Mangaka with the most Imagination (Kishi, Oda, Kubo, Isayama)

[CurseSealofEarth]

No, they are not. Concepts are way too different. I could make you a whole essay on the differences between SnK and DeathNote U_U

And nobody would read it.

 

[Kurome]

People saying any other than Oda just never read One Piece so they are out of this vote ... lol

Edit : I love SnK and Naruto but nothing compares to where One Piece can take you.
One Piece verse is so vast no one can do better in terms of imagination .....
Giants, mermaids , humans , robots , fishmen , sea monsters are just some examples

The universe can be so vast and big but all the bold things are not really original. The same with naruto. SnK is in another league when it comes to originality and admit it, has anybody ever thought of the concept of the 3D Maneuver Gear? U_U

 

[Gitch]

The universe can be so vast and big but all the bold things are not really original. The same with naruto. SnK is in another league when it comes to originality and admit it, has anybody ever thought of the concept of the 3D Maneuver Gear? U_U

3D maneuver is great but have you ever seen a starfish with a bob marley hat on and sunglasses in SnK
Or even a Robot running on coca cola ....
Or someone able to shatter earth and sky with a tremor.....
u cant fit all that in one manga if you ask me but One piece do

And if you ask me Luffy second gear and third gear are pretty original

 

[ObitoKarin]

Yeah sure, they are nothing on imagination near Hajime Isayama U_U Isayama wins this with AoT.

This. I think AoT creator needs a place too. It's a great storyline. Mad that season 2 isn't out yet. :I Finished Season 1 like a month ago and have been waiting for a announcement

 

[Clouds]

I don't even like one piece that much but

One piece takes this easily... :l

 

[Meee]

The universe can be so vast and big but all the bold things are not really original. The same with naruto. SnK is in another league when it comes to originality and admit it, has anybody ever thought of the concept of the 3D Maneuver Gear? U_U

Kinda similar to Spidermans webs.

 

[GreenV]

One Piece won in Naruto base?

Well I indeed voted for Oda.

 

[November]

In terms of imagination, Oda wins.

 

[Kurome]

3D maneuver is great but have you ever seen a starfish with a bob marley hat on and sunglasses in SnK
Or even a Robot running on coca cola ....
Or someone able to shatter earth and sky with a tremor.....
u cant fit all that in one manga if you ask me but One piece do

You mean this?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Lol

Well, they are in different leagues. You can't compare friendship, hope etc. with immense fear, almost no hope, sadistic deaths etc. U_U I will always say Isayama is better, but everybody has their own opinions.

 

[Gitch]

You mean this?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Lol

Well, they are in different leagues. You can't compare friendship, hope etc. with immense fear, almost no hope, sadistic deaths etc. U_U I will always say Isayama is better, but everybody has their own opinions.

Yea I never said i dont like the story of SnK ..... Pretty out of the bunch , it feels different and I like it....
at least someone is not affraid of killing their characters
Oda does a good job in that too..... Kishi would never kill someone as important as Ace or WB

But still in terms of imagination Oda takes it and id say Oda and Isa are pretty much equal in storytelling

Edit : BTW i really cant wait for more SnK animes .... sucks we have to wait !

 

[ObitoKarin]

Mine are just Naruto, Bleach, and AoT. I don't really keep up with OP and I haven't even started the other one.




Latest Post: Please check it out

You must be registered for see links

 

[htmwall]

there's an extremely underrated anime that IMHO the only one that can compete with one piece in term of imagination which is Gintama,i know the anime and manga are a big collection of jokes,but when it gets serious it's one of the best written mangas.

 

[Olorin]

The universe can be so vast and big but all the bold things are not really original. The same with naruto. SnK is in another league when it comes to originality and admit it, has anybody ever thought of the concept of the 3D Maneuver Gear? U_U

Spiderman has

Also the story is a basic zombie survival story, only with giants which are just giant ppl ... Oh and there is a basement

Yea I never said i dont like the story of SnK ..... Pretty out of the bunch , it feels different and I like it....
at least someone is not affraid of killing their characters
Oda does a good job in that too..... Kishi would never kill someone as important as Ace or WB

But still in terms of imagination Oda takes it and id say Oda and Isa are pretty much equal in storytelling

Edit : BTW i really cant wait for more SnK animes .... sucks we have to wait !

Jiraiya

 

[-immortal-]

ofcourse one piec fggs go for oda

 

[Olorin]

ofcourse one piec fggs go for oda

And ofc ... With a good reason

 

[Gitch]

They should make a Databook for authors ...

Oda -----------------------------------Kishi

Storytelling:9.5 ------------------------ 8
Imagination:10 ------------------------ 7
Consistency:9 ------------------------ 7
Sexyness: 0 ------------------------ 0


didnt put Kubo here for a simple reason ..... hes like a fodder

 

[Nicksterz]

One piece isn't creative, it's just retarded.
Bad story, bad art and even worse characters.
All very clichè and basic in anime standards.

I give it to Kishi and kubo.
Snk is cool with 3D gear and titan variations, but honestly not that imaginative.

This is Naruto Base not one shit base. C

 

[-immortal-]

And ofc ... With a good reason

well sir.be creative and tell me

 

[Nicksterz]

Spiderman has

Also the story is a basic zombie survival story, only with giants which are just giant ppl ... Oh and there is a basement



Jiraiya

Neji, Shukakku, inoichi, yamato (most likely), asuma, itachi, and more to come no doubt.

 

[-Punk-]

Oh shit

You must be registered for see images

​