[Theory] Karin - stronger medic than Tsunade and Sakura ?

[RinneBlitz]

The last chapter confirms it that Karin is the only one who can save Shikamaru. Don't ya think? Shikamaru's situation is almost identical to Tsunade's, with the difference that in Tsunade's case, Suigetsu's help was necessary to attach her body. Now, Shikamaru just needs to bite Karin and recover his chakra, something which Tsunade, nor Sakura can offer.

Look at this page:

You must be registered for see images

Karin's thoughts prove that she's the only one who can save Shikamaru in NV, alongside the plot of course. She thought that her youth can be sucked off if Tsunade keeps sucking that much CHAKRA, which means that Karin transfers her chakra to Tsunade. Due to Karin's Uzumaki blood, she has a lot chakra level for sure and healing Shikamaru won't be a problem for her, not after she healed that heavily injured Tsunade. In the latest chapter, Suigetsu told her that healing the Alliance comes in first place, so I guess that she'll heal Shikamaru (by transfering him her chakra, something that Tsunade and Sakura can't do) in the next chapter. Which makes me think that she's stronger than them by her own, unique way.

Oh, and by the way, what do you think Karin and Sakura can do as a medic team? For me it will be very strong team, Sakura to heal the physical damage, and Karin to heal the spiritual (to give chakra). Pretty good, your thoughts?

 

[Crossroads]

Uzumaki > Senju

If Karin could utilize her medical Jutsu to cover a wider variety of people with minimal setbacks to her chakra.. Karin might = Tsunade.

But she's a disgusting character, I dislike her.

 

[foxyladyland]

Tsunade's the best so far. Karin or Sakura gets ripped in half and most likely dies.
HInata however, can actually see inside the body *byakugan* and see better what the illness or is ailments are.
Tsunade's jutsu was still healing after her body was severed . Karin almost died letting Sasuke bite her vs BEE.
Sakura was still healing herself while Sasori was stabbing her. Hinata doesn't heal while she is under attack.

 

[Crossroads]

Tsunade's the best so far. Karin or Sakura gets ripped in half and most likely dies.
HInata however, can actually see inside the body *byakugan* and see better what the illness or is ailments are.
Tsunade's jutsu was still healing after her body was severed . Karin almost died letting Sasuke bite her vs BEE.
Sakura was still healing herself while Sasori was stabbing her. Hinata doesn't heal while she is under attack.

The OP is mainly going by how the Medical Ninja can heal others, not heal themself. Which Karin >= Tsunade in.

Because really, Naruto and Hashirama have better means of recovery than Tsunade. (Isn't the best in that category)

 

[Ōkami]

Be careful. You don't want to upset their five fans.

 

[Crossroads]

Be careful. You don't want to upset their five fans.

All 5 rival the entire Itachi fanbase.

 

[Cosman]

Be careful. You don't want to upset their five fans.

Tsunade's fans are far too noisy to only be 5...

OT: Karin has some cool medical abilities, but in the realms of disease and poison I don't know what she can do.

But she's thirstier than them both, that's for sure. Karin wants dat ass

You must be registered for see images

 

[tyresellers]

Didn't Naruto just flame up everyone's chakra. Shikamaru was dying from having his chakra stolen and if you look at the images all the fodder were again covered in nine tails chakra.

 

[AGoodBoy]

She's a stronger medic but not a better one.

 

[Child Of The Great Empire]

Karin is a great character! =D
She is a good medic.

 

[foxyladyland]

The OP is mainly going by how the Medical Ninja can heal others, not heal themself. Which Karin >= Tsunade in.

Because really, Naruto and Hashirama have better means of recovery than Tsunade.

Well, Karin's method of healing is easier. She just lets you feed off of her . Tsunade on the other hand revived Sasuke and Kakashi from the trauma of the Tsukuyomi . Its different than breaking someone from genjutsu because all you would have had to do was disrupt their chakra . Karin is a sensor so she can sense when someone is in genjutsu by their chakra disruption. So since the Sasuke & Kakashi weren't in the genjutsu , but rather some sort of coma, Karin wouldn't be able to just give them her chakra for them to wake up. Tsunade had to use some other complete method to awaken them. :] idk effortlessly.. Karin would've been drained after 3 or 4 bites. She's getting a lot better though. :]

 

[paratise]

Karin just make people recover their wounds; it does not related to her overall skillset and knowledge it is what she have in geness she is basicly a walking charger in other words.

