[Discussion] Rank the Fairy Tail Guild members in terms of strength.

[Pure Logic]

1) Gildarts - He's obviously the strongest in the guild at the moment.
2) Laxus - He's catching up to Gildarts.
3) Natsu - We've yet to see Natsu go all out or even enter Dragon Force mode yet and when he does I think he'd either be just as strong as Laxus or just a little weaker.
4) Erza - I think if Natsu went all out and battled her seriously he would beat her.
5) Makarov - Not quite as strong as Natsu or Erza now but he's not far off.
6) Gajeel - Just seems right to place him here.
7) Gray - Same reason as Gajeel.
8) Mirajane - Even though she's classed as an S Rank she's lost what she used to be.
9) Elfman - He's seriously underestimated.
10) Juvia - I have no reason.

I'm not going to put Lucy in as frankly I don't view her strong enough to put her in the top 10.

Indeed Natsu, Laxus and Gildart are super strong. Makarov, is a wizard saint and to top that off he's 80+, Gotta give the man some credit here, Hades made him a play toy, but Hades use the shock to his advantage and lets not forget he was Makarov's teacher, and the guild master before him. Also Hades was using Zerefs Dark Magic to power himself up. He was also immortal due to the heart. You guys are seriously underestimating Makarov. Gildarts... We seriously haven't seen him go all out also. Laxus, he's still young, but smart and has potential... Natsu's greatest power is willpower, and he's one of the main male character's along side Gray, and Lucy and Erza are the main female characters. With the revel of Silver, "My hunch was correct so far" We're going to see Gray's overall abilities improve to a point where he can rival Natsu.

 

[Cosmicstars]

1) Gildarts - He's obviously the strongest in the guild at the moment.
2) Laxus - He's catching up to Gildarts.
3) Natsu - We've yet to see Natsu go all out or even enter Dragon Force mode yet and when he does I think he'd either be just as strong as Laxus or just a little weaker.
4) Erza - I think if Natsu went all out and battled her seriously he would beat her.
5) Makarov - Not quite as strong as Natsu or Erza now but he's not far off.
6) Gajeel - Just seems right to place him here.
7) Gray - Same reason as Gajeel.
8) Mirajane - Even though she's classed as an S Rank she's lost what she used to be.
9) Elfman - He's seriously underestimated.
10) Juvia - I have no reason.

I'm not going to put Lucy in as frankly I don't view her strong enough to put her in the top 10.

Natsu and Erza is strong but not strong enough to surpass Makarov. Makarov is someone who can enter titan mode and cast Fairy Law those 2 things alone at least but him above Erza and Natsu. Natsu has entered DF and went all out every enemy he has faced that is worth mentioning. Gajeel and Gray being above Mirajane is a little to much too. They are close to her strength but I feel they have still yet to surpass her. Elfman and Juvia are strong also but Lucy and Freed are a little stronger. Freed clearly his forbidden demon forms and runes are pretty strong. Lucy's Urano Metria and Leo Regulus impact are pretty powerful too.

Your first 2 is good but after that it is like O_O. But yea your list isn't bad but the order is kinda like okay but I respect your opinion I would just order them differently.

 

[Pure Logic]

I'm going to use a Dragonball Z as an example.... Natsu is like Goku.... Gajeel is like Vegeta, and Gray is Piccolo. in beginning in the Series, Gray and Natsu were close in power, but Natsu improve WAY over him Gray... but I have a feeling that Gray is going to pull a power-up soon... kinda like how Piccolo and Kami fused together. Gray isn't going to fuse with someone... he's going to find a way to get stronger. Gajeel... is a Vegeta type character... he's going to stay as close as possible to Natsu's level.

 

[TheHokage]

Natsu and Erza is strong but not strong enough to surpass Makarov. Makarov is someone who can enter titan mode and cast Fairy Law those 2 things alone at least but him above Erza and Natsu. Natsu has entered DF and went all out every enemy he has faced that is worth mentioning. Gajeel and Gray being above Mirajane is a little to much too. They are close to her strength but I feel they have still yet to surpass her. Elfman and Juvia are strong also but Lucy and Freed are a little stronger. Freed clearly his forbidden demon forms and runes are pretty strong. Lucy's Urano Metria and Leo Regulus impact are pretty powerful too.

Your first 2 is good but after that it is like O_O. But yea your list isn't bad but the order is kinda like okay but I respect your opinion I would just order them differently.

I feel like even though Makarov is strong I'm not going to deny that but if...for instance Natsu went all out with Dragon force remember his dragon force will be nothing like Sting and Rouge's half cooked versions Natsu's is actually badass I think he would defeat Makarov as in that type of situation even if Makarov became bigger he wouldn't be able to keep up with Natsu's speed in Dragon Force not to mention Makarov is getting old now.

With your Gajeel and Gray being weaker than Mirajane I'm not certain to be honest I view them two as people who are not to far away from Natsu but it could go either way so Mirajane could be stronger but hey that's just my opinion.

Indeed Natsu, Laxus and Gildart are super strong. Makarov, is a wizard saint and to top that off he's 80+, Gotta give the man some credit here, Hades made him a play toy, but Hades use the shock to his advantage and lets not forget he was Makarov's teacher, and the guild master before him. Also Hades was using Zerefs Dark Magic to power himself up. He was also immortal due to the heart. You guys are seriously underestimating Makarov. Gildarts... We seriously haven't seen him go all out also. Laxus, he's still young, but smart and has potential... Natsu's greatest power is willpower, and he's one of the main male character's along side Gray, and Lucy and Erza are the main female characters. With the revel of Silver, "My hunch was correct so far" We're going to see Gray's overall abilities improve to a point where he can rival Natsu.

Well with Gildarts I just assume he's the strongest because he was able to survive by himself against Acnologia and he was even fighting it when it wasn't playing around...I think in strength Gildarts is probably as strong as the 4 saints that are called monsters.

 

[Pure Logic]

Gildarts is indeed strong, but I have a feeling the TOP 4 Are Way OP, and I have a feeling Natsu is going to be trained by one.

 

[dario14]

gildarts

laxus/natsu (serious angry only base in top 5)

makarov

erza

grey/gajeel (can pick one)

 

[evilmanofdoom]

natsu is so OP

seriously its not even funny

 

[cajin]

1. Gildarts
2. Laxus Dreyar/Makarov
3. Natsu Dragneel
4. Erza Scarlet
5. Mirajane
6. Gray Fullbuster
7. Gajeel
8. Elfman
9. Juvia
10. Lucy