[VS] EMS Sasuke vs EMS Madara

Waltz

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 6, 2011
Messages
9,979
Reaction score
1,256

...

Claims: Anyone with decent reading comprehension would realize that they were in close combat during the off paneled time period.

Then Claims: So you're telling me that Hashirama, who needed Shinsuusenju to disable Perfect Susanoo, is going to survive a prolonged battle with it and then eventually defeat Madara w/o the use of Shinsuusenju or any of his Mokuton Constructs? Again, you can't even be serious with this nonsense.

Then claims: Don't tell me he used them when he clearly left them behind.

You're contradicting yourself. Prior to his battle with Shodai at the valley, Madara was able to battle the Senju [including Hashirama] for a day before exhaustion; highlights the gap in events. I am saying that you have no evidence to support your 'belief' that Madara didn't resurface Susano'o or that Hashirama didn't use Mokuton jutsu between the time gap unless you're appealing to ignorance. Whatever wording you prefer to work with on Sennin Modo issue and yes, naturally we're referring to Madara in his prime at The End Valley as that is the standard to which he is measured. Would make no sense to rival him [Sasuke] against Madara before that point as his then apex of power, mastery over abilities and familiarity with his Sharingan jutsu all remains unknown.
 
Last edited:

Bronze

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
15,769
Reaction score
1,221
@Waltz:

I am amazed by your intelligence and debating. You're far better than me. I will waste all of my reputations giving it to you. You deserve it:).
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
...

Claims: Anyone with decent reading comprehension would realize that they were in close combat during the off paneled time period.

Then Claims: So you're telling me that Hashirama, who needed Shinsuusenju to disable Perfect Susanoo, is going to survive a prolonged battle with it and then eventually defeat Madara w/o the use of Shinsuusenju or any of his Mokuton Constructs? Again, you can't even be serious with this nonsense.

Then claims: Don't tell me he used them when he clearly left them behind.

You're contradicting yourself. Prior to his battle with Shodai at the valley, Madara was able to battle the Senju [including Hashirama] for a day before exhaustion; highlights the gap in events. I am saying that you have no evidence to support your 'belief' that Madara didn't resurface Susano'o or that Hashirama didn't use Mokuton jutsu between the time gap unless you're appealing to ignorance
.
What does Madara's stamina have anything to do with what I said? Where did I even contradict myself?

Anyone with decent reading comprehension would realize that they were in close combat during the off paneled time period

PS and the constructs that he clearly abandoned were not used, that much is clear.

So you're telling me that Hashirama, who needed Shinsuusenju to disable Perfect Susanoo, is going to survive a prolonged battle with it and then eventually defeat Madara w/o the use of Shinsuusenju or any of his Mokuton Constructs? Again, you can't even be serious with this nonsense

Again, where did I contradict myself here? All 3 of things have the same point. Hashirama did not use the broken Shinsuusenju, Mokujin and Mokuryu against Madara hence him clearly dismounting them. Madara did not use PS again as Hashirama wouldn't have been able to defeat it without Shinsuusenju, which had already been taken out of commission.

....I said that the Mokuton constructs that were in the panel were not used again hence him leaving them behind. You telling me "No evidence no evidence" over and over again isn't saying anything of use.

....Where did I say he didn't use Susanoo? I simply referred to PS in general, unless that is what you are referring to when you say Susanoo.

-Him dismounting them is evidence enough that he didn't use them.

-The fact that Shinuusenju is necessary to destroy PS is evidence that PS wasn't used after the initial clash, otherwise Madara would have won.

Madara did not defeat and destroy Mokujin, Mokuryu, and Shinsuusenju's remains without PS. Not a chance. All logic points to this being the conclusion. Even if you were correct, it doesn't help prove your stance since Hashirama would have had less difficulty if he had fought Madara w/o Kurama then he would have if he fought Madara w/ Kurama.

Whatever wording you prefer to work with on Sennin Modo issue and yes, naturally we're referring to Madara in his prime at The End Valley as that is the standard to which he is measured. Would make no sense to rival him [Sasuke] against Madara before that point as his then apex of power, mastery over abilities and familiarity with his Sharingan jutsu all remains unknown.

I was referring to EMS Madara w/o Kurama with the post you responded to as the thread itself refers to EMS Madara w/o Kurama. Then you responded saying that the gap between Madara w/o Kurama and Hashirama is very very small, and that's what we are arguing about.
 

Varrah

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 27, 2012
Messages
1,062
Reaction score
293
Uh, Waltz do you want to handle several of the posts here in the thread or should I just make a collective post that tackles them?
 

