Resealing Kurama's chakra saves a Jinchuuriki

[Lagadatte]

So after all the threads I read about how Kishimoto is shooting himself in the foot with this piece of information and negating his own logic, I decided to make a new one with my take on the situation.

Question: If resealing a Bijuu would save a dying ex-Jinchuuriki from certain death, why didn't Minato reseal Kurama into Kushina to save her and ensure at least one living parent for his non-Jinchuuriki son? Her death was pointless.

I read 654654 threads about this particular topic and opinions ranged from explaining the level of weakness of the ex-Jinchuuriki and how MUCH of an Uzumaki they were and similar answers that are overthinking one VERY SIMPLE truth.

Answer: Because THEY DIDN'T KNOW. How about that? Kurama had to tell Gaara that it could work, no one knew it, no one had attempted it before, how could they possibly know?! So chill out, guys, Kishimoto might make no sense whatsoever with MANY things in this manga, but I don't think this is one of them.

 

[SIR UZMAKIMADARA]

So after all the threads I read about how Kishimoto is shooting himself in the foot with this piece of information and negating his own logic, I decided to make a new one with my take on the situation.

Question: If resealing a Bijuu would save a dying ex-Jinchuuriki from certain death, why didn't Minato reseal Kurama into Kushina to save her and ensure at least one living parent for his non-Jinchuuriki son? Her death was pointless.

I read 654654 threads about this particular topic and opinions ranged from explaining the level of weakness of the ex-Jinchuuriki and how MUCH of an Uzumaki they were and similar answers that are overthinking one VERY SIMPLE truth.

Answer: Because THEY DIDN'T KNOW. How about that? Kurama had to tell Gaara that it could work, no one knew it, no one had attempted it before, how could they possibly know?! So chill out, guys, Kishimoto might make no sense whatsoever with MANY things in this manga, but I don't think this is one of them.

your answer is plausible

but IMO , Only Yin part kurama can save naruto because Yin released techniques, based on the spiritual energy that governs the imagination, can be used to create form out of nothingness.

Approximately whole medical ninjutsus are based on Yin Release E.g Kabuto's Yin Healing Wound Destruction and Tsunade's Yin Seal: Release.

Izanagi is also a Yin Release jutsu

 

[Flakez]

Or because if she and Minato didn't die the whole story would be different... I don't get people who diss Kishi for this.

 

[Amazeballs]

Plus there's the fact that Kurama would not have shared chakra with Kushina anyway at that point. In this case, Kurama not only can share his own chakra with Naruto, but can also convert "Bijuu Chakra" into "Naruto Chakra."

I still hope that they seal the Gedo Mazou's arm into Naruto.

 

[Anonn]

Or because if she and Minato didn't die the whole story would be different... I don't get people who diss Kishi for this.

your answer is plausible

but IMO , Only Yin part kurama can save naruto because Yin released techniques, based on the spiritual energy that governs the imagination, can be used to create form out of nothingness.

Approximately whole medical ninjutsus are based on Yin Release E.g Kabuto's Yin Healing Wound Destruction and Tsunade's Yin Seal: Release.

Izanagi is also a Yin Release jutsu

Again solo'd.

 

[Six Paths]

I agree with UZMAKIMADARA's Theory

 

[Byron123]

Nope that's BS, there is a very simple explanation about that. Kurama didn't want to get sealed in Kushina so it would try to oppose to the sealing and considering that she was this weak, even if she managed to reseal him inside of her, there is no guarantee that she would manage to control him at such a bad shape. However, in naruto's case, Kurama does want to be resealed inside of him and so even if he's weak now, he won't try to free himself and so Naruto won't have a problem controlling him and thus he will gain back his chakra.

 

[esenn1]

Kushina's death was not due to extraction of Kurama, it was because of Kurama's nail into her stomach from behind.

 

[RiaValkyre]

Kushina's death was not due to extraction of Kurama, it was because of Kurama's nail into her stomach from behind.

that was the shinigami.

 

[esenn1]

although i think naruto is the weakest jin ever. Kushina, after FULL KURAMA was extarcted from her, was still living and even used her chakra (the chain) to harness Kurama, but Naruto is dying with only ONE HALF of Kurama extracted from him

 

[nandachikara]

Nice thread dude

 

[esenn1]

that was the shinigami.

no, shinigami killed Minato. Kurama pierced both Minato and Kushina from behind when he tried to kill Naruto.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Six Paths of Logic]

So after all the threads I read about how Kishimoto is shooting himself in the foot with this piece of information and negating his own logic, I decided to make a new one with my take on the situation.

