Sakura is bad medic you say ?

[hyi]

Naruto doesn't HEAL for god sake

I have seen a lot of people saying naruto >sakura in healing i mean wtf
Shikamaru was saved by (healing/will power/chakra transfer ) he was saved by naruto the most but sakura played an important role in it she kept him alive.and tsunade finished the rest.

First Shikamaru was not wounded nor sick .

He got all his chakra sucked by that form of jubbi .

Normally when ALL the human chakra fade away the human die but shikamaru was alive because he had naruto's chakra around him

What naruto did . is giving/handing chakra to shikamaru and by that he helped him to survive (apparently naruto did that because his will power *to not give up and not let a friend die etc)

So that stupid statement
Naruto > sakura at healing .is false
it's
Naruto>sakura at transferring chakra .

Second : Sakura CAN transfer chakra through katsuyu pieces .
And transfer chakra to everyone and heal them but ironically katsuyu pieces died by the tree .

You must be registered for see images

She could save shikamaru if katsuyu pieces did not sucked by the tree and died . {its plot she didn't do it not that sakura doesn't know how to or can't do it} .

Third : sakura did help at healing shikamaru without her he would be dead before naruto help.so she wasn't "useless" .
She kept him alive even though he had no chakra .(he should be dead but with HEALING) with her own chakra she kept his heart beating . (thats a medic ninjutsu right there).

Fourth : Sakura was one of the people who her chakra was sucked out but she stood up and continued healing .

You must be registered for see images

Though She is different from the others who got there chakra sucked sakura have stored chakra in her forehead and that chakra in a seal so the tree could not suck that out which kept sakura alive .

If naruto by any means better than sakura at healing (which is not)

Than he should healed himself

At

You must be registered for see images

he should have healed kakashi

You must be registered for see images

naruto simply give his chakra to power up /shield or to recover loss of chakra or just to rise stamina .
In shikamaru situation Its like theres a patient theres a donator and theres a doctor .
both are important .
But You are telling the doctor he is useless at his job and the patient is alive only BECAUSE of the donator .


________

And the worst is people who say she sucks at medic ninjutsu

Sakura was impressive and she is the best medical ninja after tsunade wether you like it or not .

You must be registered for see images

HEALING all those shinobi's in seconds is something only sakura and tsunade can do .

That's why

You must be registered for see images

 

[-Punk-]

Shikkamaru was on the verge of dying , Sakura couldn't help him & Naruto saved him because of his feelings then Tsunade healed him .

 

[scorezor]

calm down please..... don't play their game... (yeah i know that's too late :/ ).

 

[Tingun]

Kabuto is better than her.

 

[hyi]

Shikkamaru was on the verge of dying , Sakura couldn't help him & Naruto saved him because of his feelings then Tsunade healed him .

The three of them helped him as cheesy this is sound naruto feelings helped him yes but that doesnt imply what sakura did wasn't helpful like i said she kept him alive before naruto and tsunade help.

 

[hyi]

Kabuto is better than her.

That could be true but its a matter of opinion between kabuto and sakura

Kabuto cant heal all those people in seconds like sakura and sakura cant do some of kabuto techs

For me healing 4,000 shinobi in seconds is very good thats why i put her second after tsunade last chapter situation was because katsuyu

 

[Tingun]

That could be true but its a matter of opnion between kabuto and sakura

Kabuto cant heal all this people in seconds like sakura and sakura cant do some of kabuto techs

For me healing 4,000 shinobi in seconds is very good thats why i put her second after tsunade last chapter situation was because katsuyu

Kabuto does not need mass healing to be a better medical ninja. Kabuto is so advanced that he was noted in part 1 to possibly surpass even tsunade in her prime. His understanding of the human body so intricate that he was able to personally infuse his own cells and even those of madara and hashirama's cells. He was able to heal without having close contact and was able to pinpoint vital nerves without any chakra exposing jutsu.

 

[hyi]

Kabuto does not need mass healing to be a better medical ninja. Kabuto is so advanced that he was noted in part 1 to possibly surpass even tsunade in her prime.

