[Discussion] Why obito don't just use the rinenggan jutsu revive Rin?

[morningmoon]

I don't really understand. Why obito Didnt use his Rinnengan to revive Rin? Didn't he love Rin so much? Could it be Rinnengan only can revive those who been killed by the Rinnengan owner?

 

[scorezor]

I don't really understand. Why obito Didnt use his Rinnengan to revive Rin? Didn't he love Rin so much? Could it be Rinnengan only can revive those who been killed by the Rinnengan owner?

................... As far as i know... when the user of a rinnegan uses the Rinne-tensei the user sacrificies his own life.

 

[Bubbles The Powerpuff Girl]

It would be somewhat selfish.

Yes, he could have done it at first, but he stated ''I don't want to live in this world anymore''. He could've even died and not seen her ever again.

After the conversation with Naruto, Obito realized and said ''I regret this''. He wanted to make up for all the things he had done. I believe you can revive people from just a certain time-zone at a time.

If he just revived Rin, many many shinobi would remain dead. The family's and friends would want revenge and Rin would hate him.

He didn't want that.

 

[Klad]

It's because it isn't his goal . His goal was to end the cycle of "trash" .

 

[scorezor]

It would be somewhat selfish.

Yes, he could have done it at first, but he stated ''I don't want to live in this world anymore''. He could've even died and not seen her ever again.

After the conversation with Naruto, Obito realized and said ''I regret this''. He wanted to make up for all the things he had done. I believe you can revive people from just a certain time-zone at a time.

If he just revived Rin, many many shinobi would remain dead. The family's and friends would want revenge and Rin would hate him.

He didn't want that.

@bold - what do you mean by time-zone exactly?

 

[Bubbles The Powerpuff Girl]

@bold - what do you mean by time-zone exactly?

For example;

Jiraiya died a week ago.

10 shinobi's died today in the attack of Pain.

Time-zone (day or two).

You revive those 10 shinobi's. Jiraiya remains dead.

 

[Umari Senju]

Well he could have. But that would require his death in return and if he just revived her then we wouldn't have much of a war now would we

 

[scorezor]

For example;

Jiraiya died a week ago.

10 shinobi's died today in the attack of Pain.

Time-zone (day or two).

You revive those 10 shinobi's. Jiraiya remains dead.

Thanks for the answer =D. Well... i think that your thought (of the rinnegan) isn't true... because nagato was supposed to "revive" Madara and we know "Madara" died a long ass time ago , unless ... there's a second Madara that "f[Uu[/U]cks" that timeline somehow xD or time-zone , whatever you wanna call it xD. did this made sense to you?

 

[morningmoon]

As I know using Rinnengan reviving jutsu only cost massive amount of chakra. The user will not die if he is in perfect healthy condition. Pain case is different where he use it when he doesn't have enough chakra.

If obito could use it on Rin just after Nagato die. It will save him a lot work and time. If I am obito I am sure revive the person I love the soonest.

The only reason I could guest, is that jutsu only can revive those who been killed by Rinnengan owner. Just like Nagato case, he only revive those thing and people he kill/destroy.

And here I guest madara killing himself while he still have the Rinnengan with him aged ago. That's why he could be revived.

However the jiraiya case remain mystery, why everyone killed by Nagato is revived, but only jiraiya remain dead? 2 possibility, 1- not enough chakra or life force. 2- jiraiya is already revived and he is now hiding somewhere or doing something mystery. Will be coming to save naruto soon.

 

[xLucyx]

Isn't it more that Jiraiya died while he was sinking? Even if Jiraiya was revived, he would still die, because of the water pressure on him.

 

[Draxus]

The only reason I could guest, is that jutsu only can revive those who been killed by Rinnengan owner. Just like Nagato case, he only revive those thing and people he kill/destroy.

And here I guest madara killing himself while he still have the Rinnengan with him aged ago. That's why he could be revived.

However the jiraiya case remain mystery, why everyone killed by Nagato is revived, but only jiraiya remain dead? 2 possibility, 1- not enough chakra or life force. 2- jiraiya is already revived and he is now hiding somewhere or doing something mystery. Will be coming to save naruto soon.

That's definitely not true. Madara didn't have the rinnegan when he died.

Also there is no way Nagato only ever killed leaf ninja. The obvious answer is that it's ability is limited to both chakra and the will of the user. Nagato only willed to restore the lives of those he killed in the village, not over his long history as Pein.

As for the OP... even if Obito would remain alive after reviving Rin, what would that do for him? All it would do is divert him from the path he chose, it be completely retarded.

 

[the last shinobi]

For example;

Jiraiya died a week ago.

10 shinobi's died today in the attack of Pain.

Time-zone (day or two).

You revive those 10 shinobi's. Jiraiya remains dead.

What are you talking about, if thats the case madara wouldn't have gave him his eyes in the first place. The purpose of Nagato getting the eyes was to revive him later(not two days from the day he died). Also then how did obito just revive madara who clearly died 16 or more years ago.

 

[FearxDeath]

I don't really understand. Why obito Didnt use his Rinnengan to revive Rin? Didn't he love Rin so much? Could it be Rinnengan only can revive those who been killed by the Rinnengan owner?

Its simple, the world was Hell. So why would he revive Rin and bring her back into Hell.

 

[Ahmed1993]

To him , the real Rin is a fake :|