Mangaka with the most Imagination (Kishi, Oda, Kubo, Isayama)

[North Kai]

Which of these authors has the most imagination?
Masashi Kishimoto - Naruto
Eiichiro Oda - One Piece
Tite Kubo - Bleach
Hajime Isayama - SNK

 

[The7thHokage]

I would go with SNK, since Naruto, Bleach, and OP are based on true stories, legends, and common mythology.

 

[Olorin]

I don't usually care what ppls favorites or bests are unless they try to shove it down your throat, bash or just dont know what they are talking about

But as far as imagination goes, if you read all 4 of them, Oda should be the victor, easily, thats not even arguable,mit's just basic common sense if you know how crazy, huge and versatile Odas world and designs are

I mean Narutoa and Bleach are quite imaginative but nowhere as original and out there as the OP world and SNK is very basic as far as the world and story go

 

[Arian]

ehat is snk? oda and kishi are both geniouses imo .. but tite kubo sucks the big one. bleach had a great story until the aizen arc...but imo it was never on the same level as one piece and naruto

 

[Kurome]

Yeah sure, they are nothing on imagination near Hajime Isayama U_U Isayama wins this with AoT.

 

[Kurome]

ehat is snk? oda and kishi are both geniouses imo .. but tite kubo sucks the big one. bleach had a great story until the aizen arc...but imo it was never on the same level as one piece and naruto

Shingeki no Kyojin - Attack on Titan

 

[kibainuzuka]

One Piece>SnK
seriously if you put SnK here put Death Note too,those are same league -_-

 

[muhachiuchiha]

They all have good imagination, and all of them are using some sort of mythology, its not like Isayama thought of titans, and Kishi didnt just think of Jiraya, Oro and Tsunade. Out of the 4, i still think Kishis imagination is the best.

 

[-Punk-]

Only know Kishi & Hajime , I don't follow the rest . So going with my man Hajime Isayama .*votes* *blushes*

 

[Kurome]

One Piece>SnK
seriously if you put SnK here put Death Note too,those are same league -_-

No, they are not. Concepts are way too different. I could make you a whole essay on the differences between SnK and DeathNote U_U

 

[Gitch]

Oda hands down ..... hes been going for 10 years and still nothing seems redundant

 

[dark legion]

I believe they all base their creations on Legends and culture ...but anyway Masashi Kishimoto overdo it ,so Masashi Kishimoto has the best imagination ,, I think :hyper:

 

[Meee]

Tsugumi Ohba

 

[Gitch]

They all have good imagination, and all of them are using some sort of mythology, its not like Isayama thought of titans, and Kishi didnt just think of Jiraya, Oro and Tsunade. Out of the 4, i still think Kishis imagination is the best.

How is One Piece using mythology ? nothing you see in One Piece will be like the others

 

[-Akuma-]

Kouta Hirano

 

[kibainuzuka]

No, they are not. Concepts are way too different. I could make you a whole essay on the differences between SnK and DeathNote U_U

both are like around maybe 70-100 episodes of anime [Snk will finish in 20 volumes] and both are unique,both are original,not based on something,thats what I meant

 

[htmwall]

No, they are not. Concepts are way too different. I could make you a whole essay on the differences between SnK and DeathNote U_U

what he meant is that both mangas use the same redundant concept.
death note: killing with writing names(thought has more mind games in it).
SNK: kids killing giants 24/7.
both worlds can't compare to OP world they're too limited.

 

[Gitch]

People saying any other than Oda just never read One Piece so they are out of this vote ... lol

Edit : I love SnK and Naruto but nothing compares to where One Piece can take you.
One Piece verse is so vast no one can do better in terms of imagination .....
Giants, mermaids , humans , robots , fishmen , sea monsters are just some examples

 

[take it easy]

oda and kishi

 

[Kurome]

what he meant is that both mangas use the same redundant concept.
death note: killing with writing names(thought has more mind games in it).
SNK: kids killing giants 24/7.
both worlds can't compare to OP world they're too limited.

After all they've seen, i tell you they're not kids anymore Lol