Did kishi break minatos character?

[Ebisu]

Like it was said ftg was invented by him. Then all of a sudden tobirama uses it , so why didn't he used it during part one when edted. Than his intelligence from calculating and shrewd to a goofy guy. Than inventor of ftg to copier of a tbb. Like what? Tobirama could have been given a different jutsu for space time. Than for rasengan could have been said he never saw a tbb or something. His intelligence I feel got shitted on. I don't hate tobirama , but thats how I feel. Btw I am no minato fanboy but I feel his character changed. On phone so can't give scans.

 

[mikeeozua]

He had to change his character otherwise he would just be some boring perfect ken doll with a personality as interesting as cardboard. I'm glad that Kishi gave him the flaw in naming really long names for jutsu, to be honest. And his affection towards his students, it makes him more interesting IMO.

 

[AlphaScythian]

Was minato a good character to begin with?

 

[Ebisu]

He had to change his character otherwise he would just be some boring perfect ken doll with a personality as interesting as cardboard. I'm glad that Kishi gave him the flaw in naming really long names for jutsu, to be honest. And his affection towards his students.

He was a bad ass character like thing. Then why doesn't kishi change madara into a bych who whines. Why didn't he whine when the bijus smacked the shit out him. He is also to perfect of a antagonist.

 

[KisuneUchiha]

He had to change his character otherwise he would just be some boring perfect ken doll with a personality as interesting as cardboard. I'm glad that Kishi gave him the flaw in naming really long names for jutsu, to be honest. And his affection towards his students, it makes him more interesting IMO.

Cardboard CAN be very interesting XD

 

[mikeeozua]

He was a bad ass character like thing. Then why doesn't kishi change madara into a bych who whines. Why didn't he whine when the bijus smacked the shit out him. He is also to perfect of a antagonist.

He isn't a 'perfect' antagonist, he admitted himself that his plans have not worked at all and he has had to improvise a lot. Plus he still carries that inner strife towards the Senju over Izuna which doesn't make him completely evil.

 

[Kakashi Hatakeo]

Yeah he changed the legendary minato, keep things how they are man I mean itachi didn't come back as a joker, nor hanzo or pain or anybody else. I just don't know man

 

[Lucidus]

no not necersarily broke his character but i do think Kishi made a mistake in giving minato KCM mode i just feel it does nothing for him at all.. Minato's speed was already legendary, he was already a sensor type.. and he is an edo so no need for a mountain ton increase in chakra plus this means we dont get to see his original chakra pool because people will just say he can only do certain things that to the cloak...

plus being an edo means he doesnt lose chakra anyways >.<

 

[Young Thug]

You must be registered for see images

 

[Fair Warning]

Kishi missed a lot of things....but thats another thread...

When Minato came back, we should have seen him bow in front of the previous hokage and say he did all he could to protect the leaf. He should not have been a wise cracking, tobirama copier, slow, unanalytical goofball like part 1 naruto.

Kushina said Minato was a genius and cool and calm, now suddenly he is just like Naruto

 

[the last uchiha]

Like it was said ftg was invented by him. Then all of a sudden tobirama uses it , so why didn't he used it during part one when edted. Than his intelligence from calculating and shrewd to a goofy guy. Than inventor of ftg to copier of a tbb. Like what? Tobirama could have been given a different jutsu for space time. Than for rasengan could have been said he never saw a tbb or something. His intelligence I feel got shitted on. I don't hate tobirama , but thats how I feel. Btw I am no minato fanboy but I feel his character changed. On phone so can't give scans.

nahh minato always been a shoddy shinobi and lame boring character

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Minato will and always will be top 5 material...maybe even top three, edo or not, cloak or not.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Kishi missed a lot of things....but thats another thread...

When Minato came back, we should have seen him bow in front of the previous hokage and say he did all he could to protect the leaf. He should not have been a wise cracking, tobirama copier, slow, unanalytical goofball like part 1 naruto.

Kushina said Minato was a genius and cool and calm, now suddenly he is just like Naruto

Fail, Naruto is like him.

He came first...the dad.
Logic...

Minato is a genius....he figured out rinne rebirth in 3 seconds.
He's also calm, but this is a war.
Minato bows to no one because they are inferior.

 

[Gerkak]

Minato was ruined. I agree

 

[AlphaScythian]

For me minato is just Nighcrawler with a knife while dependent on the knife to teleport and bigger rasengan. Not strong enough.
Hence he got BM i guess.

He's not really developed as a character for me, doesnt have much drama, purpose and all. He was needed as back story to kid naruto.
Bringing him back is just as stupid as bringing Fukagu with MS imho.

 

[Ovan]

Most jutsu are copied and used by other ninja. Minato took the jutsu and made a version of it that fit his play style. That is all. Lacking information does not mean that it was made up.

People act in many different ways during different situations.

 

[Ebisu]

Why people calling him a robot?

 

[-Punk-]

No he didn't , Minato is one of the great characters of the series .

 

[Xlad]

It wasn't said anywhere that Minato invented FTG. Tobirama using ST Ninjutsu wasn't a stretch, especially when Minato noted Obito's Kamui being superior to both his and Tobirama's Space Time technique.

 

[Calpal]

Minato is more dissapointing now that hes not intimidating and acts like a kid, yes, a bit ruined.