(DrProof) Ideology; The Sharingan's Truth [Must Read]

[DrProof]

The Presumed Truth

---

Prologue

The Sharingan one of the Three Great Doujutsu in Naruto has yet to been fully explained, thus why I've decided to give my opinion on the Kekkei Genkei. The answers in which I will be answering in this theory are the following: Why do the Uchiha achieve a variety of abilities due to their sharingan, and How their emotional thinking (key word emotion) allows them to unlock the said abilities.​

Hypothesis​

The true way the Uchiha in which we've formerly came to know about unlock The Sharingan, and its other forms due to witnessing (or have their minds delude them to believing the event happened) the loss of a loved one, or someone they held close, but this isn't hatred in which unlocks the Sharingan completely it's their infatuation (which causes the hatred)

You must be registered for see links

with their losted loved ones which causes them mental distraught leading them to releases special chakra into their brains allowing them to unlock "the eye that reflects feelings"; The Sharingan.

However, as their hatred deepens, and grows stronger as Tobirama Senju clearly explains they unlock new powers of The Sharingan; Mangekyou Sharingan along with Tsukuyomi, Amaterasu, Susano'o, Kamui, Kotoamatsukami. However how exactly are these techniques unlocked? I presume IT ISN'T genetic, but by the users ideology. Here are my thoughts on the current subject.

• The Sharingan's abilities aren't passed down blood to blood, but by the users ideology (I will explain this later).
• Izanagi/Izanami may or may not be unlocked by the users ideology however, I believe that the usage of the two techniques depend on the users state of mind meaning, the user is able to use the techniques with the right ideals or mental state.
• An Uchiha's "symptom" due to their mental distraught for their loved ones effect their ideals causing them to unlock a great power; The Sharingan.

The Uchiha (due to their mental distraught) after the lose of a loved one deploys a symptom in which causes allows them the ability to unlock the Doujutsu, The Sharingan, which gives them new abilities. However, my theory is that the abilities of The Sharingan in which they are branded with are inherited not genetically, but by their ideology. The connect to Ideals, and the Uchiha's mental distraught for their lost love ones is quite similar.

Ideology
noun, plural i·de·ol·o·gies.
1. The body of doctrine, myth, belief, etc., that guides an individual, social movement, institution, class, or large group.
2. Such a body of doctrine, myth, etc., with reference to some political and social plan, as that of fascism, along with the devices for putting it into operation.
3. Philosophy. A. the study of the nature and origin of ideas. B. a system that derives ideas exclusively from sensation.
4. Theorizing of a visionary or impractical nature.

I want everyone to strictly pay attention to the Philosophy definition B. "A system that derive ideas exclusively from sensation." key word their is sensation (Sensation: A state of heightened interest or emotion: "The anticipation produced in me a sensation somewhat between bliss and fear" -James Weldon Johnson), and what do the Uchiha thrive off of to become stronger? That's right, emotion. With this in mind, I'm sure most of the members on base can deduce what I'm getting at, and that is "Why certain Uchiha's have the abilities they do." I'll be explaining that now.

Due to the explanation I've just inferred that Uchiha clan members have the abilities they do through their own Ideals about X, and/or Y (Someone/Something etc). However, explaining it isn't enough, I have to give some examples as to why I believe the said conclusion is correct, I'll analyze Itachi Uchiha:

Itachi: A pacifist, who tried to stay away from physically hurting someone however, he wasn't above using force if necessary. Itachi is someone who would do anything to protect his loved ones, a noble man who'd even try to undo the evilness of others by allowing them to repeat an event continuously until they accepted their fate: Tsukuyomi, Amaterasu, and Susano'o.

Susano'o: Due to Itachi being the shinobi he is he'd try to protect anyone, and anything he held dearly. A prime example is: Konoha, Sasuke Uchiha, and his secret.

Amaterasu: Itachi being the pacifist he is, he doesn't like to fight physically much. However, when push comes to shove he wasn't afraid to get his hands dirty.

Tsukuyomi: Itachi is a known pacifist, and prefers to justify his battles without touching his opponents physically, but mentally this is the ideal jutsu for that very purpose.

Izanami: Itachi being the kind-hearted pacifist he truly is would give his enemy a chance to rethink themselves, as well as their ultimate resolve, allowing them to accept fate.

