[Question] Is Garp stronger than the 3 Admirals ?

[Mattek2008]

Question. Do you think that Garp is stronger than the admirals? 1v1 scenario, not 3v1.

 

[GenKiDama]

yes. remember what the marines said at marineford, "hes our best guardian"

 

[Titania Erza]

I don't know, since I haven't seen Garp in action (at his current age). Since Kizaru couldnt beat Rayleigh, I think that Garp wouldnt be beaten by Kizaru as well. Fujitora is a weird case, since his DF-powers seems to be completely broken. And we dont know anything about the last admiral.

 

[Mattek2008]

I don't know, since I haven't seen Garp in action (at his current age). Since Kizaru couldnt beat Rayleigh, I think that Garp wouldnt be beaten by Kizaru as well. Fujitora is a weird case, since his DF-powers seems to be completely broken. And we dont know anything about the last admiral.

Oh, well i mean at marineford arc. forgot to include that, sorry

 

[UchihaNagashi]

Garp has fought Roger sometimes, occasionally. And they almost killed each other.

So I think this shouldn't be a question.​

 

[Khallil]

well he fought on par with Gol D. Roger, so I think so

 

[Hexuze]

Pre-TS, possibly but post-TS I seriously doubt he is.

 

[Mattek2008]

well he fought on par with Gol D. Roger, so I think so

Garp has fought Roger sometimes, occasionally. And they almost killed each other.

So I think this shouldn't be a question.​

Well obviously, but that was 20+ years ago and he is rather old. So i don't think it's that obvious that he would or wouldn't beat them...

 

[Lt Fresh]

If you mean presently, probably not due to age.

If you're talking about during the marineford arc then yes. Sengoku had to slam Garp's face into the ground so he wouldn't go kill Akainu. And I would assume he can take on beat Aokiji and Kizaru...of course 1v1
-Garp is at least admiral level, he could have been an admiral but denied the position multiple times.

 

[Mattek2008]

If you mean presently, probably not due to age.

If you're talking about during the marineford arc then yes. Sengoku had to slam Garp's face into the ground so he wouldn't go kill Akainu. And I would assume he can take on beat Aokiji and Kizaru...of course 1v1
-Garp is at least admiral level, he could have been an admiral but denied the position multiple times.

Great answer, thanks. Yes i should've spent more time writing this thread. I apologize

 

[Titania Erza]

Oh, well i mean at marineford arc. forgot to include that, sorry

OH the former ones

Kizaru is still Kizaru,s o my opinion about that won't change. Garp seemed quite confident in being able to beat the crap out of Aikanu, but to be honest I don't know if he could have defeated Aikanu. That Sengoku had to hold him down isnt a good reason, since when Garp would have attacked Sengoku, it would had been way too chaotic. Against Aokiji, I think that it will be either a draw or a win with high difficulty.

 

[UchihaNagashi]

Well obviously, but that was 20+ years ago and he is rather old. So i don't think it's that obvious that he would or wouldn't beat them...

He got a V2 Luffy punch from point black without losing consciousness, stroke Marco down when Kizaru and Akainu failed in the task, has lifted a chain and cannonball (if you can call it even that in that situation), which was many times bigger than the Sunny, beat the hell out of Chinjao in his prime who was at least as old as him and was on par at old age with current Luffy, beat the hell out of Roger multiple times as stated by himself, crushed 8 mountains when facing Chinjao, has mastered Haki, has been offered this place of admiral multiple times but refused.

And you still deny his strength?​

​

 

[David1996]

Garp the mother****ing hero mannn

 

[Mattek2008]

He got a V2 Luffy punch from point black without losing consciousness, stroke Marco down when Kizaru and Akainu failed in the task, has lifted a chain and cannonball (if you can call it even that in that situation), which was many times bigger than the Sunny, beat the hell out of Chinjao in his prime who was at least as old as him and was on par at old age with current Luffy, beat the hell out of Roger multiple times as stated by himself, crushed 8 mountains when facing Chinjao, has mastered Haki, has been offered this place of admiral multiple times but refused.

And you still deny his strength?​

​

No, i don't deny his strength at all, sorry if it sounded like that. I haven't caught up with One Piece yet, i just finished watching the Marineford arc, and then Garp said he would kill Aikanu. So i just made a thread asking if this was possible, because considering Garps age, he shouldn't be as strong as he was in his prime.. I did make a poorly written thread, and for that i apologize

 

[YellowFang]

Individually...?
Yes, in his prime days...
Now, maybe not...

 

[P3ĮÑ]

With hype included, he obviously is. Kizaru fought somewhat on par with Rayleigh, and GOL D roger was said to be confronted and cornered by garp occasionally, still adding he must've been pretty powerful in his prime, even by feats, he damaged marco with a single punch, who sent kizaru flying with a single kick. still current garp can't take on all three of the admiral together IMO

Individually, it's possible.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

Yup.
If he went against all three of them at once, imo, they would push him half to death.
But he would come out on top.
Id give it to Garp, extreme diff.

 

[AlicexX]

Yup.
If he went against all three of them at once, imo, they would push him half to death.
But he would come out on top.
Id give it to Garp, extreme diff.

So you're saying that Garp can defeat all of the Admirals in a 3v1 scenario?

OT: I think that he could beat one extreme-diff. If not then he pushes one to extreme.

 

[Fireplay]

Prime Garp is. Not sure about old Garp. Probably yes.

Yup.
If he went against all three of them at once, imo, they would push him half to death.
But he would come out on top.
Id give it to Garp, extreme diff.

No one can beat 3 admirals at the same time bro. No one.

 

[Olorin]

I do think that Garp is steonger than the Admirals but I also think that the admirals are not yet in their prime, that will be in the promised war (well, except Fujitora)

Prime Garp imo about equaled Roger and Luffy will eventually become (maybe a bit stronger) what prime Garp was except with his gear 2nd hes gonna be like Garp on steroids