Like i said its matter of opinion . He is the third best medic for me .

Sakura also noted to surpass tsunade few times

 

[Filo]

tsunade did acknowledge that she did well

 

[Οdin]

Hashirama surpasses all.

 

[fayeon]

Well said .


Who ever said she is bad medic is just hating she is def one of top 3 in medical ninjutsu

Some of Sakura haters will even argue with kishimoto if he say she is good medic or have medic skills

 

[Troyg39]

Seriously....

Let me make sure I'm following your train of logic.....

1. Shikamaru was not wounded or sick: So you are saying that he was simply out of chakra and that that's all he needed correct? Since he wasn't wounded or sick as you say, he didn't need "healing" but only chakra

2. Shikamaru was alive because he had Naruto's chakra: So you are saying that what kept him alive was Naruto's chakra.

You do realize that means Sakura played no role in keeping him alive. According to you, he wasn't sick nor wounded (which is false btw, he's suffered injuries and visible scars over the course of the war) so chakra was the only thing that made him better, which he got from Naruto, not Sakura, again according to you

You guys seriously have to stop making these threads. I get you want to defend her but you make her look worse everytime with your arguments. She did what she could to try and heal him as best she could, unfortunately for her what Shikamaru needed more than anything was chakra, something she couldn't give him. She, along with Naruto and Tsunade healed him. Chakra recovery is apart of the healing process, without it Shikamaru wouldn't have recovered, even if his physical wounds did

 

[fayeon]

Seriously....

Let me make sure I'm following your train of logic.....

1. Shikamaru was not wounded or sick: So you are saying that he was simply out of chakra and that that's all he needed correct? Since he wasn't wounded or sick as you say, he didn't need "healing" but only chakra

2. Shikamaru was alive because he had Naruto's chakra: So you are saying that what kept him alive was Naruto's chakra.

You do realize that means Sakura played no role in keeping him alive. According to you, he wasn't sick nor wounded (which is false btw, he's suffered injuries and visible scars over the course of the war) so chakra was the only thing that made him better, which he got from Naruto, not Sakura, again according to you

You guys seriously have to stop making these threads. I get you want to defend her but you make her look worse everytime with your arguments. She did what she could to try and heal him as best she could, unfortunately for her what Shikamaru needed more than anything was chakra, something she couldn't give him. She, along with Naruto and Tsunade healed him. Chakra recovery is apart of the healing process, without it Shikamaru wouldn't have recovered, even if his physical wounds did

Before naruto help shikamaru sakura was keeping him alive when a person lose chakra they die when a person about to die they stop breathing and there heart beat stops but sakura was keeping him alive for the moment using healing (making his heart beat giving a some recovery chakra etc)
So sakura played a big role in keeping him alive before tsunade and naruto do it . Without her he would be long dead .

 

[Tingun]

Before naruto help shikamaru sakura was keeping him alive when a person lose chakra they die when a person about to die they stop breathing and there heart beat stops but sakura was keeping him alive for the moment using healing (making his heart beat giving a some recovery chakra etc)
So sakura played a big role in keeping him alive before tsunade and naruto do it . Without her he would be long dead .

She was keeping him alive with the aid of naruto's already existing cloak.

 

[fayeon]

She was keeping him alive with the aid of naruto's already existing cloak.

Yes but my point and OP point is without her he would be dead
Os she was helpful
naruto cloack was used as a shield in the start but than naruto without realizing replaced his chakra with shikamaru chakra

 

[Troyg39]

Before naruto help shikamaru sakura was keeping him alive when a person lose chakra they die but sakura was keeping him alive for the moment using healing (making his heart beat giving a some recovery chakra etc)
So sakura played a big role in keeping him alive before tsunade and naruto do it . Without her he would be long dead .

Let me get this straight, when a person runs completely out of chakra they die.....hmm interesting.