Sasuke however, genetically inherited his abilities (from Itachi possibly) or he could also have ideologies in which enable him to possess his current techniques, who knows as I haven't fully analyzed Sasuke. Anyhow, I will explain other Uchiha's if needed in replies as I just wanted to get to the point in this thread, and not prolong it as I know many members use the TL;DR.​

​

Special Chakra​

Think back to when Tobirama had been talking about the Sharingan, and how it was awakended, Tobirama's exact words were: "Special chakra sprouts inside their brains which affects the optic nerve and produces a change in their eyes.". This special chakra is triggered by their feelings for a lost love one, now read on to the next quote: "That is "the eye that reflects feelings".

You must be registered for see links

The reflection of feelings, that is the answer to everything. A person's ideology is triggered by their mutual feelings about someone/something, the Sharingan is awakened by the feelings of the Uchiha, and the Mangekyou Sharingan's abilities are dependent on the Uchiha's ideologies.​

Conclusion​

• The Uchiha's abilities are inherited genetically, and by their Ideology. Thus, this proves why their current ideals grant them their techniques, and ties into their mental distraught symptom; Unlocking The Sharingan.

​

 

[Hori]

Ahh.. did read (1st two lines).. Its an old thread of yours.

 

[DrProof]

Ahh.. didn't read.. Its an old thread of yours.

Incorrect it isn't. I revised a bit more in this theory. Instead of genetically passed down, I believe it's more strongly dependent on the Uchiha's ideals. I've even added a section: "Special Chakra" to elaborate more on this.

An example of blood to blood brothers not possessing the same techniques (which should theoretically be passed down due to same DNA/Lineage) would be Hashirama, and Tobirama.

 

[Naruto.]

I completely agree. Each Uchiha hence has his own unique Mangekyou ability.
Obito for example, was fed up of this world, and wanted to create a dream world.
Kamui is almost equal to the alternate world, because it's an alternate dimension.

Sasuke had a burning desire to kill his brother, the one who massacred the entire clan, like it was nothing. That's why he was able to manipulate Amaterasu's flames.

 

[olumiday]

the Sharingan isn't awakened by losing a loved one.
that requirement is for MS awakening.

 

[Chīkara]

Don't know what to think of it.. Its good but I kinda disagree with
the Jutsu's the user get from certain ideology's,
Do you mind elaborating on both Sasuke and Obito ?

​

​

I completely agree. Each Uchiha hence has his own unique Mangekyou ability.
Obito for example, was fed up of this world, and wanted to create a dream world.
Kamui is almost equal to the alternate world, because it's an alternate dimension.

Sasuke had a burning desire to kill his brother, the one who massacred the entire clan, like it was nothing. That's why he was able to manipulate Amaterasu's flames.

Then Susano'o wouldn't suit him at all since proof said it was to protect.
Sasuke only wanted to destroy at that time.



​

​

 

[DrProof]

I completely agree. Each Uchiha hence has his own unique Mangekyou ability.
Obito for example, was fed up of this world, and wanted to create a dream world.
Kamui is almost equal to the alternate world, because it's an alternate dimension.

Sasuke had a burning desire to kill his brother, the one who massacred the entire clan, like it was nothing. That's why he was able to manipulate Amaterasu's flames.

Correct. Obito wanted to escape reality, exactly when Rin died I believe right then, and there Obito had came to the conclusion that without Rin, there was no point to living in THIS world.

You must be registered for see links

. So once Obito saw Rin died, he unlocked Kamui.

Note: Kakashi unlocked Kamui as well due to having Obito's eye, it was due to Obito's own ideology did the Sharingan actually unlock Kamui. Kakashi had passed out seconds later, no even knowing Mangekyou Sharingan had been unlocked.

 

[God of TryHards]

Ehhhhh a lot of what you say I would think is true. Except when you mention their ideals unlock their specific abilities. I think that's too much of a stretch an seems more reaonable to be a genetic thing. I mean you can take any ability and compare it to a characters personality. Interesting read though.

 

[Naruto.]

Then Susano'o wouldn't suit him at all since proof said it was to protect.
Sasuke only wanted to destroy at that time.



​

The Susano'o's use is not only to protect, but to attack too.
Plus, Susano'o is common among Madara, Sasuke and Itachi. So, that's a different thing there.

 

[DrProof]

Then Susano'o wouldn't suit him at all since proof said it was to protect.
Sasuke only wanted to destroy at that time.​

​

Remember Sasuke wanted to protect the Uchiha name. So that is one, in the same. Protecting = Susano'o. I believe Sasuke's more inept rage for those who scorned the Uchiha's past unlocked Amaterasu Control (Blaze Release).