Waltz

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 6, 2011
Messages
9,979
Reaction score
1,256
KidGamer65 said:
Hashirama did not use the broken Shinsuusenju, Mokujin and Mokuryu against Madara hence him clearly dismounting them. Madara did not use PS again as Hashirama wouldn't have been able to defeat it without Shinsuusenju, which had already been taken out of commission.

-Him dismounting them is evidence enough that he didn't use them.

-The fact that Shinuusenju is necessary to destroy PS is evidence that PS wasn't used after the initial clash, otherwise Madara would have won.

.....

Didn't I say unless you're appealing to ignorance? and yet you employ an Ad Ignorantiam. As if Hashirama and Madara were or appeared exhausted to the extent [in the initial scan] where they couldn't perform jutsu.

KidGamer65 said:
....I said that the Mokuton constructs that were in the panel were not used again hence him leaving them behind. You telling me "No evidence no evidence" over and over again isn't saying anything of use.

....Where did I say he didn't use Susanoo? I simply referred to PS in general, unless that is what you are referring to when you say Susanoo.


@ Underlined: Susano'o is Susano'o. Pay attention to the bold slated Gray:

Waltz said:
You're contradicting yourself. Prior to his battle with Shodai at the valley, Madara was able to battle the Senju [including Hashirama] for a day before exhaustion; highlights the gap in events. I am saying that you have no evidence to support your 'belief' that Madara didn't resurface Susano'o or that Hashirama didn't use Mokuton jutsu between the time gap unless you're appealing to ignorance. Whatever wording you prefer to work with on Sennin Modo issue and yes, naturally we're referring to Madara in his prime at The End Valley as that is the standard to which he is measured. Would make no sense to rival him [Sasuke] against Madara before that point as his then apex of power, mastery over abilities and familiarity with his Sharingan jutsu all remains unknown.

KidGamer65 said:
Madara did not defeat and destroy Mokujin, Mokuryu, and Shinsuusenju's remains without PS. Not a chance. All logic points to this being the conclusion. Even if you were correct, it doesn't help prove your stance since Hashirama would have had less difficulty if he had fought Madara w/o Kurama then he would have if he fought Madara w/ Kurama.

Did I ever say....

....Hmmm, this must be some sort of confabulation.

KidGamer65 said:
I was referring to EMS Madara w/o Kurama with the post you responded to as the thread itself refers to EMS Madara w/o Kurama. Then you responded saying that the gap between Madara w/o Kurama and Hashirama is very very small, and that's what we are arguing about.

Obviously.....

Why? In terms of power this is what we know of Madara prior VoTE and acquiring Kyuubi:

You must be registered for see images
 

Waltz

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Oct 6, 2011
Messages
9,979
Reaction score
1,256
Uh, Waltz do you want to handle several of the posts here in the thread or should I just make a collective post that tackles them?

Meh, about to have dinner, so you may.

You must be registered for see images
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
.....

Didn't I say unless you're appealing to ignorance? and yet you employ an Ad Ignorantiam. As if Hashirama and Madara were or appeared exhausted to the extent [in the initial scan] where they couldn't perform jutsu.

I never said they couldn't employ jutsu at all..or at least I didn't mean to say that they fought without jutsu. My apologies if I did. I just mean they didn't use the things I mentioned.


@ Underlined: Susano'o is Susano'o. Pay attention to the bold slated Gray:

Alright, gotcha/

Did I ever say....

....Hmmm, this must be some sort of confabulation.
Then I fail to see how anything you have been posting up until now helps prove your point.


Obviously.....

Why? In terms of power this is what we know of Madara prior VoTE and acquiring Kyuubi:

You must be registered for see images

..........

Hashirama being the only one who can fight Madara on equal grounds doesn't mean that they are equal, especially considering I doubt he had knowledge of Hashirama's Shinsuusenju considering every time they have fought, the landscape wasn't altered to the extent it was altered at the Valley of the End. Same goes for Hashirama's knowledge on Perfect Susanoo, considering Madara stated "Do you see how much I've changed" and the landscape not being changed that much.

Hashirama being the only one who can fight Madara on equal grounds simply means that no one else can but him, it doesn't mean that Hashirama at his best is equal to Madara at his very best. (Minus Kurama for this comparison)

Madara being equal or having a very small gap in power with Hashirama (again, no Kurama) makes absolutely no sense given that he took on Madara w/ Kurama and still beat him, with very very high difficulty. THAT is a small gap. Now take away Kurama completely. Are you still going to tell me that the gap is very small or that they are roughly equal? That makes no sense, at all. You are relying on one statement that doesn't necessarily prove your point while pretty much everything else in the manga along with common sense shows that you are wrong.
 

