[Discussion] why Sasuke cannot be the reincarnation of Indra

[Samoan Ninja of the Cloud]

Sasuke cannot be the reincarnation of Indra. Madara is the only reincarnation of Indra. mainly because of their characteristics. lets look at Sasuke. Sasuke left the village to be trained by someone else to get stronger. he wouldn't have had to do that if he was a true genius, but no, the true Genius was Itachi. Indra was a True Genius by birth. the closest reincarnation candidate for Indra after Madara Uchiha would have to be Itachi. another point that goes against Sasuke being the Reincarnation of Indra is mainly because when sasuke left the village, he joined a team, and then when he killed orochimaru, he made a team. but with Indra, that dude flew solo.....every single time. like in the situation now. Everyone is against Madara. Sasuke cannot go up against everyone like Madara or Indra, so it stands to reason that Sasuke cannot be the reincarnation because sasuke, at birth was a normal uchiha, nothing new.

in conclusion, the above statements are my own opinion but i believe this to be the case. that sasuke is not, and cannot be the reincarnation of Indra. but if kishi decides to pull a fast one on and openly say inn the manga that Sasuke is the Reincarnation of Indra, i will have to accept that.

 

[xXVergiliusXx]

He is, period

 

[TheAncientJinchuuriki]

As much as I hate it, he is the reincarnation of Indra

 

[UCE]

madara died thats the thing and sasuke has his own ideals of peace so

 

[Erebus]

????????????

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And my friend Sasuke is a genius

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[Mamoru]

If it isn't Sasuke, then Ashura is Hashirama's reincarnation. Sasuke and Naruto are parallels to Hashirama and Madara, which both both contain heavy similarities and share the same ideals. It's only proper for Sasuke to be Indra's reincarnation.

 

[Samoan Ninja of the Cloud]

Cmon, Sasuke is not the same kind of "Genius" as were the others. he was only showing the superiority of the Uchihas innate abilities for perception and skill. at the most least Sasuke was the below average Uchiha. Sasuke, was just following his brothers footsteps (a.k.a. The True Genius) and gained the powers that madaraa has, but Sasuke is not strong enough to take on everyone in the shinobi world as Both Indra has, and as Madara is doing now. Sasuke is part of the power of love. and will continue to do so. he can't really do anything by himself.

If it isn't Sasuke, then Ashura is Hashirama's reincarnation. Sasuke and Naruto are parallels to Hashirama and Madara, which both both contain heavy similarities and share the same ideals. It's only proper for Sasuke to be Indra's reincarnation.

i know its proper, well, in this case, plot-no-jutsu, but Sasuke isn't carrying all the qualifications to be the true successor of Indras will. he is on the opposite side. what is he gonna do after the war, create another war between himself and the shinobi world his brother died to protect? not likely. the most he is gonna do is fight naruto and in that respect to sasuke

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

????????????

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And my friend Sasuke is a genius

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

not a true genius.... he only gained that title when compared to kids who were not Uchiha. if he was compared to the other Uchiha kids, he would most likely be the Naruto of the Uchiha clan....

and on a second note, the "true Genius" title stayed with Itachi. remember, according to the nature of the Genius title....there is only one, every ten years (or something like that)

and the second picture, didn't oro say the same thing about itachi?

 

[UCE]

Cmon, Sasuke is not the same kind of "Genius" as were the others. he was only showing the superiority of the Uchihas innate abilities for perception and skill. at the most least Sasuke was the below average Uchiha. Sasuke, was just following his brothers footsteps (a.k.a. The True Genius) and gained the powers that madaraa has, but Sasuke is not strong enough to take on everyone in the shinobi world as Both Indra has, and as Madara is doing now. Sasuke is part of the power of love. and will continue to do so. he can't really do anything by himself.

dude to make it easy on you indra had battle sense right so take deidara vs sasuke and danzou vs sasuke for example, genius when it comes to battle

 

[Joethemh]

Because mastering the Fire Style: Fireball Jutsu at age 7 is a normal occurrence. Even Kakashi was surprised he could mold nature chakra at his age. Sasuke IS a genius. If you want real proof, Lee said it himself a bunch of times. And if anyone in the NV is honest, it's Lee.

 

[nandachikara]

sasuke is still going to turn evil when the title of hokage is given to naruto...just like madara and hashi...the path of hatred is indra's,sasuke inherits that hatred because he is more or less the reincarnation of indra.

 

[adeshina365]

Sasuke is the reincarnation of Indra, get over it.