 

[Hori]

Incorrect it isn't. I revised a bit more in this theory. Instead of genetically passed down, I believe it's more strongly dependent on the Uchiha's ideals. I've even added a section: "Special Chakra" to elaborate more on this.

An example of blood to blood brothers not possessing the same techniques (which should theoretically be passed down due to same DNA/Lineage) would be Hashirama, and Tobirama.

Ahahaha that was a joke relax....Then what about Madara, Izuna? Both from same parents but different motives. Also what about their father Fugaku? What is so similar with him and his sons? How do you explain the fact that Sasuke's abilities that he gained from Itachi for example amaterasu, why did he become more proficient with it then Itachi, thus unlocking enton manipulation?

 

[Braveknight]

Nothing to disagree here, how ever, what about madara's case?

 

[DrProof]

Ahahaha that was a joke relax....Then what about Madara, Izuna? Both from same parents but different motives. Also what about their father Fugaku? What is so similar with him and his sons? How do you explain the fact that Sasuke's abilities that he gained from Itachi for example amaterasu, why did he become more proficient with it then Itachi, thus unlocking enton manipulation?

We know nothing about Izuna (ability wise) remember, nor Fugaku for that matter. Similarity doesn't mean anything within this theory as it's all based off of one person's ideology be it Itachi, Sasuke, Obito, Madara etc.

To explain as to why Sasuke is more inept, and advanced with Amaterasu than Itachi is simple, his rage for his clan triggered a better use of the offensive ability. You can also apply this to Itachi's advancement within Tsukuyomi: Itachi's Tsukuyomi was better due to having a more pacifistic outlook on life (preferred to not use physical contact, but mental/verbal).

 

[Europa]

It would make sense and I'd find it rather cool if kishi did decide to implement this in the manga. But I have a feeling he'll never fully delve on the details and just expect us to accept it in the end.

Anyways; I liked it. Wish you would post that thread on Kimimaro and the Sage though...

 

[DrProof]

Ehhhhh a lot of what you say I would think is true. Except when you mention their ideals unlock their specific abilities. I think that's too much of a stretch an seems more reaonable to be a genetic thing. I mean you can take any ability and compare it to a characters personality. Interesting read though.

I see nothing as a "stretch", but more-so as another outlook on things.

Nothing to disagree here, how ever, what about madara's case?

Madara is simple, yet complicated at the same time. I'm going to analyze Sasuke, Madara, Obito, as well Itachi a bit more, and post another thread regarding a continuation of their ideology = abilities received.

 

[ANiMUS]

I agree when coming to their key MS jutsu
Itachi-deceitful-tsukuyomi
Sasuke-malice/ destruction- amaterasu
Madara- overprotective-susanoo
Obito-dillusional/ won't except reality-Kamui
I don't agree with every part, but nice theory+rep

 

[AlphaScythian]

Izanagi/izanami is basic 3T jutsu has nothing to do with emotions or mindset. So very wrong here.

Mindset/ideology may have influence on unique MS powers as well as it has on design.

The intensity of emotions would result into stronger sharingan which would enhance all its attributes.

 

[DrProof]

It would make sense and I'd find it rather cool if kishi did decide to implement this in the manga. But I have a feeling he'll never fully delve on the details and just expect us to accept it in the end.

Anyways; I liked it. Wish you would post that thread on Kimimaro and the Sage though...

I doubt he will. But if he does, it'd be amazing to see his explanation, and where he'd take this.

I agree when coming to there key MS jutsu
Itachi-deceitful-tsukuyomi
Sasuke-malice/ destruction- amaterasu
Madara- overprotective-susanoo
Obito-dillusional/ won't except reality-Kamui
I don't agree with every part, but nice theory+rep

Thanks, but what part(s) do you not agree with? I would like to clear up some misconceptions in your doubts.

 

[sealingscroll]

Nice. People need to read and think.

 

[DrProof]

Izanagi/izanami is basic 3T jutsu has nothing to do with emotions or mindset. So very wrong here.

Mindset/ideology may have influence on unique MS powers as well as it has on design.

The intensity of emotions would result into stronger sharingan which would enhance all its attributes.

I had forgotten that Izanagi/Izanami was a simple 3-tomeo technique. Thank you for announcing that. I also agree that the intensity of their emotions later on could strengthen their Mangekyou Sharingan techniques. An example of this would be Sasuke breaking Danzo's Curse Seal, with an outbreak of chakra.