No. Heated metals lose magnetism at their curie point. Gold is not magnetic, so saying it will lose its ability to be magnetic is ludicrous. Assuming he uses Iron sand like he third Kazekage plated with gold, he still wouldn't lose its magnetism. Iron's curie point is 1316 Celsius. If not, then the only thing left to theorise on is Gold being magnetic and having a curie point. If not, then you can come up with your own theory/hypothesis.
Ah, well I was checking over his fight again to make a final judgment and did notice this bit
4th Kazekage uses Jinton - the Art of Magnet release. It uses magnetism to manipulate metals and perform their jutsu, be it Gold dust style or Iron Sand style.
No. Lava is at 1000-1500 Kelvin when it is beneath lots of other lava. The lowest point is usually about 5200 Kelvin, just to show how the level (implying place) in which lava is matters. Mei can use lava which instantly cools down since it is in a thin layer compared to erupting volcano's lava. Hence why I put the number 650-800. And the curie point isn't always beneath the melting point, Cobalt has a higher curie point than melting point believe it or not. And assuming that it will melt even with your inaccurate given temperatures is false, since debates weight odds out. And the odd are gold will still not melt in her lava since it is higher than the mean. 'Atleast 20%' is an asspull. And even if you do that to my 'more' accurate data, it still is beyond the curie point since it is approximately 850 C degress>650-800.
That's a baseless assumption considering mei has been shown to be the one who manipulates the cooling of her lava as she hardened it near instantly when she shot it at the wall in kage summit, yet kept it liquid for a sustained period during the madara battle. The fact that she can also control the acidic nature of her acid to melt concrete just solidifies this. If anything, the temperature of her lava is higher than that which comes from a volcanic vent. It's not a small stream, it's a condensed stream that was heated and flung out. Air temperature isn't cooling it that quickly, it'd take water for better cooling.
What? She doesn't control the hardening of her lava, that's absurd. Prove it related scans or don't assume such nonsense. Her Lava cooled down quickly because she used a smaller amount of it. When she used her lava against Madara she used an enormous amount, and even then you can't say it wouldn't have cooled down quickly. She was non-stop using lava, so the lava wouldn't have cooled down if it was still being supplied with the same heat of its own [
Your scans proved my points. The first attack was lava which stayed a liquid for quite a while. The second was lava to cover madara, not suiton, which then began to harden. Same way when she spat lava on walls at summit, it cooled quickly as it rolled down and sealed the rooms. Easy evidence of the fact that it near instantly cooled at the top while some parts where left hot to flow is the simple fact that the lava made a seal on a vertical wall with no added support. Normally, gravity would simply make it all drop off. We can go into the science of it all, but claiming it's absurd she can control the levels of Lava she isn't in contact with is like claiming it's insane she can control the acidity of lava she's not in contact with... even though she did it. Changing PH simply adding more [relevant] ions from water. Water she can simply get from her suiton. In the same way, changing the temperature of her lava is a simple matter of heating it with her katon, or cooling it with her suiton... without actually producing it. But, hey, I'm just stating an observation... If you think lava can be splashed on a door and harden on contact on the top, but flow down the rest of the way to then harder at the bottom, be my guest...