However Tsunade and Sakura are different; their healing prowess relies on their knowledge on medical field and skillset in chakra control. Karin can't make an autopsy, examination on disesae, surgery, antidote etc; things what a medic suppose to do. Not to mention she haven't shown to heal herself unlike two others; she is a quick medicine for another.

That's how i see: Comparing Karin with Tsunade/Sakura is like comparing a single accumulator with a mechanic with full equipment.

 

[Crossroads]

Well, Karin's method of healing is easier. She just lets you feed off of her . Tsunade on the other hand revived Sasuke and Kakashi from the trauma of the Tsukuyomi . Its different than breaking someone from genjutsu because all you would have had to do was disrupt their chakra . Karin is a sensor so she can sense when someone is in genjutsu by their chakra disruption. So since the Sasuke & Kakashi weren't in the genjutsu , but rather some sort of coma, Karin wouldn't be able to just give them her chakra for them to wake up. Tsunade had to use some other complete method to awaken them. :] idk effortlessly.. Karin would've been drained after 3 or 4 bites. She's getting a lot better though. :]

I'd give this a well thought out reply, but caterpillar and AGoodBoy cleaned up the thread.

 

[Fecal Matter]

Karin is a great character! =D

Surely you jest.​

 

[Bimbonium]

Karin just make people recover their wounds; it does not related to her overall skillset and knowledge it is what she have in geness she is basicly a walking charger in other words.

However Tsunade and Sakura are different; their healing prowess relies on their knowledge on medical field and skillset in chakra control. Karin can't make an autopsy, examination on disesae, surgery, antidote etc; things what a medic suppose to do. Not to mention she haven't shown to heal herself unlike two others; she is a quick medicine for another.

That's how i see: Comparing Karin with Tsunade/Sakura is like comparing a single accumulator with a mechanic with full equipment.

Nice reply, the comparison is flawless.

 

[KingHashirama]

Karin is a fodder compared to Kabuto/Tsunade/Sakura in regards to medical ninjutsu.

Just because she has the power to heal doesn't make her a better medical ninja.. Otherwise Kimimaro sh*ts on her due to his bone regeneration.


Also another problem is Sakura and Tsunade don't need people to bite them... not to mention Tsunade who can live with her body split apart..

 

[NinjutsuSeeker]

The last chapter confirms it that Karin is the only one who can save Shikamaru. Don't ya think? Shikamaru's situation is almost identical to Tsunade's, with the difference that in Tsunade's case, Suigetsu's help was necessary to attach her body. Now, Shikamaru just needs to bite Karin and recover his chakra, something which Tsunade, nor Sakura can offer.

Look at this page:

You must be registered for see images

Karin's thoughts prove that she's the only one who can save Shikamaru in NV, alongside the plot of course. She thought that her youth can be sucked off if Tsunade keeps sucking that much CHAKRA, which means that Karin transfers her chakra to Tsunade. Due to Karin's Uzumaki blood, she has a lot chakra level for sure and healing Shikamaru won't be a problem for her, not after she healed that heavily injured Tsunade. In the latest chapter, Suigetsu told her that healing the Alliance comes in first place, so I guess that she'll heal Shikamaru (by transfering him her chakra, something that Tsunade and Sakura can't do) in the next chapter. Which makes me think that she's stronger than them by her own, unique way.

Oh, and by the way, what do you think Karin and Sakura can do as a medic team? For me it will be very strong team, Sakura to heal the physical damage, and Karin to heal the spiritual (to give chakra). Pretty good, your thoughts?

well...I wont say she is a better medic than sakura and tsunade...that is Ludacris, but anyway, a tag teamwith her and sakura, yes, very good medic team. Although Karin can heal massive ammounts of damage to one person, sakura can heal an entire army...so..yyeaaaaa

 

[TheEvilOne]

In healing a single person Karin is definitely better, however in healing an army/village Tsunade and Sakura have no contest.

 

[KingHashirama]

In healing a single person Karin is definitely better, however in healing an army/village Tsunade and Sakura have no contest.

o-o I doubt she can heal a brain damage.. o-o

 

[H a n]

Naw. I don't see her being better then Tsunade. She can't heal herself yet so how in the world could she even be better then Sakura.