 

[Cerise]

We don't know who Indra's reincarnation is yet, that will probably be revealed in chapter 671.

We assume it's Sasuke due to many hints leading to a battle between him and Naruto. However, Hashirama did say Sasuke was like Izuna and not Madara, so it's hard to say where Kishimoto is heading with this.

Logically Sasuke being Indra fits due to the connection between him and Naruto since part 1.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Well idiot #6045874384702984738477....

Let me tell you why Madara isn't the reincarnation of Indra...because he died and as soon as Sasuke was born it was most likely that same time Madara died.

Also, by Madara being dead for sooooo long is also why.
Also because after being edo tensei back to life and rinne tensei back he still isn't. Madara doesn't reference nothing but the Juubi.

Also I noticed that none of The Chosen One's can't kill each other.

 

[Aatrox]

I'll be back to post in this thread when Sasuke is told he is the reincarnation of Indra. Madara is no longer the incarnation of Indra, if he was at all, because he died. Just because he is revived doesn't mean he is the current incarnation, just a past one.

 

[21naruto21]

Well madara cant be the reincarnation of indra cause he was dead for a few decades so he may have been befor he died but cant now cause he lost his life force and it would transfer to a new birthed person ie another uchia and the only one left in the story is sasuke so by process of elimination and the way the stories going kish will probly make saskue the reincarnation or there wont be a reincarnation of the brother at all but doesnt sound likey since he made one brother reincarnate and as the brothers died fighting if you remember when naruto and sasku fought at the bridge naruto said next time we fight we will both die right there gives hints towards saskue being indra cause they have been destined to fight and try to beat the other one like brothers.

 

[blackstar9]

Cmon, Sasuke is not the same kind of "Genius" as were the others. he was only showing the superiority of the Uchihas innate abilities for perception and skill. at the most least Sasuke was the below average Uchiha. Sasuke, was just following his brothers footsteps (a.k.a. The True Genius) and gained the powers that madaraa has, but Sasuke is not strong enough to take on everyone in the shinobi world as Both Indra has, and as Madara is doing now. Sasuke is part of the power of love. and will continue to do so. he can't really do anything by himself.

What manga you reading ? Because sasuke was advanced in every way . Oro said he would surpass itachi. Nine tails said his chakra reminded him of madara. Sasuke mastered cursemark . I could go on and on.. But sasuke was clearly a genius in his own right. Oro also said his genius was mild compared to sasuke. He has been praised by minato, hashi

 

[Seventh Sama]

lawd sausage is most likely indra's reincarnation... but madara being indra's reincarnation would be more interesting....

 

[Samoan Ninja of the Cloud]

your forgetting one thing......There was one thing alive of Madara during his death. dont forget the Black Zetsu. the black zetsu was a manifestation of Madaras will. hence, Madara still lived (in a sense). Madaras plan was to be revived and his will made sure of that. hence madaraa still kicking around, the title of Genius was already given to Itachi and oro only called Sasuke a geniu at the time, but was nothing compared to Itachi who was the one that drew orochimaru into thinking of using an Uchiha for his revival plan.

 

[VolatileSoul]

I had my own reasons for believing it was unlikely, but this is just bullshit. Sasuke is a genius. The greatest proof of this is that Orochimaru believed that compared to Sasuke, him being called a genius was pitiful. Just look at the praise Hiruzen gave Orochimaru. He believed Oro was one of the greatest geniuses his eyes ever fell upon. There is also the fact that Naruto and Sasuke are parallels. He is going to be equivalent to Naruto until this manga ends. Not only that, Naruto isn't a carbon copy of Ashura either. That isn't how reincarnation works. It's not a copy paste. And Sasuke is not a genius? Are you on crack? Tobirama considers Sasuke to be just as prodigious as Madara. At age freaking 17. Naruto of the Uchiha clan? How do you expect people to take you seriously after that? The fact that you consider Itachi the true genius of the two when Sasuke has more potential and is stronger than Itachi was at the same age, and is currently just proves what utter bullshit this is.

 

[Uchiha Sutona]

Yes there are some characteristics that imply that Sasuke could not be the incarnation of Indra, But there is also one characteristic that implies that Madara is not as well... the simple fact that he has died. He WAS the reincarnation but since he died it moved on, and now it went to Sasuke, Sasuke is the new reincarnation. Also another simple fact that he is the reincarnation is because he is the last living uchiha, (besides Obito, but he's done for very soon, and Madara I don't count because he already died) Since he is the last, He is the only LIVING capable reincarnation of Indra.