Did the Shinju transform into the Ten-Tails before or after Hagoromo was born??

[Kirby1]

This has been on my mind for the longest time now, especially with this new chapter. I am curious is to when the Shinju transformed into the Juubi. Did the Shinju become the Juubi before or after Hagoromo Otsutsuki and his brother were born?

In all honesty, I find it hard to believe that the Shinju would remain in it's original form until after Kaguya gave birth to her children and then transform into the Juubi. It just doesn't make any sense. Hopefully Kishimoto will shead some light on this.

 

[Trolling King]

Listen that doesnt matter. Just grab that plot hole and shove it in the closet with the rest of them.

 

[Misconception]

Listen that doesnt matter. Just grab that plot hole and shove it in the closet with the rest of them.

This......

 

[Sentinel of Light Style]

it isn't entirely plot hole: if Kaguya would have died, the power would have been gone again; but now So6P and his brother come around and they are born with the power of chakra and will pass it on as well

 

[SIX PATHZ]

may be after lost the fruit tree getting weaker or smthing i guess.so get back those powers juubi was there. it make sense we saw it absorb chakra in the war when it reviled.

 

[Kirby1]

My theory: After Kaguya ate the fruit, the Shinju transformed into the Juubi and started rampaging across the world and a few years later, Kaguya gave birth to Hagoromo and his brother and sheltered them from the Juubi until the time was right for them to face it.

Then Hagoromo and his brother fought the Juubi when they were in their 20s and defeated it.

Either way, it is a huge plot hole that Kishimoto really needs to fill. Hopefully he will shead some light on this as I said before.

 

[Seventh Sama]

Possibly before, since the juubi is most likely the sages father...

 

[Joseph Gomes]

Dont worry bout the plot holes...

 

[Kirby1]

Dont worry bout the plot holes...

But this is one of the biggest plot holes yet? Especially given that it was discussed in the recent chapter.

It's not like the Shinju would do this: "Hey, you took my fruit *****! Oh well, I'll just stick around here for a few years and then go on a rampage after you have two children and a good life! Ta ta!"

I mean c'mon, the Shinju had to have transformed into the Juubi sometime before Kaguya gave birth to Hogoromo and his brother.

 

[Kirby1]

Hello everyone! I'm back! If there is anyone else who would like to discuss this topic, be my guest!

 

[assface3]

My theory: After Kaguya ate the fruit, the Shinju transformed into the Juubi and started rampaging across the world and a few years later, Kaguya gave birth to Hagoromo and his brother and sheltered them from the Juubi until the time was right for them to face it.

Then Hagoromo and his brother fought the Juubi when they were in their 20s and defeated it.

Either way, it is a huge plot hole that Kishimoto really needs to fill. Hopefully he will shead some light on this as I said before.

That's the most plausible theory.