Bronze

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
15,769
Reaction score
1,221
I would like to point out, that Madara and Hashirama were fighting to the absolute death:
You must be registered for see images

It wouldn't make any sense for Hashirama to stop using techniques (ones mentioned).
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
I would like to point out, that Madara and Hashirama were fighting to the absolute death:
You must be registered for see images

It wouldn't make any sense for Hashirama to stop using techniques (ones mentioned).

It really does, considering everything he did up until then cost a lot of chakra. Not to mention we have a panel of him abandoning them, so saying he did use them isn't an option.
 

Bronze

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
15,769
Reaction score
1,221
It really does, considering everything he did up until then cost a lot of chakra. Not to mention we have a panel of him abandoning them, so saying he did use them isn't an option.

Both of them used up a lot of chakra. The fact is, none of them showed any fatigue which suggests they weren't tired yet after Kyuubi suppression. We saw them tired when they looked almost dead.

See the difference:
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Look at how fast Madara dodged the hand of the Shinsuusenju. Even after so much chakra, they didn't look that tired.

Now compare it to here:
You must be registered for see images

You can see in ^ scan, they almost look they're gonna die. From that scan, we can safely assume, that they were fighting for a very long time after Kurama suppression. Shinobi cant get tired to that level, unless they have used big jutsu.

Bold is pure assumption. You lack the proof and panels to show he hadn't used them after jumping. Don't say he jumped, cuz that's not strong evidence that stopped using them. A lot of ninjas jump off their summoning animals. That doesn't mean they stopped using them.

The thing is, you and me can argue like this forever based on our assumption. That leads to a pointless discussion. The only way to know who is right is either wait until manga shows all off panels during their fight, or we make a poll and see what people think.
 

DemonicAvenger

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
3,254
Reaction score
271
@Waltz & KidGamer

Just my 2 cents, but EMS Madara alone is enough to stalemate even Senin Mode Hashirama all the way up to Shinsuusenju, which is where he becomes outmatched. I wouldn't find it to be far fetched to say that they at least continued to use Mangekyo and Mokuton Techs respectively.
 

slimreaper

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
8,416
Reaction score
499
you idiots saying sasuke doesn't have tsukuyomi but clearly he does.

every time tsukuyomi is used the black and white color is reversed

You must be registered for see images

notice how it differs from sasuke's sharingan genjutsu

more examples

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images


now notice when sasuke puts bee in genjutsu the color change

You must be registered for see images

sasuke has tsukuyomi it is indisputable. further proof is sasuke holding his eye. why would he hold his eye if using a regular genjutsu?
 

DemonicAvenger

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
3,254
Reaction score
271
you idiots saying sasuke doesn't have tsukuyomi but clearly he does.

every time tsukuyomi is used the black and white color is reversed

You must be registered for see images

notice how it differs from sasuke's sharingan genjutsu

more examples

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images


now notice when sasuke puts bee in genjutsu the color change

You must be registered for see images

sasuke has tsukuyomi it is indisputable. further proof is sasuke holding his eye. why would he hold his eye if using a regular genjutsu?

Danzo makes it seem that the time displacement is an attribute specific to Itachi's. Your probably right, as in Sasuke's being a Tsukiyomi without time displacement.
 

Gakido

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
May 3, 2013
Messages
1,234
Reaction score
61
Sasuke would win with Very-High Diff IMO
 

adeshina365

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
4,667
Reaction score
485
Danzo makes it seem that the time displacement is an attribute specific to Itachi's. Your probably right, as in Sasuke's being a Tsukiyomi without time displacement.
I've thought about it for a while and this is the conclusion that I've come to as well.

Sasuke's use of "sharingan genjutsu" against (to help) Itachi can be attributed to his Tsukuyomi not being any where near as potent, leading him to conserve his chakra.

This is the only conclusion that I've come to that makes some sense.
 

BlackFlame44

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
4,181
Reaction score
167
So far in the manga only itachi has had tsukuyomi anything otherwise is speculation
 

DemonicAvenger

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2012
Messages
3,254
Reaction score
271
I've thought about it for a while and this is the conclusion that I've come to as well.

Sasuke's use of "sharingan genjutsu" against (to help) Itachi can be attributed to his Tsukuyomi not being any where near as potent, leading him to conserve his chakra.

This is the only conclusion that I've come to that makes some sense.

More than likely. In the same fashion that Itachi can manipulate Amaterasu after it has been cast but Enton is something that only Sasuke's Amaterasu was privy of.
 
Last edited:
Top