PM me if you want to continue tomorrow but I wanna eat my cereal out da milk.They didn't prove your points at all. The lava did indeed stay liquid for a while on both scans. Lava from volcano's may take up to 30+ years to completely cool down, while within the first 5-10 minutes it has cooled enough to make it possible to walk on. This makes it evident that lava's high temperature is instantly cooled down, while once it reaches say 400 (random number, but decently accurate) degrees and below, it is quite hard to cool down. And you are correct, I had misinterpreted the scan in which she did(n't) use suiton. However, you claiming it took any amount of time is irrelevant (not that you did) since we don't see her lava for more than 6 pages including the two pages in which she was still releasing her lava. Saying that time was not the same as the time it took for her lava to harden against Sasuke in comparison of a ratio between the two quantities of her lava is speculation. The time she used it against Sasuke, the lava had not hardened for two chapters; next chapter after she used it [Your scans proved my points. The first attack was lava which stayed a liquid for quite a while. The second was lava to cover madara, not suiton, which then began to harden. Same way when she spat lava on walls at summit, it cooled quickly as it rolled down and sealed the rooms. Easy evidence of the fact that it near instantly cooled at the top while some parts where left hot to flow is the simple fact that the lava made a seal on a vertical wall with no added support. Normally, gravity would simply make it all drop off. We can go into the science of it all, but claiming it's absurd she can control the levels of Lava she isn't in contact with is like claiming it's insane she can control the acidity of lava she's not in contact with... even though she did it. Changing PH simply adding more [relevant] ions from water. Water she can simply get from her suiton. In the same way, changing the temperature of her lava is a simple matter of heating it with her katon, or cooling it with her suiton... without actually producing it. But, hey, I'm just stating an observation... If you think lava can be splashed on a door and harden on contact on the top, but flow down the rest of the way to then harder at the bottom, be my guest...
One last thing "saying it's temperture... is laughable". Yea... torch style is so hot that it instantly vaporizes on contact, which is even beyond what lava is capable of.
Anyway, I'm bored of this now, sorry
I'll admit, you know your science and I've never had such an interesting scientific debate on here( majoring in a scientific field by chance?)... but Let me just put some point forward and see how you take them.
I agree, most scientific debate I have had. And no, I am not majoring, I am still 16 years old, I am simply good at science because I am in the IB program and take 2 sciences at a higher level (which would give me 6 credits for Bio, 6 credits for chemistry at Colombia University) which may be a reason to why I am pretty good at science. You yourself are also very good in science.
High speed projectiles can be blocked with extremely thin gold dust masses of equal size to the lava 'projectiles'. Lava has not shown to have any force, so saying they wouldn't block it is fictitious. It would simply demagnetise the thin gold dust, and drop to the floor with the gold dust. this will soon enough harden and the gold dust will cool below curie point, thus even more things to use for his magnetic attacks. Saying once he encircles her with gold, she wins is rather inaccurate. Once she is surrounded by that much gold dust, one her attacks won't be of scale to demagnetise all of it since the demagnetised ones will simply fall down towards gravity, making space for the magnetic ones. Furthermore, even if she somehow could make all that gold dust non-magnetic, it would still be too much for her to handle due to the sheer weight. Sand is approximately 7 times less dense than Gold dust, which logically implies it is extremely heavy. Her being hit by hot gold isn't the reason for why she would die, it is the pressure that would kill her, and she hasn't shown any tolerance for high pressure (tanking capability) now has she?
You can't use the pH change as a reference for slight proof that lava can be heated, let alone evident proof. I would agree she could change the temperature of her lava before spitting it out by cooling it, however, I disagree that she can heat it. Her having fire relase (Katon) doesn't imply she can heat lava with fire. It is illogical. The hottest fire is oxyhydrogen, and this fire can't be replicated since not only would it probably melt her (2000 C) but would also require a 2:1 hydrogen to oxygen level which in't easy to achieve. Fire in Naruto has never reached the colour white or any brighter colour, so she can't exceed temperatures beyond 1200 C. Moreover, if she had orange Katon, she could reach <1100 degrees C. This would be the same heat as the lava you are talking about. Any red fire (which is the only thing shown in the manga yet) is >900 C at most (if it isn't clear red [hasn't been shown in manga]). She can't heat the lava more than it already is heated, and odds are she doesn't have fire the heat of 1000 degrees let alone 1200 C. She still cannot heat it after it is released. Don't compare Roshi with Mei, he only has these abilities because of the Yonbi (Son Goku). Bijuu unique abilities are beyond any ability of a shinobi's abilities.
It's gold dust, not sand. This isn't Gaara. Never the less, Gold still doesn't melt from either of these, nor will it be affected by demagnetisation for a long period since the initial temperature cools quickly below the curie point (assuming there was one).