Question: If resealing a Bijuu would save a dying ex-Jinchuuriki from certain death, why didn't Minato reseal Kurama into Kushina to save her and ensure at least one living parent for his non-Jinchuuriki son? Her death was pointless.

I read 654654 threads about this particular topic and opinions ranged from explaining the level of weakness of the ex-Jinchuuriki and how MUCH of an Uzumaki they were and similar answers that are overthinking one VERY SIMPLE truth.

Answer: Because THEY DIDN'T KNOW. How about that? Kurama had to tell Gaara that it could work, no one knew it, no one had attempted it before, how could they possibly know?! So chill out, guys, Kishimoto might make no sense whatsoever with MANY things in this manga, but I don't think this is one of them.

Or because if she and Minato didn't die the whole story would be different... I don't get people who diss Kishi for this.

Plus there's the fact that Kurama would not have shared chakra with Kushina anyway at that point. In this case, Kurama not only can share his own chakra with Naruto, but can also convert "Bijuu Chakra" into "Naruto Chakra."

I still hope that they seal the Gedo Mazou's arm into Naruto.

/Thread

although i think naruto is the weakest jin ever. Kushina, after FULL KURAMA was extarcted from her, was still living and even used her chakra (the chain) to harness Kurama, but Naruto is dying with only ONE HALF of Kurama extracted from him

Lol, kushina gave birth, but Naruto master the nine-tails chakra (some and then full), was training, and fought power opponents in the war. So dont cry because naruto is drained out newb

Nice thread dude

Like your sig.

 

[Punk Hazard]

your answer is plausible

but IMO , Only Yin part kurama can save naruto because Yin released techniques, based on the spiritual energy that governs the imagination, can be used to create form out of nothingness.

Approximately whole medical ninjutsus are based on Yin Release E.g Kabuto's Yin Healing Wound Destruction and Tsunade's Yin Seal: Release.

Izanagi is also a Yin Release jutsu

It would make more sense to use Yang then, since that breathed life into form created with Yin.

 

[Flakez]

although i think naruto is the weakest jin ever. Kushina, after FULL KURAMA was extarcted from her, was still living and even used her chakra (the chain) to harness Kurama, but Naruto is dying with only ONE HALF of Kurama extracted from him

@bold, You on crack bro? Naruto is 2nd strongest jin after Madara and Obito. Both Naruto and Sasuke died for the sake of creating a desperate situation for the SA. Also how much time you live after an extraction does not determine how strong you are power-wise.

 

[Tawleyn]

It would make more sense to use Yang then, since that breathed life into form created with Yin.

Maybe, but I think the whole concept is that Yin creates something from nothing.

Yang breathes life into something, but I think chakra is different than "life". Yin would be perfect for restoring Naruto's lack of chakra.

However, we don't know the nature of Bijuu extraction. Does it yank the life force from the Jin's body? Or does it completely drain their chakra?

My guess is that the Jin's chakra is so interconnected with the Bijuu's (whether they're friendly or not) and yanking the Bijuu (a being made up of chakra) drags the host's chakra along with it.

 

[cptenn94]

They didnt know is one good explantation.

However I think that they did not have enough chakra to do it. Minato didnt have enough left to seal kurama in kushina, and kushina didnt have enough to reseal without dieing of chakra depletion.

Also they may not have known. From our understanding, jinchurikis have only been around for 100 years or so. Before then they were free reigning. And since all except uzumakis died after the bijuu was extracted, there has never been a chance to reseal a bijuu(or a reason)

 

[cptenn94]

although i think naruto is the weakest jin ever. Kushina, after FULL KURAMA was extarcted from her, was still living and even used her chakra (the chain) to harness Kurama, but Naruto is dying with only ONE HALF of Kurama extracted from him

Size of the bijuu doesnt matter for the extraction. Naruto has been fighting for hours on end. Naruto had a strong attachment to kurama (so it was a much bigger mental strain.) Naruto had his chakra integrated with kuramas when kurama was extracted. Narutos seal was at full strength when it was ripped out.(thus more strain)

There are many possible factors. Kushina also had a strong chakra that was well suited for kurama. The same hasnt been said about naruto.

And lastly there is 1 feat above all, that shows naruto is not a weak jin. The fact that he was a jin at the first day he was born. AS A BABY he was strong enough to maintain the seal. You cant be a weak jin and do that.