the bolded part of your post is the most dumb argument usually used by those who have no logic when going against a possible rinnegan for naruto. It is true that this thread is a theory, but it is also true that all eye-body concept defenders never learned from the manga.
rikudo sennin was one guy who unlocked rinnegan without the existence of uchiha or senju. He was a geniune rinnegan wielder because of shinju/juubi power his mother ate or after becoming juubi jinchuriki. this prove that one can obtain rinnegan if he has the same power that rikudo had.
It turns out that naruto is compared to rikudo by the biju, plus naruto was given power by the bijus. In addition, it appears that juubi saw rinnegan cloak in naruto. If juubi and shinju are the same, then you can understand that all the biju's chakra put together will get closed to shinju/juubi power. this intel suggest themselves that naruto has power closer or maybe equal to what rikudo had at birth.
moreover, the analogy is so closed that while rikudo mother ate the fruit, naruto's mother was a jinchuriki of kyuubi. Both the fruit and kyuubi are chakra masses from the shinju tree. thus, with a clear mind, it appears that naruto is not only similar to rikudo in the will, but he exactly has the same power that rikudo had. According to previous chapter, naruto's birthday will be a major turn in the series.
finally, i will conclude to say that your no rinnegan without sharingan argument is true for a mere senju, and vice versa for an uchiha. however, for someone who has the initial root of the rinnegan as rikudo has, he is the source of sharingan and mokuton. Thus, naruto having the power of the bijus, and being hinted to be related to rikudo give a lot of chance of him unlocking rikudo's jutsus. here are what you need to know:
1. Rikudo's jutsu used by naruto on kyuubi
You must be registered for see images
as you can see, ever kyuubi think naruto is using rikudo's juts, or he thought an instant that naruto was rikudo. Not only the juts nerfed kyuubi, but it cancelled his bijudama. This is what i think will be naruto's trump card against juubi.
2.naruto got power from the bijus
You must be registered for see images
3. Naruto controlling chakra he sealed in sa shinobi to dodge or block the storm caused by juubi.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
as you can see in the first image, and sakura's statement in the second, the chakra was what protected the sa. The only thing sakura missed is that the chakra had no mind. Rather, naruto was the one controlling his chakra from above them. this is exactly what nagato was doing with his paths of pain. the only difference is that naruto can do it without chakra rod. Rather, he can seal his chakra directly in the shinobi. And if you still think that naruto cannot transmit chakra wherever he has already sealed a trace of his own chakra, look here:
You must be registered for see images
basically, tobirama explained the whole process and how naruto transmitted minato's chakra to everyone using a trace of his previous chakra in them. You can even see how the chakra naruto gave them increased without him touching them. This tell you that naruto can transmit chakra to anyone if he has already sealed his chakra in them.
4. Finally, naruto's chakra did not convey his feeling to individuals.
You must be registered for see images
rather, naruto transmitted his heart only to ino, then it was transferred to other people through ino's jutsu. Thus, unlike hashirama who needed to touch ino, naruto can convey his feeling to anyone who possesses his chakra. Actually, saying that it is naruto's heart is really kishi's way of masking the facts to ignorant people. From the comment of each individual, we can see that they could know exactly what naruto wanted them to see.
Another evidence that ino was the one transmitted what she received from naruto is tsunade and the others who do not have naruto's chakra. Thus, the techniques naruto used was not the same as chakra transmission. Instead, he transmitted intel to ino over the chakra link that exists between him and her. basically, naruto is doing the same think nagato was doing with his paths. Whenever one path was talking, it was nagato talking through the chakra link between them. In fact, if naruto can put intel in ino's mind, then he can also read intel from ino's mind. Basically, naruto has shared memory with anyone, meaning shared vision as well.
--- to the op --
i am the one who created this theory on another forums. You should have given me credit. You used a part of my theory, and add some other material from nagato's story. Well, nicely done, but don't expect sasuke's fandom to even process the intel.
so youre arguing that naruto doesnt need a sharingan to get rinnegan, he doesnt even need rinnegan to use rinnegan abilities, and that even though when communicating to everyone telepathically through ino is when he can transfer his feelings and thoughts, its not the mind transfer jutsu doing it, its just naruto sending his feelings to everyone through chakra. Because he has no rinnegan required rinnegan. And that pain controlled the dead bodies not through controlling thier movements with chakra rods, but by sending them his thoughts with his chakra cloak, that really how rinnegan works. Sounds legit.
when did he tell u dont need rinnengan to use rinnengan abilities..it was just said he was going closer towards rinnengan..and he showed a similar ability to dat of rinnengan's outer path!!
how can you be so sure that hachibi has so low chakra as compared to kyubi.....if you are saying on the basis on number of tails thatn you are completely wrong because hachibi denied the fact that the power of the bijus could be compared through their number of tails...
doubt naruto gets rinnegan because the villains have it.
Naruto beating them using his owns powers with sage mode and fox mode will be a start of new era that has suppassed the old one being the rinngean with hasihrama+sharingan dna.Ie the so6p himself.
Also worth noting this transfer thing happened while naruto was in fox + sage mode.
its mostly likely a side affect of this mode. we know nothing about it.
doubt naruto gets rinnegan because the villains have it.
Naruto beating them using his owns powers with sage mode and fox mode will be a start of new era that has suppassed the old one being the rinngean with hasihrama+sharingan dna.ie the so6p himself.
Also worth noting this transfer thing happened while naruto was in fox + sage mode.
Its mostly likely a side affect of this mode. We know nothing about it.
