mix well

thanks bro and you are damn right :heh:

I was thinking the same! Danzo deserved to die. I hate him! Seriously he was the main culprit! I actually watched the sasuke vs Danzo episode again! hehehe

yeah Danzou was a evil person.

good theory i like it

thanks dude

 

[uzmakinaruto]

nice thread dude

I really like it

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

nice thread dude

I really like it

thanks dude

 

[Memento Mori]

Very good theory,I think you had hard time of posting this thread
I do think that if danzo didn't stole shisui's eye,he could have somehow succeded in casting KA on Fugaku and may maintained order among Uchiha clan,Who knows what may happen!!!!

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

Very good theory,I think you had hard time of posting this thread
I do think that if danzo didn't stole shisui's eye,he could have somehow succeded in casting KA on Fugaku and may maintained order among Uchiha clan,Who knows what may happen!!!!

Thanks dude for the appreciation.
I think that Shisui might be able to solve the conflict.

 

[Dantee]

Its in latest episode and IF my memory serves me right this also mentioned in danzo vs sasuke fight

Nah im pretty sure it never happened.

 

[EVlL]

you sure sasuke agreed the same thing as naruto does? sasuke's answer isnt showed in the manga. it only shows: he says yes after being asked 'is that your answer' so your theory isnt solid. and i assume his answer isnt far from becoming hokage, protecting konoha, or things like that

 

[Memento Mori]

Thanks dude for the appreciation.
I think that Shisui might be able to solve the conflict.

Yeah,Afterall he has KA

 

[Memento Mori]

you sure sasuke agreed the same thing as naruto does? sasuke's answer isnt showed in the manga. it only shows: he says yes after being asked 'is that your answer' so your theory isnt solid. and i assume his answer isnt far from becoming hokage, protecting konoha, or things like that

He would have said this

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[NaruSasuRival]

This time hagoromo again asked the same question from both Naruto and sasuke

But this time Sasuke agreed with Naruto and they are on same point that's why Hagoromo given his power to both sasuke and naruto.[/B].

You must be registered for see images

Now onwards The cycle of hatred will be ended ..Basically that's the Cycle of jealousy started from uchiha's

Now, new Uchiha clan will be born by the efforts of naruto and sasuke

I think your conclusion ruined your analysis. While we know what Naruto said, we don't know what Sasuke said. Thus saying that Sasuke said the same thing as Naruto is a fallacy.

In fact, if we analyze what hagoromo said, it actually suggest that Sasuke said the same thing as Indra. The reason is that Hagormo cleary said, the last time, I entrusted everything to Ashura, and this caused a war. This time, I will also entrust some of my power to Sasuke.

In my opinion, if Sasuke said the same thing as Naruto, Hagoromo wouldn't need to say what he said. Rather, I am almost 100% sure that Sasuke said the same thing as Indra, and this would make hagoromo's statement legit - that is giving part of his power to Indra despite his way of piece that he does not like. Moreover, if you read what hagoromo said prior to his statement, he even stated that it was selfish of him to force his view on his children. This is why this time, he left the responsibility to make piece in their hands. This also justify nicely the theme of naruto series - that is whatever one become depends on their own choices and actions. You can have power and fail while someone less powerful than you succeeds by making friends.

Also, go back and read Sasuke's statement when he claimed the seat of Hokage. he said that he will show the village how to be hokage, when at the same time no one wants him to be Hokage. This means that he will have to force his view on the village. Whether you believe or not, there will be a clash.