So clearly Shikamaru wasn't completely out of chakra then was he? Because if he were, he would've died before Sakura had ever gotten to him. I mean did you not notice the countless other DEAD ninja who had ALL of their chakra drained? The tree had stopped sucking his chakra, so he was no longer at risk of losing it all. He had just enough to hold on for a bit longer. She didn't keep him alive by giving him chakra. He had enough chakra left to stay alive for a bit longer. Sakura didn't give him chakra. She tried to do her normal medical jutsu where she heals physical wounds.

You and the thread maker saying that she gave him chakra to keep him alive is a poor attempt to give her more credit than she deserves for this particular incident. She's a great medic just leave it at that. You make people want to hate her when you overrate every scenario she's in.

 

[Tingun]

Yes but my point and OP point is without her he would be dead
Os she was helpful
naruto cloack was used as a shield in the start but than naruto without realizing replaced his chakra with shikamaru chakra

He could have survived, who's to say naruto couldn't have willed someone else's nearby cloak to do exactly what sakura's did.

 

[fayeon]

Let me get this straight, when a person runs completely out of chakra they die.....hmm interesting.

So clearly Shikamaru wasn't completely out of chakra then was he? Because if he were, he would've died before Sakura had ever gotten to him. I mean did you not notice the countless other DEAD ninja who had ALL of their chakra drained? The tree had stopped sucking his chakra, so he was no longer at risk of losing it all. He had just enough to hold on for a bit longer. She didn't keep him alive by giving him chakra. He had enough chakra left to stay alive for a bit longer. Sakura didn't give him chakra. She tried to do her normal medical jutsu where she heals physical wounds.

You and the thread maker saying that she gave him chakra to keep him alive is a poor attempt to give her more credit than she deserves for this particular incident. She's a great medic just leave it at that. You make people want to hate her when you overrate every scenario she's in.

I dont know why this is overrating.

Sakura was helpful to him shikamaru was alive because the naruto cloack .those who died there chakra and naruto's got sucked already.

For shikamaru choji might helped him .
Shikamru might have some of his chakra but he was losing it even if the tree wasnt sucking him anymore he was losing chakra and stamina .

Sakura was not VERY helpful but she was keeping him alive

She kept healing him for 2 chapters if she did not and he left alone all that time without healing waiting for naruto's help he would die .

Why would ino thank sakura is she did not help him ? I am not overrating anything theres mothing proves what sakura did was useless .

And her healing is not only for wounds .

When she healed naruto she said" i will restore naruto chakra and give him full recovery "

So she was doing the same for shika

 

[SpiderRider89]

Seriously....

Let me make sure I'm following your train of logic.....

1. Shikamaru was not wounded or sick: So you are saying that he was simply out of chakra and that that's all he needed correct? Since he wasn't wounded or sick as you say, he didn't need "healing" but only chakra

2. Shikamaru was alive because he had Naruto's chakra: So you are saying that what kept him alive was Naruto's chakra.

You do realize that means Sakura played no role in keeping him alive. According to you, he wasn't sick nor wounded (which is false btw, he's suffered injuries and visible scars over the course of the war) so chakra was the only thing that made him better, which he got from Naruto, not Sakura, again according to you

You guys seriously have to stop making these threads. I get you want to defend her but you make her look worse everytime with your arguments. She did what she could to try and heal him as best she could, unfortunately for her what Shikamaru needed more than anything was chakra, something she couldn't give him. She, along with Naruto and Tsunade healed him. Chakra recovery is apart of the healing process, without it Shikamaru wouldn't have recovered, even if his physical wounds did

Sakura's role wasn't to make him better but to keep him alive. Without her he would have been dead. Her medical jutsu was what kept him alive.

 

[fayeon]

He could have survived, who's to say naruto couldn't have willed someone else's nearby cloak to do exactly what sakura's did.

Ok if naruto can do it alone than why there was still people dying ? Even before naruto sucked by the god tree . The people was dying with naruto cloack .

Naruto wasnt aware what he did in this chapter so why wouldn't he do that with everyone without awareness too

Shukamru had extra help it was sakura